{"ontologies":{"OPTIMADE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.optimade.org/ontology/materials-databases/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://www.optimade.org/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"OPTIMADE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/Materials-Consortia/ontology","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/Materials-Consortia/ontology/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology for materials database interoperability, structure-classification, simulation models, and physical properties.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Materials-Consortia/ontology/master/materials-databases/materials-databases.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Materials Databases Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"9","omv:numberOfProperties":"1","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPTIMADE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T17:16:51.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.1038/s41524-020-00407-z\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OPTIMADE&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Ontology for Materials Databases\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPTIMADE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPTIMADE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPTIMADE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OPTIMADE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPTIMADE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPTIMADE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/OPTIMADE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"7"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.optimade.org/ontology/materials-databases/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.optimade.org/ontology/materials-databases/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPTIMADE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/MIT.html","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/MIT.html"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Rickard Armiento"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPTIMADE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/nfdimatwerk]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5362},"DPP-COMP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-comp/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-comp/0.1/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPPO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DPP-COMP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-comp/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPPO","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Submodule ontology representing components and materials assemblies inside a Digital Product Passport (DPP)., This is an ontology module focusing on the composition information of products.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/LiUSemWeb/DPPO/dev/ontology/dpp-comp/0.1/dpp-comp.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Digital Product Passport Components Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"24","omv:numberOfProperties":"22","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"dpp-comp","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-COMP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:10:42.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2023-11-27T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DPP-COMP&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-COMP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-COMP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-COMP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DPP-COMP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-COMP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-COMP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DPP-COMP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"7"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-comp/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-comp/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-core/, http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-odp/, http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-info/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-core/, http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-odp/, http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-info/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-COMP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPP/blob/master/LICENSE","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"3"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPP/blob/master/LICENSE"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"LiU SemWeb team"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Maike Jansen\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/630206a0-49b6-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/630206a0-49b6-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Huanyu Li\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ee97be10-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ee97be10-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Eva Blomqvist\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/63a324c0-49b6-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/63a324c0-49b6-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Robin Keskisärkkä\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/63c97640-49b6-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/63c97640-49b6-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-COMP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":250.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7041},"DPP-INFO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-info/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-info/0.1/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPPO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DPP-INFO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-info/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPPO","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Submodule ontology representing informational metadata properties of a Digital Product Passport (DPP)., This is a minimal core ontology describing DPP information types.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/LiUSemWeb/DPPO/dev/ontology/dpp-info/0.1/dpp-info.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Digital Product Passport Information Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"12","omv:numberOfProperties":"18","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"dpp-info","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-INFO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:10:43.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2023-10-30T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DPP-INFO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-INFO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-INFO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-INFO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DPP-INFO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-INFO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-INFO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DPP-INFO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"7"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-info/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-info/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-odp/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-odp/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-INFO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPP/blob/master/LICENSE","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPP/blob/master/LICENSE"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"LiU SemWeb team"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Maike Jansen\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/630206a0-49b6-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/630206a0-49b6-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Huanyu Li\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ee97be10-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ee97be10-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Eva Blomqvist\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/63a324c0-49b6-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/63a324c0-49b6-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Robin Keskisärkkä\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/63c97640-49b6-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/63c97640-49b6-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-INFO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":250.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6970},"DPP-PROV":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-prov/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-prov/0.1/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPPO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DPP-PROV","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-prov/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPPO","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Submodule ontology representing provenance and lifecycle event tracking inside a Digital Product Passport (DPP)., Provenance information for DPP information.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/LiUSemWeb/DPPO/dev/ontology/dpp-prov/0.1/dpp-prov.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Digital Product Passport Provenance Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"16","omv:numberOfProperties":"24","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"dpp-prov","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-PROV/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:10:44.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2023-11-27T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DPP-PROV&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-PROV/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-PROV/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-PROV/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DPP-PROV&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-PROV/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-PROV/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DPP-PROV","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"7"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-prov/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-prov/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-odp/, http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-info/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-odp/, http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-info/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-PROV/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPP/blob/master/LICENSE","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPP/blob/master/LICENSE"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"LiU SemWeb team"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Maike Jansen\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/66f42990-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/66f42990-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Huanyu Li\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ee97be10-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ee97be10-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Eva Blomqvist\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/67ad5cd0-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/67ad5cd0-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Robin Keskisärkkä\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/67d2fda0-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/67d2fda0-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-PROV/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":250.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6788},"DPP-AEC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/janneke.bosma/ontologies/2024/1/untitled-ontology-4"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":2.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://www.DPPOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/JannekeBosma/DPP","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DPP-AEC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"An ontology for Digital Product Passports in the Architecture, Engineering, and Construction (AEC) industry.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/JannekeBosma/DPP/main/Ontology_DPP_2024.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"DPP for Architecture, Engineering, and Construction","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"17","omv:numberOfProperties":"43","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-AEC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:10:44.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DPP-AEC&q=","schema:comment":"[\"An ontology for Digital Product Passports in the AEC industry\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-AEC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-AEC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"2","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-AEC/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DPP-AEC&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"5","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-AEC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-AEC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DPP-AEC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"6"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/janneke.bosma/ontologies/2024/1/untitled-ontology-4","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/janneke.bosma/ontologies/2024/1/untitled-ontology-4"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-AEC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"6"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Janneke Bosma"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-AEC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":223.0,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4192},"SMART-IM":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/standards/smart/ontologies/core/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://smartsdu.org/informationmodel","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SMART-IM","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The IEC & ISO Information Model for SMART content defines the core concepts, relationships, and attributes that ensure international standards content is Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, and Reusable (FAIR)., Core Ontology for representing (SMART) content of standard as per the ISO/IEC Directives Part 2. Example of SMART content are Provisions such as Requirement, Recommendation, Permission","omv:resourceLocator":"https://bitbucket.org/smartsdu/information-model-share/raw/2.0.0/information_model/ontologies/core-ontology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"IEC & ISO Information Model for SMART content","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.iec.ch\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d1ca5a30-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d1ca5a30-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.iso.org\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d1f66600-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d1f66600-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"26","omv:numberOfProperties":"16","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"smart","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMART-IM/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:18:46.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SMART-IM&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMART-IM/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMART-IM/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"2","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMART-IM/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SMART-IM&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"5","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMART-IM/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMART-IM/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SMART-IM","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"10"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":85,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":65.0,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/standards/smart/ontologies/core/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/standards/smart/ontologies/core/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMART-IM/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"SMART Single Delivery Unit"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMART-IM/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":36.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":234.0,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6904},"AFO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.allotrope.org/voc/afo/merged/REC/2023/09/merged-without-qudt-and-inferred.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://www.allotrope.org/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"AFO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Allotrope Foundation Ontology (AFO) represents lab equipment, processes, measurements, and analytical chemistry vocabulary.","omv:resourceLocator":"http://purl.allotrope.org/voc/afo/merged/REC/2023/09/merged-without-qudt-and-inferred.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Allotrope Foundation Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AFO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:36:09.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=AFO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AFO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AFO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AFO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=AFO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AFO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AFO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/AFO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.allotrope.org/voc/afo/merged/REC/2023/09/merged-without-qudt-and-inferred.ttl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.allotrope.org/voc/afo/merged/REC/2023/09/merged-without-qudt-and-inferred.ttl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AFO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Allotrope Maintainers"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AFO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2023-09"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3676},"AMAO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/AMAO"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"AMAO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Fraunhofer ICGV AM Application Ontology is an ODE_AM application module for additive-manufacturing data management. It reuses BFO as top-level and CCO as mid-level ontologies, imports the IGCV Manufacturing Application Ontology, and adds AM-specific concepts such as process parameters, build-platform coordinates, support structures, machine entities, and instruction-file artifacts for consistent process documentation and querying.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/AMAO","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Fraunhofer ICGV AM Application Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/ThomasBjarsch/ODE_AM"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"168","omv:numberOfProperties":"30","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"13"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:56.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-02-06T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=AMAO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology, created for use at Fraunhofer IGCV, includes essential classes specifically relevant to Project ODE_AM within the domain of Additive Manufacturing. It is designed with the capability for successive expansions to accommodate future developments and additional requirements in this field.\",\"It uses Basic Formal Ontology as a Top- and Common Core Ontologies as Mid-Level-Ontologies. Fraunhofer IGCV Manufacturing Application Ontology is used as direct import.\",\"This ontology, designed for use in data management within the Fraunhofer IGCV's project-specific web-app, includes only those classes that are directly relevant to the project's needs. It primarily integrates existing classes from the Basic Formal Ontology (BFO) and the Common Core Ontologies (CCO), selectively chosen to fit the considered use cases in our project. This focused approach ensures efficient and relevant data categorization and retrieval tailored to our specific project requirements.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"32","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=AMAO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"102","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/AMAO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"30"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/AMAO","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/AMAO"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://protege.stanford.edu/plugins/owl/dc/protege-dc.owl, https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/MAO]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://protege.stanford.edu/plugins/owl/dc/protege-dc.owl, https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/MAO]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"4"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Thomas Bjarsch\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/197b0cb0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/197b0cb0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_ODE_AM, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:26.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:26.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_ODE_AM, name=MaterialDigital / ODE_AM, description=MaterialDigital subproject ODE_AM, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_ODE_AM, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMD, name=MaterialDigital / PMD, description=Platform MaterialDigital project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMDAO, name=MaterialDigital / PMD Application Ontologies, description=PMD application ontologies, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":36.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":238.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6704},"AMONTOLOGY":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/ina3/ontologies/2016/2/untitled-ontology-122"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"AMONTOLOGY","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://amontology.readthedocs.io","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The AM ontology has been developed following two major milestones. The ontology developed within the first milestone includes AMProcessOntology, ModelOntology and AMOntology files. AMProcessOntology contains the set of entities used to capture knowledge about additive manufacturing processes.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Aditive Manufacturing Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/NIST-SDA/AMontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"85","omv:numberOfProperties":"5","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMONTOLOGY/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:45.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2021-04-15T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=AMONTOLOGY&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMONTOLOGY/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMONTOLOGY/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"8","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/AMONTOLOGY/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=AMONTOLOGY&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"83","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMONTOLOGY/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMONTOLOGY/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/AMONTOLOGY","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"55"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/ina3/ontologies/2016/2/untitled-ontology-122","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/ina3/ontologies/2016/2/untitled-ontology-122"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMONTOLOGY/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Paul Witherell"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMONTOLOGY/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":221.0,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3755},"APPLICATIONONTOL":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/sensotwin/applicationontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://w3id.org/sensotwin/applicationontology/1.0.1."},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"APPLICATIONONTOL","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/SENSOTWIN\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://materialdigital.github.io/materialdigital1_ontology_collection/index.html","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"SensoTwin Application Ontology models fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) engineering knowledge for the SensoTwin digital-twin workflow. Its scope includes materials, manufacturing and curing processes, testing procedures, parameters and results, simulation context, and component geometry, with example instances used for proof-of-concept and demonstrator scenarios.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/materialdigital1_ontology_collection/main/SensoTwin/tbox/PMDCollectionSensoTwin.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"SensoTwin Application Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/upaehler/SensoTwin"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"433","omv:numberOfProperties":"161","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"219"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:32.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2026-02-06T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=APPLICATIONONTOL&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology describes fibre composites according to the needs in the project SensoTwin, still under development.\\n\\nIt takes care of: \\nused materials\\nproduction processes \\ntesting processes, parameters and results\\nsimulation\\nand componentgeometry\\n\\nIncluded instances serve as proof of concept or as exemplary applications.\",\"Usage of Ontologies:\\nPMDCO\\nPMDSI (old)\\nqudt\\nProv\\nIAO\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"28","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=APPLICATIONONTOL&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"191","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"53"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/sensotwin/applicationontology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/sensotwin/applicationontology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/pmd/co, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o-inverses#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/pmd/co, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o-inverses#]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/SENSOTWIN\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"6"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ursula Pähler\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bad92400-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bad92400-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.1."},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_SENSOTWIN, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_SENSOTWIN, name=MaterialDigital / SensoTwin, description=MaterialDigital subproject SensoTwin, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_SENSOTWIN, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":51.0,"normalizedScore":35,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":259.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7023},"ASMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/asmo/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/asmo/v1.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ASMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/OCDO/asmo","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"ASMO defines concepts needed to describe atomistic simulation methods (including DFT, molecular dynamics, and Monte Carlo) and models their workflow/provenance context via PROV-O-compatible semantics. It is used to represent simulation methods, parameters, algorithms, and calculated outputs in a machine-interpretable and queryable form across computational materials workflows.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/OCDO/asmo/main/asmo.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Atomistic Simulation Methods Ontology (ASMO)","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/OCDO/asmo"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ASMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:00:04.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ASMO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ASMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ASMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/ASMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ASMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ASMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ASMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/ASMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/asmo/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/asmo/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ASMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7564-7990\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/397e6d90-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/397e6d90-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0698-4891\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39cc3420-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39cc3420-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5149-603X\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39e5fa20-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39e5fa20-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6776-1213\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39feaa70-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39feaa70-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9560-4728\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a154560-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a154560-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ASMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, homePage=https://nfdi-matwerk.de/solutions/all-solutions/semantics, institution=NFDI-MatWerk, updated=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ASMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMEO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CMSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MWO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PLDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PODO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RDOC], created=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NFDIMATWERK, name=NFDI-MatWerk Semantic Resources, description=Project entry for NFDI-MatWerk semantic resources curated in MatPortal dev. The project groups ontologies that are directly NFDI-MatWerk authored, NFDI-MatWerk infrastructure-use-case resources, or NFDI-MatWerk-listed semantic resources relevant to materials science and engineering interoperability., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/nfdimatwerk"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":52.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7302},"AUTOMATCE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/automatce.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/automatce/releases/2026-05-28/automatce.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"AUTOMATCE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/AUTOMATCE\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://w3id.org/pmd/automatce","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Automotive Circular Economy Ontology (AUTOMATCE) is a PMD-aligned application ontology focused on circular-economy concepts in automotive contexts. It is published as its own ontology module and provides reusable terminology for representing lifecycle, recovery, and circularity-related knowledge in automotive materials and process data., Application ontology for automotive circular-economy product, material, sustainability, usage, dismantling, engineering and transactional data aligned to PMDCore and BFO 2020.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/automatce/main/automatce.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Automotive Circular Economy Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/automatce"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"530","omv:numberOfProperties":"76","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"92"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-05-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"3","dct:created":"2026-05-28T18:00:02.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=AUTOMATCE&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"69","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=AUTOMATCE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"9","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"44"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/automatce.ttl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/automatce.ttl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/AUTOMATCE\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://w3id.org/pmd/automatce.owl#CC-BY-4.0","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://w3id.org/pmd/automatce.owl#CC-BY-4.0"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0009-0003-1503-4422\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/22e4a930-3ced-013f-cfba-1ee491c84be1\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/22e4a930-3ced-013f-cfba-1ee491c84be1\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0009-0007-7468-3544\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/23072730-3ced-013f-cfba-1ee491c84be1\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/23072730-3ced-013f-cfba-1ee491c84be1\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0473-0070\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/231ee740-3ced-013f-cfba-1ee491c84be1\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/231ee740-3ced-013f-cfba-1ee491c84be1\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0744-8855\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/23387090-3ced-013f-cfba-1ee491c84be1\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/23387090-3ced-013f-cfba-1ee491c84be1\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0009-0003-1503-4422\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/22e4a930-3ced-013f-cfba-1ee491c84be1\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/22e4a930-3ced-013f-cfba-1ee491c84be1\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0009-0007-7468-3544\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/23072730-3ced-013f-cfba-1ee491c84be1\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/23072730-3ced-013f-cfba-1ee491c84be1\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0473-0070\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/231ee740-3ced-013f-cfba-1ee491c84be1\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/231ee740-3ced-013f-cfba-1ee491c84be1\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0744-8855\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/23387090-3ced-013f-cfba-1ee491c84be1\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/23387090-3ced-013f-cfba-1ee491c84be1\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2026-05-28"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":249.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7204},"BIMIOT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/BIM-IoT_IntegrationOntology.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/BIM-IoT_IntegrationOntology.owl/1.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BIMIOT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"BIM-IoT Integration Ontology aligns IFC building-model concepts (for example IfcBuilding, IfcBuildingStorey, and IfcBuildingElement) with IoT observation concepts so that building components, sensors, and measured values can be represented in one graph. The ontology imports dedicated BIM and IoT ontologies and adds integration relations for deployment, location, and property linkage, enabling digital-twin style queries across static BIM structure and live sensor data.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"BIM-IoT Integration Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"159","omv:numberOfProperties":"107","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMIOT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"5"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:01.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"3","dct:created":"2026-02-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIMIOT&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMIOT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMIOT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"3","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMIOT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIMIOT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"158","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMIOT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMIOT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BIMIOT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"87"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":16.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/BIM-IoT_IntegrationOntology.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/BIM-IoT_IntegrationOntology.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMIOT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMIOT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":221.0,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4749},"BTO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bto.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bto/releases/2021-10-26/bto.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BTO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A structured controlled vocabulary for the source of an enzyme. It comprises terms for tissues, cell lines, cell types and cell cultures from uni- and multicellular organisms., A structured controlled vocabulary for the source of an enzyme comprising tissues, cell types and cell cultures","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"BRENDA Tissue and Enzyme Source Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/BRENDA-Enzymes/BTO"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"6569","omv:numberOfProperties":"10","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"BrendaTissueOBO","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:38.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"19","dct:created":"2022-02-04T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BTO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"329","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BTO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1055","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BTO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"290"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bto.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bto.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":11.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OBO"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OBO"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/oboformat/spec.html"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":16.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/oboformat/spec.html","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","mod:maxDepth":"6"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"releases/2021-10-26"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"OBO-Edit 2.3.1\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":244.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4864},"BTO-BFO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/brinell-hardness-test/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BTO-BFO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Brinell Test Ontology-BFO is the BFO-based Brinell ontology variant for representing the Brinell testing process, required equipment, test-piece characteristics, and the testing parameters and measurement steps defined in DIN EN ISO 6506-1. It retains the Brinell domain content of BTO while expressing that content in the BFO-aligned version of the ontology family.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/brinell-hardness-test/-/raw/main/BTO5.0.4.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Brinell Test Ontology-BFO","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/HosseinBeygiNasrabadi/Brinell-Test-Ontology-BTO-"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-BFO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:00:08.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BTO-BFO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"KupferDigital project (www.materialdigital.de/project/1)\",\"Brinell Test Ontology (BTO) has developed for representing the Brinell testing process, testing equipment requirements, test pieces charactristics, and related testing parameters and their measurement procedure according to DIN EN ISO 6506-1 standard.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-BFO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-BFO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-BFO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BTO-BFO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-BFO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-BFO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BTO-BFO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/brinell-hardness-test/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/brinell-hardness-test/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/core/Core.rdf, https://github.com/Mat-O-Lab/MSEO/raw/main/domain/util/readable_bfo_iris.ttl/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/core/Core.rdf, https://github.com/Mat-O-Lab/MSEO/raw/main/domain/util/readable_bfo_iris.ttl/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-BFO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Beygi Nasrabadi, Hossein (www.orcid.org/0000-0002-3092-0532)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/95abc540-edb4-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/95abc540-edb4-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Skrotzki, Birgit\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/95c00f00-edb4-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/95c00f00-edb4-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-BFO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"5.0.4 (BFO, IOF. MSEO)"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":237.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6499},"BTO-EMMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/brinell-hardness-test/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BTO-EMMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Brinell Test Ontology-EMMO is the EMMO/CHAMEO-aligned Brinell ontology variant for representing Brinell hardness testing, including equipment requirements, test-piece characteristics, and the parameters and measurement procedure defined in DIN EN ISO 6506-1. It is the EMMO-grounded release of the Brinell ontology family and keeps the same Brinell test scope as the main BTO entry.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/brinell-hardness-test/-/raw/main/BTO3.0.4.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Brinell Test Ontology-EMMO","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/HosseinBeygiNasrabadi/Brinell-Test-Ontology-BTO-"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-EMMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:00:11.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BTO-EMMO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"KupferDigital project (www.materialdigital.de/project/1)\",\"Brinell Test Ontology (BTO) has developed for representing the Brinell testing process, testing equipment requirements, test pieces charactristics, and related testing parameters and their measurement procedure according to DIN EN ISO 6506-1 standard.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-EMMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-EMMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-EMMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BTO-EMMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-EMMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-EMMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BTO-EMMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/brinell-hardness-test/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/brinell-hardness-test/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://emmo-repo.github.io/versions/1.0.0-beta7/emmo.ttl, https://w3id.org/emmo]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://emmo-repo.github.io/versions/1.0.0-beta7/emmo.ttl, https://w3id.org/emmo]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-EMMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Beygi Nasrabadi, Hossein (www.orcid.org/0000-0002-3092-0532)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d09c0b20-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d09c0b20-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Skrotzki, Birgit\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d0ba4790-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d0ba4790-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-EMMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"3.0.4 (EMMO, CHAMEO, MT)"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":237.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6428},"BTO-PROVO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/brinell-hardness-test/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BTO-PROVO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Brinell Test Ontology-PROVO is the PROV-O/PMDco-aligned Brinell ontology variant for representing Brinell hardness testing, including the test process, equipment requirements, specimen characteristics, and the parameters and measurement procedure defined in DIN EN ISO 6506-1. It keeps the Brinell testing domain model of BTO while expressing the workflow in the provenance-oriented release of the ontology family.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/brinell-hardness-test/-/raw/main/BTO4.0.4.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Brinell Test Ontology-PROVO","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/HosseinBeygiNasrabadi/Brinell-Test-Ontology-BTO-"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"59","omv:numberOfProperties":"24","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-PROVO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"40"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:00:13.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BTO-PROVO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"KupferDigital project (www.materialdigital.de/project/1)\",\"Brinell Test Ontology (BTO) has developed for representing the Brinell testing process, testing equipment requirements, test pieces charactristics, and related testing parameters and their measurement procedure according to DIN EN ISO 6506-1 standard.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-PROVO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-PROVO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"16","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-PROVO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BTO-PROVO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"46","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-PROVO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-PROVO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BTO-PROVO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"11"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/brinell-hardness-test/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/brinell-hardness-test/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/pmd/co, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o-inverses#, https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/core-ontology/main/pmd_core.ttl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/pmd/co, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o-inverses#, https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/core-ontology/main/pmd_core.ttl]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-PROVO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"6"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Beygi Nasrabadi, Hossein (www.orcid.org/0000-0002-3092-0532)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/de0e0b00-edb2-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/de0e0b00-edb2-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Skrotzki, Birgit\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/de28a000-edb2-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/de28a000-edb2-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BTO-PROVO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"4.0.4 (PROV, PMDco)"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":240.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7387},"BUILDMAT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/BuildingMaterials"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BUILDMAT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Building Material Ontology provides the core concepts needed to describe building materials, their types, layered compositions, and associated properties. Its scope is the semantic organization of construction-material entities together with the layer and property descriptions used to characterize them.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://digitalconstruction.github.io/Materials/v/0.5/materials.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Building Material Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/DigitalConstruction/BuildingMaterials"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"BMO","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BUILDMAT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"Building Material Ontology defines the main concepts of building material, types, layers, and properties","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:00:15.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BUILDMAT&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BUILDMAT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BUILDMAT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/BUILDMAT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BUILDMAT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BUILDMAT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BUILDMAT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BUILDMAT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":63.0,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/BuildingMaterials","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/BuildingMaterials"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"beta"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BUILDMAT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Prathap Valluru"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Janakiram Karlapudi (janakiram.karlapudi@tu-dresden.de)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/abc46e50-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/abc46e50-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Prathap Valluru (prathap.valluru@tu-dresden.de)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/abdc50c0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/abdc50c0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BUILDMAT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":250.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5698},"BWMD":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.iwm.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/bwmd-ontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BWMD","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/BWMDPROJ\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"BWMD is the original non-modularized ontology created in the MaterialDigital project in 2020 and built on top of BFO. It captures the BWMD materials-science vocabulary as one integrated ontology artifact rather than as a split set of modules, preserving the original modeling approach of that project line.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"BWMD Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/pmdco-bwmd"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"770","omv:numberOfProperties":"31","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:09.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2022-06-23T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BWMD&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"54","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BWMD&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"512","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BWMD","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"88"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.iwm.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/bwmd-ontology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.iwm.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/bwmd-ontology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/BWMDPROJ\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"11"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Elena Garcia Trelles"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/ADAM, homePage=https://am-data-space.de/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=ADAM, name=KMU-akut: ADAM, description=Um die Innovations- und Wettbewerbsfähigkeit deutscher kleiner und mittlerer Unternehmen (KMU) zu steigern, bedarf es konzertierter Anstrengungen zur Digitalisierung der Wertschöpfungsketten. Dabei sind Einzelinitiativen von KMU aus systemischer Perspektive meist nicht zielführend, sowie technologisch und finanziell kaum stemmbar. Für die Domäne der Additiven Fertigung (AM) soll im Projekt »ADAM«, als Teil des Fraunhofer-Programms »KMU-akut«, ein Cluster entstehen, das die Bedarfe von KMU aus AM-Wertschöpfungsketten erhebt und systematisch mit industrietauglichen Fraunhofer- Technologien deckt. Das Konsortium aus Fraunhofer-Instituten stellt dabei das nötige Technologiespektrum bereit, um maßgeschneiderte, KMU-spezifische Lösungen gleichzeitig in ein übergeordnetes Gesamtkonzept zur Digitalisierung zu integrieren. Eine dynamische Ausrichtung der Forschungsaktivitäten der Institute\r\ngemäß der erhobenen KMU-Bedarfe soll den direkten Technologietransfer zusätzlich stärken.\r\n\r\nDas Cluster bildet den Nukleus für ein »Datenökosystem AM«, das erhebliche Effizienzsteigerungen, sowie neuartige digitale Produkte, Dienstleistungen und Geschäftsmodelle ermöglicht. Technisch auf den International Data Spaces (IDS) basierend, sichert die digitale Infrastruktur die Datensouveränität und den Wissensvorsprung der beteiligten Unternehmen., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/ADAM, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/AluTrace, homePage=https://github.com/Mat-O-Lab/AluTrace-Data-and-Documentation, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=AluTrace, name=AluTrace, description=Digitalisierung der Prozesskette additiv gefertigter Aluminiumleichtbaukomponenten.\r\n\r\nAdditive Fertigung (AM) bietet aufgrund großer Designfreiheiten ein enormes Leichtbaupotenzial und wird deshalb im Anlagen- und Maschinenbau, im Fahrzeugbau und in der Luft- und Raumfahrt in immer mehr Bereichen eingesetzt. Vom Rohmaterial bis zum fertigen Bauteil durchlaufen die Zwischenprodukte mehrere Wertschöpfungsstufen und dabei meist mehrere Unternehmen. Für eine maximale Ausschöpfung des Leichtbaupotenzials müssen Wissensverluste zwischen den einzelnen Wertschöpfungsstufen verhindert werden, um durchgängig eine möglichst genaue Kenntnis des Werkstoffs, des Bauteils und des Fertigungsprozesses zu erhalten. So können Design und Produktion in wirtschaftlicher und ökologischer Hinsicht weiter optimiert werden.\r\n\r\nZiel des Forschungsprojekts AluTrace ist es deshalb, die über Produktentwicklungs- und -herstellungszyklen entstehenden Daten- und Wissensinseln digital zu verknüpfen. Das Konsortium aus dem Fraunhofer EMI, dem Fraunhofer IWM sowie dem fem Forschungsinstitut Edelmetalle + Metallchemie untersucht am Beispiel additiver Fertigung, wie die durchgängige Nutzbarmachung von Daten und Wissen zum Werkstoff, dem Fertigungsprozess und zu den Bauteilanforderungen zur Optimierung von Aluminiumleichtbaustrukturen beitragen kann. Dazu werden dezentral vorliegende Werkstoff- und Werkstoffprozessdaten gezielt ergänzt, semantisch durch Wissensgraphen beschrieben und mithilfe der Technologie der International Data Spaces (IDS) vernetzt.\r\n\r\nFür eine Ergebnisverbreitung in die Wirtschaft wird das Konsortium von einem industriellen Beirat aus namhaften Unternehmen begleitet, darunter Dienstleister im Bereich von additivem Design und Fertigung, Metallverarbeitung sowie Anbieter von Leichtbauprodukten und KI-Lösungen. Das Projekt wird mit rund 400 000 Euro vom Ministerium für Wirtschaft, Arbeit und Wohnungsbau Baden-Württemberg gefördert und hat eine Laufzeit von 15 Monaten.\r\n, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/AluTrace, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/DMD4Future, homePage=https://www.materials.fraunhofer.de/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=DMD4Future, name=DMD4Future, description=Fraunhofer-internen Innovationsprogramms setzte sich mit der digitalisierten Material- und Datenwertschöpfungskette auseinander.\r\n\r\nIm Projekt DMD4Future wurden neue datenbasierte Technologiekompetenzen zur Beschreibung und Optimierung in und entlang der unterschiedlichen Phasen des Material- und Produktlebenszyklus erarbeitet. Darüber hinaus wurde die Basis für datengetriebene Geschäftsmodelle sowie für digitale Mehrwertangebote in der Materialwirtschaft vorbereitet., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/DMD4Future, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_BWMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMDMAP], created=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_BWMD, name=MaterialDigital / BWMD, description=MaterialDigital subproject BWMD, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_BWMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/Mat-O-Lab, homePage=https://matolab.materials.digital/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:23.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSEO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:23.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=Mat-O-Lab, name=Materials Open Laboratory, description=Joint Venture Between Fraunhofer MATERIALS and BAM, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/Mat-O-Lab, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":241.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4114},"BWMD-DOMAIN":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.materials.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/BWMD_ontology/domain"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://gitlab.cc-asp.fraunhofer.de/EMI_datamanagement/bwmd_ontology/-/raw/master/BWMD_ontology_domain.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BWMD-DOMAIN","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This project inherits the BWMD ontology created by Fraunhofer IWM. Within the DMD4F project this ontology was curated by Fraunhofer EMI, i.e. it was divided into modules","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"BWMD Domain Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"772","omv:numberOfProperties":"35","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T22:49:26.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2021-01-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BWMD-DOMAIN&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This is the domain module of the BWMD_ontology.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"54","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BWMD-DOMAIN&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"28","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"88"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":16.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.materials.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/BWMD_ontology/domain","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.materials.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/BWMD_ontology/domain"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"retired"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.materials.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/BWMD_ontology/mid]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.materials.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/BWMD_ontology/mid]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"11"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Christoph Schweizer, Martin Huschka]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.0.3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/ADAM, homePage=https://am-data-space.de/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=ADAM, name=KMU-akut: ADAM, description=Um die Innovations- und Wettbewerbsfähigkeit deutscher kleiner und mittlerer Unternehmen (KMU) zu steigern, bedarf es konzertierter Anstrengungen zur Digitalisierung der Wertschöpfungsketten. Dabei sind Einzelinitiativen von KMU aus systemischer Perspektive meist nicht zielführend, sowie technologisch und finanziell kaum stemmbar. Für die Domäne der Additiven Fertigung (AM) soll im Projekt »ADAM«, als Teil des Fraunhofer-Programms »KMU-akut«, ein Cluster entstehen, das die Bedarfe von KMU aus AM-Wertschöpfungsketten erhebt und systematisch mit industrietauglichen Fraunhofer- Technologien deckt. Das Konsortium aus Fraunhofer-Instituten stellt dabei das nötige Technologiespektrum bereit, um maßgeschneiderte, KMU-spezifische Lösungen gleichzeitig in ein übergeordnetes Gesamtkonzept zur Digitalisierung zu integrieren. Eine dynamische Ausrichtung der Forschungsaktivitäten der Institute\r\ngemäß der erhobenen KMU-Bedarfe soll den direkten Technologietransfer zusätzlich stärken.\r\n\r\nDas Cluster bildet den Nukleus für ein »Datenökosystem AM«, das erhebliche Effizienzsteigerungen, sowie neuartige digitale Produkte, Dienstleistungen und Geschäftsmodelle ermöglicht. Technisch auf den International Data Spaces (IDS) basierend, sichert die digitale Infrastruktur die Datensouveränität und den Wissensvorsprung der beteiligten Unternehmen., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/ADAM, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/AluTrace, homePage=https://github.com/Mat-O-Lab/AluTrace-Data-and-Documentation, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=AluTrace, name=AluTrace, description=Digitalisierung der Prozesskette additiv gefertigter Aluminiumleichtbaukomponenten.\r\n\r\nAdditive Fertigung (AM) bietet aufgrund großer Designfreiheiten ein enormes Leichtbaupotenzial und wird deshalb im Anlagen- und Maschinenbau, im Fahrzeugbau und in der Luft- und Raumfahrt in immer mehr Bereichen eingesetzt. Vom Rohmaterial bis zum fertigen Bauteil durchlaufen die Zwischenprodukte mehrere Wertschöpfungsstufen und dabei meist mehrere Unternehmen. Für eine maximale Ausschöpfung des Leichtbaupotenzials müssen Wissensverluste zwischen den einzelnen Wertschöpfungsstufen verhindert werden, um durchgängig eine möglichst genaue Kenntnis des Werkstoffs, des Bauteils und des Fertigungsprozesses zu erhalten. So können Design und Produktion in wirtschaftlicher und ökologischer Hinsicht weiter optimiert werden.\r\n\r\nZiel des Forschungsprojekts AluTrace ist es deshalb, die über Produktentwicklungs- und -herstellungszyklen entstehenden Daten- und Wissensinseln digital zu verknüpfen. Das Konsortium aus dem Fraunhofer EMI, dem Fraunhofer IWM sowie dem fem Forschungsinstitut Edelmetalle + Metallchemie untersucht am Beispiel additiver Fertigung, wie die durchgängige Nutzbarmachung von Daten und Wissen zum Werkstoff, dem Fertigungsprozess und zu den Bauteilanforderungen zur Optimierung von Aluminiumleichtbaustrukturen beitragen kann. Dazu werden dezentral vorliegende Werkstoff- und Werkstoffprozessdaten gezielt ergänzt, semantisch durch Wissensgraphen beschrieben und mithilfe der Technologie der International Data Spaces (IDS) vernetzt.\r\n\r\nFür eine Ergebnisverbreitung in die Wirtschaft wird das Konsortium von einem industriellen Beirat aus namhaften Unternehmen begleitet, darunter Dienstleister im Bereich von additivem Design und Fertigung, Metallverarbeitung sowie Anbieter von Leichtbauprodukten und KI-Lösungen. Das Projekt wird mit rund 400 000 Euro vom Ministerium für Wirtschaft, Arbeit und Wohnungsbau Baden-Württemberg gefördert und hat eine Laufzeit von 15 Monaten.\r\n, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/AluTrace, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/DMD4Future, homePage=https://www.materials.fraunhofer.de/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=DMD4Future, name=DMD4Future, description=Fraunhofer-internen Innovationsprogramms setzte sich mit der digitalisierten Material- und Datenwertschöpfungskette auseinander.\r\n\r\nIm Projekt DMD4Future wurden neue datenbasierte Technologiekompetenzen zur Beschreibung und Optimierung in und entlang der unterschiedlichen Phasen des Material- und Produktlebenszyklus erarbeitet. Darüber hinaus wurde die Basis für datengetriebene Geschäftsmodelle sowie für digitale Mehrwertangebote in der Materialwirtschaft vorbereitet., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/DMD4Future, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/Mat-O-Lab, homePage=https://matolab.materials.digital/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:23.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSEO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:23.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=Mat-O-Lab, name=Materials Open Laboratory, description=Joint Venture Between Fraunhofer MATERIALS and BAM, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/Mat-O-Lab, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4411},"BWMDMAP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.iwm.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/bwmd-ontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BWMDMAP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/BWMDPROJ\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology describing concepts and relationships for BWMD Ontology (IWM)","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"BWMD Ontology (IWM)","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1095","omv:numberOfProperties":"37","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMDMAP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:35:54.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"8","dct:created":"2026-02-06T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BWMDMAP&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Classes classified for compatibility with the beta version Graph Designer App\",\"BWMD ontology adapted for the DigiChrom Workshop 20.11.2024\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMDMAP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMDMAP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"54","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMDMAP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BWMDMAP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"361","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMDMAP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMDMAP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BWMDMAP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"93"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.iwm.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/bwmd-ontology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.iwm.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/bwmd-ontology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"retired"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMDMAP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/BWMDPROJ\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"11"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Fraunhofer Institute for Mechanics of Materials (IWM)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a6d1d180-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a6d1d180-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMDMAP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_BWMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMDMAP], created=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_BWMD, name=MaterialDigital / BWMD, description=MaterialDigital subproject BWMD, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_BWMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":19,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":236.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5824},"CCO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CCO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"All eleven of the Common Core mid-level ontologies, along with BFO and the subset of RO used in CCO, merged into one file. Provided for use-cases where one file representing a specific release of CCO that includes all content of its import dependencies is desirable to use over the set of individual files and imports.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/master/src/cco-merged/CommonCoreOntologiesMerged.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Common Core Ontologies (Merged))","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:00:24.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CCO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":21.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":93,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":110.0,"normalizedScore":97,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Mark Jensen"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":17,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":230.0,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":12707},"CDCO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cdos/cdco"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cdos/cdco/1.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CDCO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/OCDO/cdco","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Crystallographic Defect Core Ontology (CDCO) provides the shared upper vocabulary for defect-focused ontologies in crystalline materials, centering on classes such as crystalline material, crystallographic defect, and defect complex with core relations linking materials to their defect descriptions. It serves as the unifying semantic backbone for specialized point, line, and planar defect modules and cross-dataset integration.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/OCDO/cdco/main/cdco.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"CDCO","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/OCDO/cdco"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CDCO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:00:29.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CDCO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CDCO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CDCO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/CDCO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CDCO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CDCO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CDCO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CDCO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cdos/cdco","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cdos/cdco"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CDCO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7564-7990\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/397e6d90-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/397e6d90-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CDCO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, homePage=https://nfdi-matwerk.de/solutions/all-solutions/semantics, institution=NFDI-MatWerk, updated=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ASMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMEO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CMSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MWO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PLDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PODO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RDOC], created=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NFDIMATWERK, name=NFDI-MatWerk Semantic Resources, description=Project entry for NFDI-MatWerk semantic resources curated in MatPortal dev. The project groups ontologies that are directly NFDI-MatWerk authored, NFDI-MatWerk infrastructure-use-case resources, or NFDI-MatWerk-listed semantic resources relevant to materials science and engineering interoperability., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/nfdimatwerk"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":24,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":234.0,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4790},"CEMAO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/CEMAO"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CEMAO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Composite Extrusion Modeling Ontology (CEMAO) is an ODE_AM application ontology for composite-extrusion-modeling process knowledge in metal additive-manufacturing contexts. It is built on BFO and CCO and introduces CEM-specific process, machine, and parameter terms so manufacturing data can be represented consistently and integrated with related ODE_AM modules.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/CEMAO","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Composite Extrusion Modeling Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/ODE_AM"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"39","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:09.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-02-06T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CEMAO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"It uses Basic Formal Ontology as Top- and Common Core Ontologies as Mid-Level-Ontologies.\",\"This ontology, designed for use in data management for metal additive manufacturing with focus on Composite Extrusion Modeling (CEM). The ontology only included classes in the scope of project ODE_AM. It primarily integrates existing classes from the Basic Formal Ontology (BFO) and the Common Core Ontologies (CCO), selectively chosen to fit the considered use cases in our project. This focused approach ensures efficient and relevant data categorization and retrieval tailored to our specific project requirements.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"5","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CEMAO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"39","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CEMAO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"11"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/CEMAO","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/CEMAO"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mohamed Kamal, Heiko Beinersdorf\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a5350f90-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a5350f90-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_ODE_AM, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:26.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:26.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_ODE_AM, name=MaterialDigital / ODE_AM, description=MaterialDigital subproject ODE_AM, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_ODE_AM, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMD, name=MaterialDigital / PMD, description=Platform MaterialDigital project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMDAO, name=MaterialDigital / PMD Application Ontologies, description=PMD application ontologies, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":231.0,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6706},"CFMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/CFMO.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CFMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"CFMO is the crowd-flow monitoring module of the SCIMOnto suite. Its class set covers people-counting sensors, density and flow parameters, hotspot and congestion analysis, alerts, and response actions such as crowd guidance, flow limitation, and evacuation routing. The ontology focuses on operational monitoring areas such as transit and rail spaces where flow state, thresholds, and mitigation actions must be modeled together.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/CFMO.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"CFMO","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"384","omv:numberOfProperties":"141","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CFMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"22"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:03.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2026-02-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CFMO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CFMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CFMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"36","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/CFMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CFMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"141","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CFMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CFMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CFMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"39"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/CFMO.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/CFMO.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CFMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"10"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CFMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4203},"CHAMEO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/1.0.2/chameo"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/emmo-repo/domain-characterisation-methodology","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CHAMEO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/emmo-repo/domain-characterisation-methodology","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[\"CHAMEO\"]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[\"CHAMEO\"]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Characterisation Methodology Ontology (CHAMEO) is an EMMO-based ontology for formal representation of materials-characterization methodologies and experiment documentation. It evolved from CHADA-style structured reporting and is used as a common semantic framework for multi-technique characterization workflows, metadata harmonization, and FAIR documentation across characterization domains., Characterisation Methodology Ontology","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/emmo-repo/domain-characterisation-methodology/main/chameo.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"CHAracterisation MEthodology Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"EMMC ASBL\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14c63030-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14c63030-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"EMMC ASBL\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/151081c0-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/151081c0-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1606","omv:numberOfProperties":"250","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"chameo","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMEO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"14"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-05-26T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"CHAMEO is a domain ontology designed to model the common aspects across the different characterisation techniques and methodologies.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"11","dct:created":"2021-12-20T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CHAMEO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Contacts:\\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\tGerhard Goldbeck\\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\tGoldbeck Consulting Ltd (UK)\\n\\t\\t\\t\\t\\temail: gerhard@goldbeck-consulting.com\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMEO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMEO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"125","dct:modified":"2025-11-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMEO/download","foaf:logo":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/emmo-repo/domain-characterisation-methodology/main/images/chameo_logo_small.png","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CHAMEO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1275","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMEO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMEO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CHAMEO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"197"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":73.0,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[\"https://www.w3.org/TR/turtle/\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/emmo/contributors, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/computerscience, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/isq, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/manufacturing, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/materials, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/math, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/metrology, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/models, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/properties, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/units/sidimensionalunits, https://w3id.org/emmo/mereocausality, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/contrast, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/holistic, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/persistence, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/perspective, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/reductionistic, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/semiotics, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/structural, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/agency, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/data, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/persholistic, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/physicalistic, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/standardmodel, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/symbolic, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/workflow]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/emmo/contributors, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/computerscience, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/isq, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/manufacturing, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/materials, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/math, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/metrology, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/models, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/properties, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/units/sidimensionalunits, https://w3id.org/emmo/mereocausality, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/contrast, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/holistic, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/persistence, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/perspective, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/reductionistic, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/semiotics, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/structural, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/agency, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/data, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/persholistic, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/physicalistic, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/standardmodel, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/symbolic, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/workflow]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMEO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[\"https://www.w3.org/TR/turtle/\"]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"22"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4181-2852\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/13fd2080-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/13fd2080-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9668-6961\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1413dfc0-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1413dfc0-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5174-8508\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14295e00-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14295e00-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4181-2852\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/13fd2080-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/13fd2080-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9668-6961\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1413dfc0-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1413dfc0-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5174-8508\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14295e00-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14295e00-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMEO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, homePage=https://nfdi-matwerk.de/solutions/all-solutions/semantics, institution=NFDI-MatWerk, updated=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ASMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMEO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CMSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MWO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PLDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PODO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RDOC], created=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NFDIMATWERK, name=NFDI-MatWerk Semantic Resources, description=Project entry for NFDI-MatWerk semantic resources curated in MatPortal dev. The project groups ontologies that are directly NFDI-MatWerk authored, NFDI-MatWerk infrastructure-use-case resources, or NFDI-MatWerk-listed semantic resources relevant to materials science and engineering interoperability., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/nfdimatwerk"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":55.0,"normalizedScore":38,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":266.0,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7217},"CHAMP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMP"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CHAMP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The goal of CHAMP is to represent the domain of the Product Life Cycle in a suite of mid-level ontologies that may be extended in applications to integrate data both within industrial organizations and across them. Here, you will find the suite of ontology files saved in the turtle format. The ontologies extend from Basic Formal Ontology (BFO), the Relations Ontology (RO), as well as the Common Core Ontologies (CCO) developed by CUBRC. The Common Core Ontologies have their own github repository here: https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology Basic Formal Ontology and related files may be found here: https://github.com/BFO-ontology In addition, there are two applications available here: Process Workflow and Ontoview. The former is an ingestion tool with an RDF-backend to support saving and re-using information throughout a mapping process; the latter is a query tool that improves on the typical SPARQL endpoint by allowing non-expert users to 'build-up' queries by browsing RDF data. Contributors to these files include: J. Neil Otte, Ron Rudnicki, Remo Fischione, Munira Binti Mohd Ali, Binbin Zhang, Ruoyu Yang, and Barry Smith","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Coordinated Holistic Alignment of Manufacturing Processes (Broken, Admin Only)","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/NCOR-US/CHAMP"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:27.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2021-04-15T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CHAMP&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CHAMP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CHAMP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":16.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":58.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMP","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":21.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMP"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":93,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":110.0,"normalizedScore":97,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Barry Smith"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":222.0,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":12754},"CHEMINF":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://semanticchemistry.github.io/semanticchemistry/ontology/cheminf.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CHEMINF","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEMISTRY\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/NFDI4CAT\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/NFDI4CHEM\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEM_INFORMATICS\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://code.google.com/p/information-artifact-ontology/","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Chemical Information Ontology (CHEMINF) models chemical information entities such as descriptors, algorithms, software implementations, and parameterized outputs used in cheminformatics. It provides semantic structure for representing qualitative and quantitative chemical information, provenance, and descriptor meaning in interoperable knowledge graphs and annotation pipelines.","omv:resourceLocator":"http://semanticchemistry.github.io/semanticchemistry/ontology/cheminf.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Chemical Information Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/semanticchemistry/semanticchemistry"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"856","omv:numberOfProperties":"118","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHEMINF/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"20"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:25.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"6","dct:created":"2026-02-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CHEMINF&q=","schema:comment":"[\"To develop the ontology, you must change the default auto-create settings in Protege 4. Go to file>preferences>New Entities. Change the following:\\nspecified URI = http://semanticscience.org/resource/\\nFollowed by '/', End with : AutoID\\nAutoID - digit count = 6, prefix = CHEMINF_\",\"The chemical information ontology (cheminf) describes information entities about chemical entities. It provides qualitative and quantitative attributes to richly describe chemicals.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHEMINF/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHEMINF/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"95","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/CHEMINF/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CHEMINF&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"510","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHEMINF/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHEMINF/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CHEMINF","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"39"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://semanticchemistry.github.io/semanticchemistry/ontology/cheminf.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://semanticchemistry.github.io/semanticchemistry/ontology/cheminf.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/iao.owl, http://semanticchemistry.github.io/semanticchemistry/ontology/cheminf-external.owl, http://semanticchemistry.github.io/semanticchemistry/ontology/cdk.owl, http://semanticchemistry.github.io/semanticchemistry/ontology/cheminf-algorithms.owl, http://semanticchemistry.github.io/semanticchemistry/ontology/cheminf-core.owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/iao.owl, http://semanticchemistry.github.io/semanticchemistry/ontology/cheminf-external.owl, http://semanticchemistry.github.io/semanticchemistry/ontology/cdk.owl, http://semanticchemistry.github.io/semanticchemistry/ontology/cheminf-algorithms.owl, http://semanticchemistry.github.io/semanticchemistry/ontology/cheminf-core.owl]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHEMINF/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEMISTRY\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/NFDI4CAT\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/NFDI4CHEM\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEM_INFORMATICS\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"11"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Egon Willighagen\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/26dd0380-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/26dd0380-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Evan Bolton\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/26f07ab0-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/26f07ab0-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Michel Dumontier\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/27051440-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/27051440-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gang Fu\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/271b13c0-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/271b13c0-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Leonid Chepelev\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2730b530-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2730b530-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mark Davies\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/274844e0-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/274844e0-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Colin Batchelor\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/275cd050-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/275cd050-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cristian Munteanu\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/27701680-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/27701680-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Janna Hastings\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/27873540-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/27873540-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHEMINF/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2.1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/chemistry"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":47.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":266.0,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6435},"CHMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/chmo.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/chmo/releases/2026-05-28/chmo.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CHMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEM_METHODS\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEMISTRY\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/NFDI4CAT\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/NFDI4CHEM\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"CHMO describes experimental and analytical methods used in chemistry, including acquisition methods (for example mass spectrometry and microscopy), preparation/separation methods, synthesis-related methods, and associated instruments. It supplies a standardized method vocabulary for interoperable annotation of chemical experiments and is maintained within the OBO ecosystem., CHMO, the chemical methods ontology, describes methods used to collect data in chemical experiments, such as mass spectrometry and electron microscopy prepare and separate material for further analysis, such as sample ionisation, chromatography, and electrophoresis synthesise materials, such as epitaxy and continuous vapour deposition It also describes the instruments used in these experiments, such as mass spectrometers and chromatography columns. It is intended to be complementary to the Ontology for Biomedical Investigations (OBI).","omv:resourceLocator":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/chmo.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Chemical Methods Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/rsc-ontologies/rsc-cmo"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"3264","omv:numberOfProperties":"54","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"131"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-05-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"7","dct:created":"2026-05-28T18:00:17.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CHMO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"466","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/CHMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CHMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"124","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CHMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"66"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":73.0,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/chmo.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/chmo.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEM_METHODS\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEMISTRY\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/NFDI4CAT\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/NFDI4CHEM\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"16"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Royal Society of Chemistry\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/df38afa0-edb6-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/df38afa0-edb6-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1595-3213\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/df99c460-edb6-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/df99c460-edb6-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2026-05-28"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/chemistry"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":49.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":264.0,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6630},"CMSO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cmso/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CMSO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/OCDO/cmso-ontology","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Computational Material Sample Ontology (CMSO) is designed to represent computational materials samples/structures, with emphasis on atomistic-scale material description and defect-aware sample representation. It captures structural entities and related attributes needed to exchange and query computational materials data in a semantically consistent format.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/OCDO/cmso-ontology/main/cmso.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Computational Material Sample Ontology (CMSO)","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/OCDO/cmso"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"46","omv:numberOfProperties":"53","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CMSO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:22.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-02-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CMSO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CMSO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CMSO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/CMSO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CMSO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"4","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CMSO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CMSO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CMSO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"21"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cmso/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cmso/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CMSO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7564-7990\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/397e6d90-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/397e6d90-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0698-4891\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39cc3420-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39cc3420-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5149-603X\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39e5fa20-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39e5fa20-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6776-1213\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39feaa70-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39feaa70-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9560-4728\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a154560-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a154560-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CMSO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.0.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, homePage=https://nfdi-matwerk.de/solutions/all-solutions/semantics, institution=NFDI-MatWerk, updated=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ASMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMEO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CMSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MWO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PLDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PODO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RDOC], created=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NFDIMATWERK, name=NFDI-MatWerk Semantic Resources, description=Project entry for NFDI-MatWerk semantic resources curated in MatPortal dev. The project groups ontologies that are directly NFDI-MatWerk authored, NFDI-MatWerk infrastructure-use-case resources, or NFDI-MatWerk-listed semantic resources relevant to materials science and engineering interoperability., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/nfdimatwerk"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":53.0,"normalizedScore":37,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":250.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5739},"CPTO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/cpto"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CPTO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/LEBEDIGITAL\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://bamresearch.github.io/LebeDigital/newest","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Concrete Process and Technology Ontology models concrete production and testing knowledge, including concrete constituents (cement, aggregates, admixtures and additions), batch and process entities, and mechanical-performance concepts such as compressive-strength classes and test outcomes. The vocabulary formalizes concrete workflow data from material composition through specimen preparation and standardized testing.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://w3id.org/cpto","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Concrete Process and Technology Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/BAMresearch/LebeDigital"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:00:36.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CPTO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CPTO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CPTO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/cpto","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/cpto"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/LEBEDIGITAL\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":232.0,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3553},"CQU":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/QuantitiesAndUnits/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/20230801/QuantitiesAndUnits/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CQU","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Commons Quantities and Units Ontology is an OMG-led systems-engineering ontology for quantities, quantity values, units, and measurement references. It is designed to interoperate with related standards such as SysML-based models and other quantity-and-unit vocabularies.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/20230801/QuantitiesAndUnits.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Commons Quantities and Units Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"80","omv:numberOfProperties":"90","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CQU/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-17T12:18:51.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"This ontology provides a core set of concepts for quantities, units, systems of quantities, and systems of units. The most widely accepted, scrutinized, and globally used system of quantities and system of units are the International System of Quantities (ISQ) and the International System of Units (SI). They are formally standardized through [ISO 31] and [IEC 60027]. The harmonization of these two sets of standards into one new set [ISO/IEC 80000] has been published by ISO in 2009 and 2010. This ontology is based on the Object Management Group (OMG)'s SysML standard and on ISO/IEC 80000-1:2009, which refers normatively to the ISO/IEC Guide 99:2007. It is compatible with and can be mapped directly to the OMG Date Time Vocabulary (DTV) Quantities Ontology, the de-facto QUDT ontology representing Units of Measure, Quantity Kinds, Dimensions and Data Types (see http://www.qudt.org/), the Units of Measurement Ontology (UO) ontology available from the BioPortal (https://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/UO) and others, as well as the quantities and units library in the SysML specification.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-04-17T12:18:50.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CQU&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CQU/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CQU/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"13","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CQU/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CQU&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CQU/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CQU/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CQU","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"14"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/QuantitiesAndUnits/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/QuantitiesAndUnits/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Classifiers/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Collections/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/ContextualDesignators/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/DatesAndTimes/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Designators/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Documents/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/TextDatatype/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Classifiers/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Collections/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/ContextualDesignators/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/DatesAndTimes/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Designators/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Documents/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/TextDatatype/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CQU/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"5"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Metrology Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Hans Peter de Koenig, DEKonsult\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/22a6b250-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/22a6b250-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Evan Wallace, U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/22bc9b50-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/22bc9b50-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stuart Chalk, University of North Florida\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/22d632d0-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/22d632d0-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Roger Burkhart, Thematix Partners LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/22eb4b80-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/22eb4b80-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Davide Sottara, Mayo Clinic\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/23018740-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/23018740-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Elisa Kendall, Thematix Partners LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9cef4a0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9cef4a0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CQU/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, homePage=https://www.bipm.org/en/measurement-units, institution=MatPortal curation (multi-source metrology set), updated=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CQU, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MASON, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROVO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SIS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SOSA, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSN], created=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=METROLOGY, name=Metrology And Measurement Ontologies, description=Curated multi-source project entry for metrology ontologies in MatPortal dev. The project groups non-biomedical ontologies for units, quantities, dimensional analysis, digital calibration, uncertainty representation, sensor provenance, and measurement-aware domain semantics., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/metrology"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":264.0,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6137},"DEB":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/osnathakimi/ontologies/deb"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DEB","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"An ontology developed to facilitate information curation in the area of medical devices, experimental scaffolds and biomaterials. The ontology was designed to complement existing medical vocabularies, with emphasis on material processing, structures and features associated with biomaterials and experimental scaffolds. It is used as part of an automated text mining pipeline which populates the database of Experimental Biomaterials and their Biological Effect (DEBBIE).","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Devices, Experimental scaffolds and Biomaterials Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/ProjectDebbie/Ontology_DEB"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"601","omv:numberOfProperties":"121","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DEB/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:48.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"6","dct:created":"2021-11-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DEB&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DEB/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DEB/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"53","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/DEB/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DEB&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"597","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DEB/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DEB/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DEB","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"56"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/osnathakimi/ontologies/deb","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/osnathakimi/ontologies/deb"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"beta"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DEB/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"4"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Osnat Hakimi"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Osnat Hakimi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d2d29350-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d2d29350-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DEB/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":29.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":222.0,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5427},"DIGITRUBBERFULLO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/digitrubber/digitrubber-full.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/digitrubber/releases/2026-05-11/digitrubber-full.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DIGITRUBBERFULLO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/DIGITRUBBER\",\"https://purl.org/linsearch/fer\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"The DIGIT RUBBER ontology is aimed at anyone who wants to semantically annotate knowledge and data related to rubber.","foaf:page":"https://tibhannover.github.io/DIGIT-RUBBER","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/TIBHannover/DIGIT-RUBBER/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"DigitRubber Ontology models rubber materials and rubber-production knowledge, including the material, process, and related semantic structures needed to describe rubber-focused workflows in a machine-readable way. The full release packages the broader reusable DigitRubber term set in one ontology artifact so rubber materials, compounds, processing steps, and related data can be described consistently., The DIGIT RUBBER Ontology (DRO) is used to represent data, information, and knowledge relating to rubber and rubber production., DigitRubber Ontology","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/TIBHannover/DIGIT-RUBBER/main/digitrubber-full.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"DigitRubber Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/TIBHannover/DIGIT-RUBBER"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1625","omv:numberOfProperties":"174","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"DRO","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"323"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-05-18T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"7","dct:created":"2023-06-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DIGITRUBBERFULLO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"A description of changes between last version and current version of the ontology.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"133","dct:modified":"2025-09-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DIGITRUBBERFULLO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"204","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"118"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":78.0,"normalizedScore":69,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/digitrubber/digitrubber-full.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/digitrubber/digitrubber-full.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/RDF_XML","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/DIGITRUBBER\",\"https://purl.org/linsearch/fer\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"17"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"InSuKa project\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/b33f4a50-3511-013f-223e-46e7a3ff78e8\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/b33f4a50-3511-013f-223e-46e7a3ff78e8\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"DIGIT RUBBER project\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/b35815a0-3511-013f-223e-46e7a3ff78e8\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/b35815a0-3511-013f-223e-46e7a3ff78e8\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"DIPONI project\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/b375eaf0-3511-013f-223e-46e7a3ff78e8\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/b375eaf0-3511-013f-223e-46e7a3ff78e8\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lars Vogt\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/b39da640-3511-013f-223e-46e7a3ff78e8\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/b39da640-3511-013f-223e-46e7a3ff78e8\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"http://www.purl.org/DigitRubberOntology/0.0.1\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2025-September-25"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[\"https://github.com/TIBHannover/DIGIT-RUBBER/tree/main/preliminary_data/Competeny%20Questions\"]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":13.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_DIGITRUBBER, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:23.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:23.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_DIGITRUBBER, name=MaterialDigital / DigitRubber, description=MaterialDigital subproject DigitRubber, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_DIGITRUBBER, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":57.0,"normalizedScore":39,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":282.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6434},"DISO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DISO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The dislocation ontology (DISO) is an ontology representing the concepts and relationships in linear defects in crystalline materials. It covers various characteristics of dislocation, including the mathematical and numerical representation of the dislocation line, and contains several dislocation-related concepts, including Bravais Lattice, Space Group, Point Group, Crystal System, and Vector.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Materials-Data-Science-and-Informatics/dislocation-ontology/master/dislocation-ontology.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Dislocation Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/Materials-Data-Science-and-Informatics/Dislocation-Ontology-Suite"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:00:46.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DISO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DISO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DISO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":21.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":93,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":110.0,"normalizedScore":97,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Said Fathalla"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, homePage=https://nfdi-matwerk.de/solutions/all-solutions/semantics, institution=NFDI-MatWerk, updated=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ASMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMEO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CMSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MWO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PLDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PODO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RDOC], created=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NFDIMATWERK, name=NFDI-MatWerk Semantic Resources, description=Project entry for NFDI-MatWerk semantic resources curated in MatPortal dev. The project groups ontologies that are directly NFDI-MatWerk authored, NFDI-MatWerk infrastructure-use-case resources, or NFDI-MatWerk-listed semantic resources relevant to materials science and engineering interoperability., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/nfdimatwerk"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":12553},"DRMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2022/titutuli/nivedita/drmo"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DRMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The DrMO ontology is a domain ontology that represents knowledge underlying the composition, characterization and standardization of different materials involved in the dental restoration procedure. It will assist dentists in selecting appropriate materials based on up-to-date scientific knowledge to satisfy a patient?s specific requirements, without jeopardizing their clinical time. It reuses several ontologies from the OBO foundry, especially the Oral Health and Disease (OHD) Ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Dental Restorative Material Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/Nivedita79/DrMO"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"251","omv:numberOfProperties":"58","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DRMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"142"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:38:08.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-10-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DRMO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The DrMO ontology is a domain ontology that represents knowledge underlying the composition, characterization and standardization of different materials involved in the dental restoration procedure. It will assist dentists in selecting appropriate materials based on up-to-date scientific knowledge to satisfy a patient\\u2019s specific requirements, without jeopardizing their clinical time. It reuses several ontologies from the OBO foundry, especially the Oral Health and Disease (OHD) Ontology. However, the dental restoration domain is complex and also requires concepts from materials science and engineering. Thus, DrMO also incorporates knowledge from the Devices, Experimental scaffolds, and Biomaterials (DEB) and Functionally Graded Materials (FGM) ontologies to provide more comprehensive knowledge of this area of dental material than previous ontologies. However, much of the terminology from FGM is different than that used in clinical dentistry. Thus, DrMO has changed the appropriate classes to make them consistent with terminology common in dentistry.  DrMO also follows ontology design best practices by reusing meta-data properties from the Dublin Core vocabulary. It captures knowledge from a large set of the most recent and influential papers in Dental Materials and related fields. Links to these papers are included in the ontology as meta-data defined with Dublin Core. It is implemented in OWL2 and was developed with the Protégé 5.5 ontology editor.  The ontology was created using the Ontology Development 101 methodology by Natalya et.al. Several domain experts in addition to Dr. Dutta also provided their expertise. The ontology is available on GitHub and licensed via an open source license. The GitHub project includes a corresponding file of SPARQL queries that answer the competency questions defined as part of the ontology development methodology.\",\"Naming convention of Class : Words together with capitalization of new word\\n\\nNaming convention of property : Words together with capitalization of new word except the initial word.\",\"Dental Restorative Material Ontology (DrMO) represents the knowledge underlying material selection process by the dentists for various dental restoration procedures.\\nDRMO is a formalized knowledge representation of currently available huge varieties of manufactured object in the field of dental restorative material.For a complete restoration process,along with the primary restorative materials few auxillary dental materials play important role: these are impression materials, liners and bases and adhesives & luting agents.The ontology covers all the materials' processing and manipulation part,properties, composition, underlying active biological substances. It supports to find the recommended manufactured object indicated for a particular dental restoartion procedure and also the contraindications against it's use with a scientific evidence base.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DRMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DRMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"15","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/DRMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DRMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"208","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DRMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DRMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DRMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"14"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2022/titutuli/nivedita/drmo","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/2022/titutuli/nivedita/drmo"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DRMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"7"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6424-4096\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a64252d0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a64252d0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8824-9577\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a69bee40-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a69bee40-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DRMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":224.0,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5439},"ECMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/ECMO.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ECMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"ECMO is the utility-consumption monitoring module in the SCIMOnto family. Its vocabulary contains electricity, gas, and water metering and monitoring parameters, abnormal-consumption and leak alerts, and operational actions such as inspection, correction, maintenance, and optimization. It is used to represent consumption monitoring and response workflows in managed facilities.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/ECMO.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"ECMO","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"397","omv:numberOfProperties":"152","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ECMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"22"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:26.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2026-02-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ECMO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ECMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ECMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"36","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/ECMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ECMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"154","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ECMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ECMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/ECMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"39"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/ECMO.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/ECMO.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ECMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"10"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ECMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3842},"EMMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://emmo.info/emmo"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://emmo.info/emmo/1.0.0-alpha2"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"EMMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://emmo-repo.github.io","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"EMMO is a multidisciplinary effort to develop a standard representational framework (the ontology) based on current materials modelling knowledge, including physical sciences, analytical philosophy and information and communication technologies. It provides the connection between the physical world, materials characterisation world and materials modelling world. EMMO is released under a Creative Commons license Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)","omv:resourceLocator":"http://emmo.info/emmo","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Elementary Multiperspective Material Ontology (EMMO)","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"EMMC ASBL\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14c63030-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14c63030-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/emmo-repo/EMMO"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"European Materials & Modelling Ontology (EMMO)\n\nEMMO is a multidisciplinary effort to develop a standard representational framework (the ontology) based on current materials modelling knowledge, including physical sciences, analytical philosophy and information and communication technologies.\n\nIt provides the connection between the physical world, materials characterisation world and materials modelling world.\n\nEMMO is released under a Creative Commons license Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0).","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:00:50.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=EMMO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Contacts:\\nGerhard Goldbeck\\nGoldbeck Consulting Ltd (UK)\\nemail: gerhard@goldbeck-consulting.com\\n\\nEmanuele Ghedini\\nUniversity of Bologna (IT)\\nemail: emanuele.ghedini@unibo.it\",\"The EMMO requires FacT++ reasoner plugin in order to visualize all inferences and class hierarchy (ctrl+R hotkey in Protege).\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=EMMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/EMMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://emmo.info/emmo","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://emmo.info/emmo"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Gerhard Goldbeck"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Emanuele Ghedini\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/308bd980-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/308bd980-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gerhard Goldbeck\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/30a3d560-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/30a3d560-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jesper Friis\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/30b965a0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/30b965a0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Georg Schmitz\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/30cdf560-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/30cdf560-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Adham Hashibon\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/69806030-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/69806030-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"University of Bologna, IT\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/312cd5b0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/312cd5b0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"SINTEF, NO\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/31412b20-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/31412b20-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Access, DE\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3156ac90-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3156ac90-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Goldbeck Consulting Ltd (UK)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/316c7fc0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/316c7fc0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Fraunhofer IWM, DE\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9878dc00-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9878dc00-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0-alpha2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/PHYSICS, homePage=https://physh.org/, institution=MatPortal curation (multi-source physics set), updated=2026-04-17T14:40:05.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDO-FULL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSCI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSH, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT], created=2026-04-17T14:40:05.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=PHYSICS, name=Physics Ontologies, description=Curated multi-source project entry for non-biomedical physics ontologies in MatPortal dev. The project groups foundational measurement ontologies, upper and domain ontologies for physical systems and materials, and ontology resources used to organize physics knowledge and publications., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/PHYSICS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/physics"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":52.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":253.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6181},"ENLIMAO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":3.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/enlimao//enlimao-full.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":2.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/enlimao//releases/2026-01-19/enlimao-full.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":17.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ENLIMAO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Engineered Living Materials Ontology (ELM Ontology) is a PMD-style application ontology for engineered living materials, maintained with the Ontology Development Kit (ODK). It provides modular ontology artifacts (including base/full/edit releases) under the `enlimao` namespace and is designed to model ELM-related materials, process, and data concepts in a machine-readable, interoperable structure.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/sintharic/ELM-Ontology/master/src/ontology/enlimao-full.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"ELM Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"101","omv:numberOfProperties":"38","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ENLIMAO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"51"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:19.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-02-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ENLIMAO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ENLIMAO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ENLIMAO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"16","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/ENLIMAO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ENLIMAO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"75","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ENLIMAO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ENLIMAO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/ENLIMAO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"17"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":56.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/enlimao//enlimao-full.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/enlimao//enlimao-full.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ENLIMAO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://w3id.org/pmd/enlimao.owl#CC-BY-4.0","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://w3id.org/pmd/enlimao.owl#CC-BY-4.0"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ENLIMAO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2026-01-19"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":36.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":225.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4906},"EPOXY_M_LY556_GF":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.materialdigital.de/ontomat/epoxy_m_ly556_gfk_ud"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"EPOXY_M_LY556_GF","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"`epoxy_gfk_ud-0.6` is an OntOMat example ontology for an epoxy-based unidirectional glass-fiber composite. It describes the composite material itself together with associated material and product properties such as density, fiber content, elastic moduli, shear moduli, Poisson ratios, tensile strengths, compressive strengths, and final-product weight.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"epoxy_gfk_ud-0.6","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"34","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"73"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:14.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2025-05-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=EPOXY_M_LY556_GF&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=EPOXY_M_LY556_GF&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"34","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"33"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.materialdigital.de/ontomat/epoxy_m_ly556_gfk_ud","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.materialdigital.de/ontomat/epoxy_m_ly556_gfk_ud"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Martin Koerdel\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/49ece470-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/49ece470-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Patrick Schneider\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/4a0815f0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/4a0815f0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Niklas-Alexander Toffert\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/4a2148e0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/4a2148e0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.6.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":36.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":229.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5714},"EVMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/EvMO.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"EVMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"EvMO is the environmental-monitoring module in SCIMOnto. It represents sensor observations and derived indicators for environmental safety conditions (for example air, smoke, gas, temperature, humidity, noise, and water-related parameters), together with alert levels and associated response actions. The ontology links monitoring areas, sensing devices, analysis outputs, and mitigation workflows in a single semantic model.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/EvMO.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"EvMO","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"382","omv:numberOfProperties":"133","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EVMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"22"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:58.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2026-02-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=EVMO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EVMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EVMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"35","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/EVMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=EVMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"139","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EVMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EVMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/EVMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"39"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/EvMO.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/EvMO.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EVMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"10"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EVMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3805},"FATIGUE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://emmo.info/emmo/domain/fatigue"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"FATIGUE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Fatigue Ontology models concepts for the materials-fatigue domain, especially terminology needed to describe fatigue behavior under cyclic loading together with related materials-mechanics concepts. Its scope includes fatigue-specific entities such as lifetime and limit measures and associated test context used in fatigue-data representation.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Fatigue Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"412","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FATIGUE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:59.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"3","dct:created":"2025-10-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=FATIGUE&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FATIGUE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FATIGUE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"15","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/FATIGUE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=FATIGUE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"222","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FATIGUE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FATIGUE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/FATIGUE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"80"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":16.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":58.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://emmo.info/emmo/domain/fatigue","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://emmo.info/emmo/domain/fatigue"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FATIGUE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"4"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FATIGUE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":19,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":219.0,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4802},"FTO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/lcf-test/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"FTO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Fatigue Test Ontology (FTO) was developed for representing the fatigue testing process, testing equipment requirements, test pieces characteristics, and related testing parameters and their measurement procedure according to DIN EN ISO 12106 standard.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/lcf-test/-/raw/main/FTO2.0.5.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Fatigue Test Process Graph","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/HosseinBeygiNasrabadi/Fatigue-Test-Ontology-FTO-"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"156","omv:numberOfProperties":"17","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"100"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:51.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2025-10-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=FTO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Fatigue Test Ontology (FTO) has developed for representing the fatigue testing process, testing equipment requirements, test pieces charactristics, and related testing parameters and their measurement procedure according to DIN EN ISO 12106 standard.\",\"KupferDigital project (www.materialdigital.de/project/1)\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"17","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=FTO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"86","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/FTO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"29"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/lcf-test/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/lcf-test/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/core-ontology/main/pmd_core.ttl"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/core-ontology/main/pmd_core.ttl","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"6"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Skrotzki, Birgit\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d0ba4790-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d0ba4790-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Beygi Nasrabadi, Hossein (www.orcid.org/0000-0002-3092-0532)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/de0e0b00-edb2-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/de0e0b00-edb2-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2.0.5 (PROV, PMDco)"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMD, name=MaterialDigital / PMD, description=Platform MaterialDigital project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMDAO, name=MaterialDigital / PMD Application Ontologies, description=PMD application ontologies, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":36.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":247.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7287},"GLOSISUNIT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/glosis/model/unit"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://w3id.org/glosis/model/unit/1.5.1"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"GLOSISUNIT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://glosis-ld.github.io/glosis/model/unit/index-en.html","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The GloSIS unit module extends the Global Soil Information System vocabulary with additional units required for laboratory analysis procedures that are not covered in the reused unit vocabulary. It is a specialized unit ontology for interoperable measurement descriptions in earth and soil science workflows., This ontology represents units of measurement used in laboratory analysis procedures of GloSIS that do not feature in the ontology. This ontology is an extension to the Global Soil Information System (GloSIS) v1.0, edited by Tomas Reznik and Katharina Schleidt","omv:resourceLocator":"https://w3id.org/glosis/model/unit/1.5.1","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"GloSIS units of measurement","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/glosis-ld/glosis"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-17T12:19:14.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-04-17T12:19:13.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=GLOSISUNIT&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This module introduces additional units of measurement that are absent from the qudt ontology.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=GLOSISUNIT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"1"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/glosis/model/unit","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/glosis/model/unit"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Metrology Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"Data model for the Global Soil Information System (GloSIS) v1.0, edited by Tomas Reznik and Katharina Schleidt and Africa Soil Profile Database\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.5.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, homePage=https://www.bipm.org/en/measurement-units, institution=MatPortal curation (multi-source metrology set), updated=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CQU, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MASON, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROVO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SIS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SOSA, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSN], created=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=METROLOGY, name=Metrology And Measurement Ontologies, description=Curated multi-source project entry for metrology ontologies in MatPortal dev. The project groups non-biomedical ontologies for units, quantities, dimensional analysis, digital calibration, uncertainty representation, sensor provenance, and measurement-aware domain semantics., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/metrology"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":24,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":236.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4437},"IMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/IMO.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"IMO is the incident-management module in SCIMOnto. It models monitored events, security and safety alert categories, crowd-behavior and incident parameters, sensor and camera evidence, and response roles and actions such as control, coordination, and first-aid handling. The ontology supports formal representation of incident detection and operational response chains.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/IMO.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"IMO","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"399","omv:numberOfProperties":"147","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"22"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:57.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2026-02-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IMO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"36","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/IMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"156","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"39"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/IMO.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/IMO.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"10"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3792},"IOFAV":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202602/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IOFAV","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The IOF Annotation Vocabulary provides the annotation properties used to document IOF ontologies and related resources. It defines metadata and editorial properties for titles, definitions, examples, usage notes, provenance, maturity, and change history so IOF content can be described consistently for both ontology developers and end users.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Industrial Ontology Foundry (IOF) Annotation Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2ccc3350-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2ccc3350-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAV/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-05-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-05-28T18:00:29.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFAV&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAV/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAV/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAV/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFAV&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAV/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAV/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IOFAV","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"1"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAV/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal IOF Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0dfcb470-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0dfcb470-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0e111f50-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0e111f50-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd5721b0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd5721b0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2b536a20-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2b536a20-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAV/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology, institution=Industrial Ontology Foundry, updated=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCERT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCORE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPSS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP], created=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=IOF, name=Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF), description=Project entry for the Industrial Ontologies Foundry ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for industrial interoperability, manufacturing, maintenance, supply chain, certification, planning, and product-service-system use cases., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":245.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7088},"IOFAVMAP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/commonstocoremapping/meta/MappingAnnotationVocabularyToCommons/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202602/core/commonstocoremapping/meta/MappingAnnotationVocabularyToCommons/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IOFAVMAP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This mapping ontology connects the IOF Annotation Vocabulary with the OMG Commons Annotation Vocabulary. It is intended to support reuse of IOF annotation patterns alongside Commons-based ontologies by aligning overlapping annotation properties across the two vocabularies.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/core/commonstocoremapping/meta/MappingAnnotationVocabularyToCommons.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Industrial Ontology Foundry (IOF) Mapping from the IOF Annotation Vocabulary to the Object Management Group (OMG) Commons Ontology Library Annotation Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/f4723ab0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/f4723ab0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/IndustrialOntologyFoundry/IOF"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-05-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"The IOF Mapping Annotation Vocabulary to Commons maps the AV to the Object Management Group (OMG)'s Annotation Vocabulary provided in the Commons Ontology Library. The Commons Annotation Vocabulary is a subset of what is included in the IOF AV, but is used across a number of OMG and other emerging standards and thus the mapping makes it easier to use other Commons library ontologies in an IOF context.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-05-28T18:00:31.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFAVMAP&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFAVMAP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"1"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/commonstocoremapping/meta/MappingAnnotationVocabularyToCommons/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/commonstocoremapping/meta/MappingAnnotationVocabularyToCommons/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/AnnotationVocabulary/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/AnnotationVocabulary/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal IOF Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Elisa Kendall, Thematix Partners LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9cef4a0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9cef4a0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology, institution=Industrial Ontology Foundry, updated=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCERT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCORE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPSS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP], created=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=IOF, name=Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF), description=Project entry for the Industrial Ontologies Foundry ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for industrial interoperability, manufacturing, maintenance, supply chain, certification, planning, and product-service-system use cases., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":248.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6925},"IOFCERT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/certification/Certification/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202602/certification/Certification/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IOFCERT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Certification Ontology models certification and attestation in the IOF suite. It includes concepts for certificates, certifying bodies, attesting agents and roles, certificate granting processes, and the relationships that connect a certificate to the entity, process, or claim it certifies.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/certification/Certification.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Certification Ontology (CO)","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2ccc3350-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2ccc3350-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology/tree/certification/certification"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"129","omv:numberOfProperties":"145","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCERT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-05-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"TBD","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-05-28T18:00:34.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFCERT&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCERT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCERT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"13","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCERT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFCERT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"92","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCERT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCERT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IOFCERT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"15"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/certification/Certification/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/certification/Certification/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCERT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal IOF Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dcbd9430-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dcbd9430-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2e00b440-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2e00b440-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCERT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology, institution=Industrial Ontology Foundry, updated=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCERT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCORE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPSS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP], created=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=IOF, name=Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF), description=Project entry for the Industrial Ontologies Foundry ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for industrial interoperability, manufacturing, maintenance, supply chain, certification, planning, and product-service-system use cases., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":250.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7902},"IOFCMNSMAP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/commonstocoremapping/MappingCommonsToIOF/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202602/core/commonstocoremapping/MappingCommonsToIOF/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IOFCMNSMAP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This mapping ontology aligns the identifier and designator patterns used in the OMG Commons Ontology Library with the corresponding concepts in the IOF Core Ontology. It is intended to help IOF-based models interoperate with Commons-based models by providing explicit mappings for collections, designators, and identifiers.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/core/commonstocoremapping/MappingCommonsToIOF.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Industrial Ontology Foundry (IOF) Mapping the Object Management Group (OMG) Commons Ontology Library (Commons) to the IOF Core Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2ccc3350-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2ccc3350-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"131","omv:numberOfProperties":"168","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-05-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"This ontology maps the OMG Common Ontologies concepts to those of IOF Core.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-05-28T18:00:39.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFCMNSMAP&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"15","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFCMNSMAP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"86","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"16"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/commonstocoremapping/MappingCommonsToIOF/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/commonstocoremapping/MappingCommonsToIOF/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/commonstocoremapping/meta/MappingAnnotationVocabularyToCommons/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Collections/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Designators/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Identifiers/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/TextDatatype/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/commonstocoremapping/meta/MappingAnnotationVocabularyToCommons/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Collections/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Designators/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Identifiers/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/TextDatatype/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal IOF Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Elisa Kendall, Thematix Partners LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9cef4a0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9cef4a0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Milos Drobnjakovic, National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9fabb30-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9fabb30-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"202502"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology, institution=Industrial Ontology Foundry, updated=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCERT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCORE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPSS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP], created=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=IOF, name=Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF), description=Project entry for the Industrial Ontologies Foundry ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for industrial interoperability, manufacturing, maintenance, supply chain, certification, planning, and product-service-system use cases., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":252.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6831},"IOFCORE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202602/core/Core/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IOFCORE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The IOF Core Ontology is the shared mid-level ontology for the Industrial Ontologies Foundry suite. It covers concepts that recur across manufacturing, enterprise, and supply chain settings and provides the common semantic foundation for the more specialized IOF domain ontologies. The ontology is grounded in Basic Formal Ontology (BFO) and includes classes and relations for agents, organizations, processes, material resources, products, capabilities, specifications, measurements, and related information entities.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/core/Core.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Industrial Ontology Foundry (IOF) Core Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2ccc3350-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2ccc3350-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"122","omv:numberOfProperties":"141","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCORE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-05-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"The IOF Core Ontology contains notions found to be common across multiple manufacturing domains. This file is an RDF implementation of these notions. The ontology utilizes the Basic Formal Ontology or BFO as a top-level ontology but also borrows terms from various domain-independent or mid-level ontologies. The purpose of the ontology is to serve as a foundation for ensuring consistency and interoperability across various domain-specific reference ontologies the IOF publishes.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-05-28T18:01:04.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFCORE&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCORE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCORE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"13","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCORE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFCORE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"85","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCORE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCORE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IOFCORE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"14"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCORE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal IOF Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2ad2c5b0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2ad2c5b0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2b15db00-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2b15db00-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2b350ed0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2b350ed0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2b536a20-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2b536a20-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2b7527c0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2b7527c0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2b901440-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2b901440-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2babf7d0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2babf7d0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2bc865a0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2bc865a0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2bed3c70-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2bed3c70-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2c26a050-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2c26a050-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2c441240-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2c441240-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2c5f25d0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2c5f25d0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2c7be7c0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2c7be7c0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCORE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology, institution=Industrial Ontology Foundry, updated=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCERT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCORE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPSS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP], created=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=IOF, name=Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF), description=Project entry for the Industrial Ontologies Foundry ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for industrial interoperability, manufacturing, maintenance, supply chain, certification, planning, and product-service-system use cases., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":250.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7276},"IOFMAINT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/maintenance/Maintenance/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202602/maintenance/Maintenance/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IOFMAINT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The IOF Maintenance Reference Ontology supports semantic interoperability in maintenance activities by providing shared concepts for maintenance management, maintenance procedures, maintenance states, asset failure, and failure modes and effects analysis. It is aligned with the IOF Core ontology and is intended as a reusable reference layer for maintenance-related application ontologies.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/maintenance/Maintenance.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Industrial Ontology Foundry (IOF) Maintenance Reference Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Industrial Ontology Foundry\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/079b32c0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/079b32c0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology/tree/master/maintenance"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"142","omv:numberOfProperties":"144","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-05-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"The purpose of this IOF Maintenance Reference ontology is to support semantic interoperatibility through the use modular ontologies in the maintenance domain. This Ontology contains terms and concepts identified as common in a number of application ontologies for maintenance management, maintenance procedures, asset failure and failure modes and effects analysis. The ontology is aligned with the IOF Core Ontology which is aligned with Basic Formal Ontology and importas terms for other domain independent ontologies.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-05-28T18:01:09.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFMAINT&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"18","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFMAINT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"105","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"16"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/maintenance/Maintenance/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/maintenance/Maintenance/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal IOF Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"IOF Maintenance Working Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/15ecedf0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/15ecedf0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melinda Hodkiewicz, University of Western Australia\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1624a5e0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1624a5e0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Markus Stumptner, University of South Australia\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1639fc40-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1639fc40-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Matt Selway, University of South Australia\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/164e5260-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/164e5260-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Caitlin Woods, University of Western Australia\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1662ebb0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1662ebb0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology, institution=Industrial Ontology Foundry, updated=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCERT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCORE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPSS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP], created=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=IOF, name=Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF), description=Project entry for the Industrial Ontologies Foundry ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for industrial interoperability, manufacturing, maintenance, supply chain, certification, planning, and product-service-system use cases., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":250.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6938},"IOFPP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/productionplanning/ProductionPlanning/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202602/productionplanning/ProductionPlanning/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IOFPP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The IOF Production Planning Reference Ontology is a domain reference ontology for process and production planning across manufacturing settings. It includes concepts for production plans and orders, process plans and steps, machines, operators, tools, inspection and setup processes, and product specifications, and is intended to be extended by industry-specific planning ontologies.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/productionplanning/ProductionPlanning.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"IOF Production Planning Reference Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2ccc3350-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2ccc3350-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/IndustrialOntologies"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"142","omv:numberOfProperties":"143","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-05-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"Production Planning ontology is a domain reference ontology for process and production planning activities within various industries. It includes general terms common for different types of manufacturing industries, such as discrete manufacturing, process manufacturing, batch manufacturing, biomanufacturing, and others. Being reference ontology, it is expacted that users of the production planning ontology will extend its classes in ways compatible with common vocabulary in manufacturing domains, such as aerospace, automotive, food industries, and others.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-05-28T18:01:14.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFPP&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"14","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFPP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"104","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IOFPP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"14"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/productionplanning/ProductionPlanning/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/productionplanning/ProductionPlanning/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal IOF Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fd44b350-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fd44b350-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2c5f25d0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2c5f25d0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fd83b600-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fd83b600-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fda0c0a0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fda0c0a0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fdb79c30-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fdb79c30-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fdcc3a00-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fdcc3a00-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fde24900-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fde24900-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fdf7bae0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fdf7bae0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fe0e46e0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fe0e46e0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology, institution=Industrial Ontology Foundry, updated=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCERT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCORE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPSS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP], created=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=IOF, name=Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF), description=Project entry for the Industrial Ontologies Foundry ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for industrial interoperability, manufacturing, maintenance, supply chain, certification, planning, and product-service-system use cases., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":250.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7033},"IOFPSS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/productservicesystem/ProductServiceSystem/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202602/productservicesystem/ProductServiceSystem/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IOFPSS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Product Service System (PSS) Reference Ontology provides a basis for modelling product-service systems in manufacturing. It covers business models, product families and variants, service specifications, provider and customer roles, resource roles, quality and requirement specifications, and other concepts needed to describe integrated product-service offerings.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/productservicesystem/ProductServiceSystem.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Product Service System (PSS) Reference Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Industrial Ontology Foundry\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ddafc750-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ddafc750-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/IndustrialOntologies/iof"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"263","omv:numberOfProperties":"161","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPSS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-05-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"A basis ontology for enhancing engineering of Product Service System(s) (PSS) in manufacturing, by modelling all the aspects that affect, or could affect a PSS.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-05-28T18:01:18.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFPSS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPSS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPSS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"17","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPSS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFPSS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"224","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPSS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPSS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IOFPSS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"20"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/productservicesystem/ProductServiceSystem/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/productservicesystem/ProductServiceSystem/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/supplychain/SupplyChain/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/supplychain/SupplyChain/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPSS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal IOF Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/21123930-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/21123930-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Dragan Stokic, Institut fuer angewandte Systemtechnik Bremen GmbH (ATB-Bremen)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2148ad50-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2148ad50-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mark Schubert, Parson Europe\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/215f5840-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/215f5840-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Roberto Sala, University of Bergamo\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2175e470-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2175e470-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Dusan Sormaz, Ohio University\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/218a4050-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/218a4050-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ana Teresa Correia, Institut fuer angewandte Systemtechnik Bremen GmbH (ATB-Bremen)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/21a9b420-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/21a9b420-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marcela Vegetti, University of Santa Fe\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/21bea4d0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/21bea4d0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Todd Schneider, Engineering Semantics\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/21d391e0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/21d391e0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gabriela Henning, CONICET\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/21f1a4b0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/21f1a4b0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPSS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology, institution=Industrial Ontology Foundry, updated=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCERT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCORE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPSS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP], created=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=IOF, name=Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF), description=Project entry for the Industrial Ontologies Foundry ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for industrial interoperability, manufacturing, maintenance, supply chain, certification, planning, and product-service-system use cases., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":250.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6959},"IOFSUPPLY":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/supplychain/SupplyChain/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202602/supplychain/SupplyChain/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IOFSUPPLY","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The IOF Supply Chain Ontology represents the generic constructs needed for supply chain and logistics scenarios. It extends the IOF semantic stack based on BFO and IOF Core with concepts for trading partners, supply relationships, movement and storage of goods, logistics planning, facilities, and related processes, providing a reference model for interoperable supply chain ontologies.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/supplychain/SupplyChain.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Industrial Ontology Foundry (IOF) Supply Chain Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Industrial Ontology Foundry\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ddafc750-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ddafc750-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/industrial-ontologies/supplychain"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"235","omv:numberOfProperties":"160","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-05-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-05-28T18:01:24.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFSUPPLY&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"21","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFSUPPLY&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"198","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"20"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/supplychain/SupplyChain/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/supplychain/SupplyChain/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal IOF Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dcbd9430-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dcbd9430-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2c5f25d0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2c5f25d0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dcefab10-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dcefab10-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Arkopaul Sarkar, National Institute of Standards and Technology\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd0693a0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd0693a0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ali Hasanzadeh, Arizona State University\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd21b820-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd21b820-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd40d4c0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd40d4c0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd5721b0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd5721b0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd6da1b0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd6da1b0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Farhad Ameri, Arizona State University\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd866f80-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd866f80-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology, institution=Industrial Ontology Foundry, updated=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCERT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCORE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPSS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP], created=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=IOF, name=Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF), description=Project entry for the Industrial Ontologies Foundry ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for industrial interoperability, manufacturing, maintenance, supply chain, certification, planning, and product-service-system use cases., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":250.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6928},"IOFTIMEMAP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/commonstocoremapping/MappingOWLTimeToIOF/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202602/core/commonstocoremapping/MappingOWLTimeToIOF/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IOFTIMEMAP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This mapping ontology aligns W3C OWL-Time with the temporal model used in the IOF suite. It supports interoperability between IOF-based models and OWL-Time-based ontologies by linking common temporal concepts such as intervals, instants, and related time descriptions.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/core/owltimetocoremapping/MappingTimeToIOF.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Industrial Ontology Foundry (IOF) Mapping the OWL Time (W3C) to the IOF Core Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Industrial Ontology Foundry\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/079b32c0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/079b32c0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"24","omv:numberOfProperties":"58","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"17"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-05-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"This ontology maps some concepts of the OWL Time (https://www.w3.org/TR/owl-time/) to corresponding concepts of IOF Core to enable IOF Core to associate calendar date and clock time to a Time Instant as well as a measurement of duration to a Time Interval based on various reference systems, e.g., calendar and clock systems) and units, e.g., hour, minute, second.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-05-28T18:01:28.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFTIMEMAP&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"5","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOFTIMEMAP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"4","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"8"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/commonstocoremapping/MappingOWLTimeToIOF/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/commonstocoremapping/MappingOWLTimeToIOF/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/, http://www.w3.org/2006/time]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/, http://www.w3.org/2006/time]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"3"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal IOF Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Arkopaul Sarkar, École Nationale d\\u2019Ingénieurs de Tarbes (ENIT)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/07369b70-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/07369b70-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jim Logan, No Magic, Inc.\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/07683760-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/07683760-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Milos Drobnjakovic, National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9fabb30-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9fabb30-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology, institution=Industrial Ontology Foundry, updated=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFAVMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCERT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCMNSMAP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFCORE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFMAINT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFPSS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFSUPPLY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOFTIMEMAP], created=2026-04-16T14:33:35.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=IOF, name=Industrial Ontologies Foundry (IOF), description=Project entry for the Industrial Ontologies Foundry ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for industrial interoperability, manufacturing, maintenance, supply chain, certification, planning, and product-service-system use cases., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/IOF, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":250.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6999},"KNOWNOW":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/KnowNow"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"KNOWNOW","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/KNOWNOW\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"KnowNow Ontology is a PMDco-based project ontology from the Know Now context, intended to represent materials-science entities and their process/measurement relationships with PMD-compatible semantics. The `noindividuals` release emphasizes reusable TBox concepts for integration into project knowledge graphs without bundled instance data.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"KnowNow_Ontology-noindividuals","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"173","omv:numberOfProperties":"97","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:38:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-02-06T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=KNOWNOW&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The PMD Core Ontology (PMDco) is a comprehensive framework for representing knowledge that encompasses fundamental concepts from the domains of materials science and engineering (MSE). The PMDco has been designed as a mid-level ontology to establish a connection between specific MSE application ontologies and the domain neutral concepts found in established top-level ontologies. The primary goal of the PMDco is to promote interoperability between diverse domains. PMDco's class structure is both understandable and extensible, making it an efficient tool for organizing MSE knowledge. It serves as a semantic intermediate layer that unifies MSE knowledge representations, enabling data and metadata to be systematically integrated on key terms within the MSE domain. With PMDco, it is possible to seamlessly trace data generation. The design of PMDco is based on the W3C Provenance Ontology (PROV-O), which provides a standard framework for capturing the generation, derivation, and attribution of resources. By building on this foundation, PMDco facilitates the integration of data from various sources and the creation of complex workflows. In summary, PMDco is a valuable tool for researchers and practitioners in the MSE domains. It provides a common language for representing and sharing knowledge, allowing for efficient collaboration and promoting interoperability between diverse domains. Its design allows for the systematic integration of data and metadata, enabling seamless traceability of data generation. Overall, PMDco is a crucial step towards a unified and comprehensive understanding of the MSE domain. PMDco at GitHub: https://github.com/materialdigital/core-ontology\",\"Ontology of project Know Now\",\"Based on Platform Material Digital Core Ontology (pmdco) https://w3id.org/pmd/co\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"12","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=KNOWNOW&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"56","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"28"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/KnowNow","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/ontologies/KnowNow"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/KNOWNOW\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"7"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2.0.0-alpha2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":226.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3479},"KUPDIGI":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/ontologies/mechanical-testing-ontology/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"KUPDIGI","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/KUPFERDIGITAL\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"KupferDigital Ontology represents copper-material and process knowledge for the KupferDigital data space, including life-cycle entities and mechanical-testing semantics reused from modules such as FTO, MTO, TTO, and TSRTO. It supports semantically integrated publication and querying of heterogeneous copper-related datasets across processing, characterization, and application contexts.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/materialdigital1_ontology_collection/main/KupferDigital/tbox/KupferDigital_rdflib/KupferDigital.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"KupferDigital Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"567","omv:numberOfProperties":"133","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"309"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:24.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-02-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=KUPDIGI&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Tensile Stress Relaxation Test Ontology (TSRTO) has developed for representing the tensile stress relaxation testing process, testing equipment requirements, test pieces charactristics, and related testing parameters and their measurement procedure according to DIN EN ISO 10319-1 standard.\",\"KuferDigital project (www.materialdigital.de/project/1)\",\"Fatigue Test Ontology (FTO) has developed for representing the fatigue testing process, testing equipment requirements, test pieces charactristics, and related testing parameters and their measurement procedure according to DIN EN ISO 12106 standard.\",\"The materials mechanical testing ontology (MTO) was developed by collecting the mechanical testing vocabulary from ISO 23718 standard, as well as the standardized testing processes described for various mechanical testing of materials like tensile testing, Brinell hardness test, Vickers hardness test, stress relaxation test, and fatigue testing.\",\"Tensile Test Ontology (BTO) has developed for representing the tensile testing process, testing equipment requirements, test pieces charactristics, and related testing parameters and their measurement procedure according to DIN EN ISO 6892-1 standard.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"32","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=KUPDIGI&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"276","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"100"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/ontologies/mechanical-testing-ontology/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/ontologies/mechanical-testing-ontology/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/pmd/co, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o-inverses#, https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/core-ontology/main/pmd_core.ttl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/pmd/co, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o-inverses#, https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/core-ontology/main/pmd_core.ttl]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/KUPFERDIGITAL\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"7"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Hossein Beygi Nasrabadi (www.orcid.org/0000-0002-3092-0532)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c1581110-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c1581110-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"3.0.2 (BPROV, PMDco)"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_KUPFERDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:23.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI], created=2026-02-16T21:34:23.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_KUPFERDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital / KupferDigital, description=MaterialDigital subproject KupferDigital, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_KUPFERDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":36.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":245.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7332},"LDO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cdos/ldo"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cdos/ldo/1.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"LDO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/OCDO/ldo","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Line Defect Ontology (LDO) is a crystalline-defects ontology focused on one-dimensional defects such as dislocations and disclinations. It provides line-defect classes and related descriptors for interoperable representation of line-defect phenomena in computational and experimental materials datasets.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/OCDO/ldo/main/ldo.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Line Defect Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/OCDO/ldo"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LDO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:02:10.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=LDO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LDO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LDO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/LDO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=LDO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LDO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LDO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/LDO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cdos/ldo","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cdos/ldo"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LDO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7564-7990\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/397e6d90-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/397e6d90-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6776-1213\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39feaa70-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39feaa70-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9560-4728\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a154560-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a154560-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LDO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, homePage=https://nfdi-matwerk.de/solutions/all-solutions/semantics, institution=NFDI-MatWerk, updated=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ASMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMEO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CMSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MWO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PLDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PODO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RDOC], created=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NFDIMATWERK, name=NFDI-MatWerk Semantic Resources, description=Project entry for NFDI-MatWerk semantic resources curated in MatPortal dev. The project groups ontologies that are directly NFDI-MatWerk authored, NFDI-MatWerk infrastructure-use-case resources, or NFDI-MatWerk-listed semantic resources relevant to materials science and engineering interoperability., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/nfdimatwerk"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":236.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4864},"LOG":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/log/log-full.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/log/1.0.2"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"LOG","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://w3id.org/pmd/log","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Platform Material Digital Logistics Application Ontology aligns IOF supply-chain semantics with PMD Core to represent logistics and supply-chain concepts in a PMD-compatible form. It provides reusable classes and relations for materials-related supply-chain data, enabling consistent semantic integration across planning, transport, and logistics information flows., This is an alignment of the IOF Supply Chain Ontologies Library to the Platform Material Digital Core Ontology. It contains ontologies to be used in the domain of supply chain and logistics.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://w3id.org/pmd/log/","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Platform Material Digital Application Ontology  for Logistics and supplychain","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/logistics-application-ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"208","omv:numberOfProperties":"89","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"36"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-18T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-04-18T18:00:19.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=LOG&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The logistics application ontology for use with PMD Core Ontology (PMDco). The scope of this module is the description of material science and engineering related logistics and general organization. Its is adopted from the IOF SupplyChain Module https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/supplychain/SupplyChain/\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"27","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=LOG&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"21","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/LOG","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"16"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/log/log-full.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/log/log-full.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Thomas Hanke\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/783c9370-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/783c9370-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMD, name=MaterialDigital / PMD, description=Platform MaterialDigital project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMDAO, name=MaterialDigital / PMD Application Ontologies, description=PMD application ontologies, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":51.0,"normalizedScore":35,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":254.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6644},"LPBFO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.emi.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/LPBFO"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://gitlab.cc-asp.fraunhofer.de/EMI_datamanagement/emilio/-/raw/master/LPBFO.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"LPBFO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The LPBF Ontology can be used to describe the additive manufacturing of a component via Laser Powder Bed Fusion (LPBF) / Selective Laser Melting (SLM). The ontology builds on BFO2.0 and BWMD_mid and has been developed to be used in conjunction with the digital workflows provided by Fraunhofer IWM. If possible, the terminology within this ontology was used as provided by ISO/ASTM 52900:2015.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Laser Powder Bed Fusion Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"509","omv:numberOfProperties":"41","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T22:39:37.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2025-10-25T15:28:36.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=LPBFO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Contact:\\nMartin Huschka \\nFraunhofer Institute for High-Speed Dynamics , Ernst-Mach-Institut, EMI\\nErnst-Zermelo-Strasse 4, 79104 Freiburg , Germany\\nMartin.Huschka@EMI.Fraunhofer.de\",\"Contact:\\nMartin Jäcklein\\nFraunhofer Institute for High-Speed Dynamics , Ernst-Mach-Institut, EMI\\nErnst-Zermelo-Strasse 4, 79104 Freiburg , Germany\\nMartin.Huschka@EMI.Fraunhofer.de\",\"The LPBF Ontology can be used to describe the additive manufacturing of a component via Laser Powder Bed Fusion (LPBF) / Selective Laser Melting (SLM). The ontology builds on BFO2.0 and BWMD_mid and has been developed to be used in conjunction with the digital workflows provided by Fraunhofer IWM. If possible, the terminology within this ontology was used as provided by ISO/ASTM 52900:2015. Historically, it was created as LPBFO ontology; an ontology that described the SLM process at Fraunhofer EMI. However, it is now being used for other applications as well, some leftovers named EMISLM might still be apparent until being updated.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"24","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=LPBFO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"36","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/LPBFO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"88"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":16.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.emi.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/LPBFO","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.emi.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/LPBFO"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"beta"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.materials.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/BWMD_ontology/mid, https://www.emi.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/LPBFO]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.materials.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/BWMD_ontology/mid, https://www.emi.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/LPBFO]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.1.8"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/ADAM, homePage=https://am-data-space.de/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=ADAM, name=KMU-akut: ADAM, description=Um die Innovations- und Wettbewerbsfähigkeit deutscher kleiner und mittlerer Unternehmen (KMU) zu steigern, bedarf es konzertierter Anstrengungen zur Digitalisierung der Wertschöpfungsketten. Dabei sind Einzelinitiativen von KMU aus systemischer Perspektive meist nicht zielführend, sowie technologisch und finanziell kaum stemmbar. Für die Domäne der Additiven Fertigung (AM) soll im Projekt »ADAM«, als Teil des Fraunhofer-Programms »KMU-akut«, ein Cluster entstehen, das die Bedarfe von KMU aus AM-Wertschöpfungsketten erhebt und systematisch mit industrietauglichen Fraunhofer- Technologien deckt. Das Konsortium aus Fraunhofer-Instituten stellt dabei das nötige Technologiespektrum bereit, um maßgeschneiderte, KMU-spezifische Lösungen gleichzeitig in ein übergeordnetes Gesamtkonzept zur Digitalisierung zu integrieren. Eine dynamische Ausrichtung der Forschungsaktivitäten der Institute\r\ngemäß der erhobenen KMU-Bedarfe soll den direkten Technologietransfer zusätzlich stärken.\r\n\r\nDas Cluster bildet den Nukleus für ein »Datenökosystem AM«, das erhebliche Effizienzsteigerungen, sowie neuartige digitale Produkte, Dienstleistungen und Geschäftsmodelle ermöglicht. Technisch auf den International Data Spaces (IDS) basierend, sichert die digitale Infrastruktur die Datensouveränität und den Wissensvorsprung der beteiligten Unternehmen., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/ADAM, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/AluTrace, homePage=https://github.com/Mat-O-Lab/AluTrace-Data-and-Documentation, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=AluTrace, name=AluTrace, description=Digitalisierung der Prozesskette additiv gefertigter Aluminiumleichtbaukomponenten.\r\n\r\nAdditive Fertigung (AM) bietet aufgrund großer Designfreiheiten ein enormes Leichtbaupotenzial und wird deshalb im Anlagen- und Maschinenbau, im Fahrzeugbau und in der Luft- und Raumfahrt in immer mehr Bereichen eingesetzt. Vom Rohmaterial bis zum fertigen Bauteil durchlaufen die Zwischenprodukte mehrere Wertschöpfungsstufen und dabei meist mehrere Unternehmen. Für eine maximale Ausschöpfung des Leichtbaupotenzials müssen Wissensverluste zwischen den einzelnen Wertschöpfungsstufen verhindert werden, um durchgängig eine möglichst genaue Kenntnis des Werkstoffs, des Bauteils und des Fertigungsprozesses zu erhalten. So können Design und Produktion in wirtschaftlicher und ökologischer Hinsicht weiter optimiert werden.\r\n\r\nZiel des Forschungsprojekts AluTrace ist es deshalb, die über Produktentwicklungs- und -herstellungszyklen entstehenden Daten- und Wissensinseln digital zu verknüpfen. Das Konsortium aus dem Fraunhofer EMI, dem Fraunhofer IWM sowie dem fem Forschungsinstitut Edelmetalle + Metallchemie untersucht am Beispiel additiver Fertigung, wie die durchgängige Nutzbarmachung von Daten und Wissen zum Werkstoff, dem Fertigungsprozess und zu den Bauteilanforderungen zur Optimierung von Aluminiumleichtbaustrukturen beitragen kann. Dazu werden dezentral vorliegende Werkstoff- und Werkstoffprozessdaten gezielt ergänzt, semantisch durch Wissensgraphen beschrieben und mithilfe der Technologie der International Data Spaces (IDS) vernetzt.\r\n\r\nFür eine Ergebnisverbreitung in die Wirtschaft wird das Konsortium von einem industriellen Beirat aus namhaften Unternehmen begleitet, darunter Dienstleister im Bereich von additivem Design und Fertigung, Metallverarbeitung sowie Anbieter von Leichtbauprodukten und KI-Lösungen. Das Projekt wird mit rund 400 000 Euro vom Ministerium für Wirtschaft, Arbeit und Wohnungsbau Baden-Württemberg gefördert und hat eine Laufzeit von 15 Monaten.\r\n, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/AluTrace, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/DMD4Future, homePage=https://www.materials.fraunhofer.de/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=DMD4Future, name=DMD4Future, description=Fraunhofer-internen Innovationsprogramms setzte sich mit der digitalisierten Material- und Datenwertschöpfungskette auseinander.\r\n\r\nIm Projekt DMD4Future wurden neue datenbasierte Technologiekompetenzen zur Beschreibung und Optimierung in und entlang der unterschiedlichen Phasen des Material- und Produktlebenszyklus erarbeitet. Darüber hinaus wurde die Basis für datengetriebene Geschäftsmodelle sowie für digitale Mehrwertangebote in der Materialwirtschaft vorbereitet., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/DMD4Future, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/Mat-O-Lab, homePage=https://matolab.materials.digital/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:23.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSEO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:23.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=Mat-O-Lab, name=Materials Open Laboratory, description=Joint Venture Between Fraunhofer MATERIALS and BAM, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/Mat-O-Lab, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":253.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4109},"MAO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/MAO"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MAO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Fraunhofer IGCV Manufacturing Application Ontology is a manufacturing-domain ontology developed in the ODE_AM context and grounded in BFO and CCO. It provides manufacturing concepts spanning materials, processes, equipment, and quality-related entities, and acts as the central base module that is extended by AM-specific ODE_AM ontologies.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/MAO","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Fraunhofer IGCV Manufacturing Application Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/MaterialDigital/ODE_AM"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"146","omv:numberOfProperties":"28","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"11"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:08.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-02-06T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MAO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology, developed for use at Fraunhofer IGCV, comprises a detailed collection of entities and their associated descriptions, tailored to support a range of projects like ODE_AM and HybridDigital within the manufacturing domain. It includes specific categories such as materials, processes, machinery, and quality standards, all of which are vital for research and development in advanced manufacturing techniques.\",\"It uses Basic Formal Ontology as Top- and Common Core Ontologies as Mid-Level-Ontologies.\",\"This ontology, designed for use in data management within the Fraunhofer IGCV's project-specific web-app, includes only those classes that are directly relevant to the project's needs. It primarily integrates existing classes from the Basic Formal Ontology (BFO) and the Common Core Ontologies (CCO), selectively chosen to fit the considered use cases in our project. This focused approach ensures efficient and relevant data categorization and retrieval tailored to our specific project requirements.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"23","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MAO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"89","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MAO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"27"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/MAO","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/MAO"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://protege.stanford.edu/plugins/owl/dc/protege-dc.owl"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://protege.stanford.edu/plugins/owl/dc/protege-dc.owl","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"4"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Thomas Bjarsch\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/73a69880-edb4-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/73a69880-edb4-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_ODE_AM, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:26.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:26.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_ODE_AM, name=MaterialDigital / ODE_AM, description=MaterialDigital subproject ODE_AM, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_ODE_AM, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMD, name=MaterialDigital / PMD, description=Platform MaterialDigital project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMDAO, name=MaterialDigital / PMD Application Ontologies, description=PMD application ontologies, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":36.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":238.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6396},"MASON":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.owl-ontologies.com/mason.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MASON","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"MASON is an ontology of tools, processes, and concepts in industrial manufacturing. It is included in the metrology slice as a manufacturing-domain ontology that can contextualize measurement and process information in production settings.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://sourceforge.net/projects/mason-onto/files/mason-onto/1.0/mason.owl/download","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"MASON","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"246","omv:numberOfProperties":"55","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MASON/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"102"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-17T12:19:20.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-04-17T12:19:19.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MASON&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MASON/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MASON/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"19","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MASON/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MASON&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"220","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MASON/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MASON/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MASON","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"16"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.owl-ontologies.com/mason.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.owl-ontologies.com/mason.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://www.w3.org/2003/11/swrl"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://www.w3.org/2003/11/swrl","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MASON/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"7"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Metrology Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MASON/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, homePage=https://www.bipm.org/en/measurement-units, institution=MatPortal curation (multi-source metrology set), updated=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CQU, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MASON, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROVO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SIS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SOSA, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSN], created=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=METROLOGY, name=Metrology And Measurement Ontologies, description=Curated multi-source project entry for metrology ontologies in MatPortal dev. The project groups non-biomedical ontologies for units, quantities, dimensional analysis, digital calibration, uncertainty representation, sensor provenance, and measurement-aware domain semantics., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/metrology"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":229.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3722},"MATONTO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://matonto.org/ontologies/matonto"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":6.0,"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"http://www.ifomis.org/bfo/1.0"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MATONTO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://obofoundry.org/ro/","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"MatOnto is a general domain ontology for materials science published as a reusable ontology set in Turtle. It is broad in scope rather than tied to a single test or process and serves as a materials-science ontology collection for representing materials-related knowledge.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"MatOnto Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Institute for Formal Ontology and Medical Information Science (IFOMIS)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/7958d520-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/7958d520-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"iNovex Information Systems, MatOnto Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/796d0770-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/796d0770-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Dumontier Lab\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/79829750-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/79829750-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/inovexcorp/MatOnto-Ontologies"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"848","omv:numberOfProperties":"96","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MATONTO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"131"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:41.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"6","dct:created":"2021-01-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MATONTO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MATONTO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MATONTO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"17","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/MATONTO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MATONTO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"351","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MATONTO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MATONTO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MATONTO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"121"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://matonto.org/ontologies/matonto","dct:identifier":"http://www.ifomis.org/bfo/1.0"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://matonto.org/ontologies/matonto"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"beta"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":104.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MATONTO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"10"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Bryan Miller"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mykola Konyk\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/7826a860-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/7826a860-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Michel Dumontier\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/783e4d70-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/783e4d70-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"MatOnto Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/7855b060-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/7855b060-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Holger Stenzhorn\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/786c9db0-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/786c9db0-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ryan Gibbons\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/78d7e100-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/78d7e100-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Andrew Spear\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/78f16cd0-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/78f16cd0-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MATONTO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"3.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":8110},"MD012":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.dipromag.de/dipromag_onto/0.1/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MD012","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/DIPROMAG\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://www.dipromag.de/ottr-templates/","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"DiProMag Ontology formalizes the process chain for production, characterization, and prototypical use of magnetocaloric alloys. It is generated from OTTR templates and provides a structured TBox for representing process parameters, measurements, and material-specific entities in the DiProMag knowledge framework.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/materialdigital1_ontology_collection/main/DiProMag/tbox/dipromag_onto_01.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"DiProMag Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"316","omv:numberOfProperties":"5","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"37"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:34.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"3","dct:created":"2023-12-18T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MD012&q=","schema:comment":"[\"An Ontolgoy for the Digitization of a process chain for the production, characterization and prototypical application of magnetocaloric alloys. This ontology was modelled via OTTR Templates and is automatically generated. You can find the templates under the URL: https://www.dipromag.de/ottr-templates/\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"27","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MD012&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"310","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MD012","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"96"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.dipromag.de/dipromag_onto/0.1/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.dipromag.de/dipromag_onto/0.1/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/DIPROMAG\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"3"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Basil Ell\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/59931e00-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/59931e00-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Moritz Blum\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/59ab2dd0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/59ab2dd0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Basil Ell\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/59931e00-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/59931e00-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Moritz Blum\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/59ab2dd0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/59ab2dd0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Martin Wortmann\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/59fabb40-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/59fabb40-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Andreas Hütten\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5a0f9970-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5a0f9970-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Simon Bekemeier\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5a2b33a0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5a2b33a0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tapas Samanta\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5a4536d0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5a4536d0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sonja Schöning\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5a6d43d0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5a6d43d0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Philipp Cimiano\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5a915f60-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5a915f60-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Thomas Hilbig\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5aafc170-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5aafc170-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Michael Feige\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5acce770-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5acce770-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lennart Schwan\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5aeb17a0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5aeb17a0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Inga Ennen\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5b003930-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5b003930-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Luana Caron\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5b1653a0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5b1653a0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Christian Schröder\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5b358a00-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5b358a00-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alisa Chirkova\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5b4a4810-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5b4a4810-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Günter Reiss\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5b64cd10-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5b64cd10-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_DIPROMAG, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:23.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012], created=2026-02-16T21:34:23.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_DIPROMAG, name=MaterialDigital / DiProMag, description=MaterialDigital subproject DiProMag, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_DIPROMAG, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":51.0,"normalizedScore":35,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":263.0,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5899},"MDO-FULL":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/mdo/full/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/mdo/full/1.0/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MDO-FULL","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/mdo/full/1.0/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/huanyu-li/Materials-Design-Ontology","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Materials Design Ontology (MDO) models domain knowledge for materials design with a particular focus on solid-state physics and computational materials science. The full release combines the core, structure, calculation, and provenance parts of MDO so materials structures, computational methods, and related provenance information can be described in one ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://liusemweb.github.io/mdo/full/1.1/mdo-full.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Materials Design Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/Materials-Design-Ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"mdo","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDO-FULL/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:02:19.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MDO-FULL&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This is the Materials Design Ontology.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDO-FULL/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDO-FULL/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/MDO-FULL/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MDO-FULL&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDO-FULL/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDO-FULL/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MDO-FULL","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":85,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/mdo/full/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/mdo/full/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/mdo/calculation/, https://w3id.org/mdo/core/, https://w3id.org/mdo/provenance/, https://w3id.org/mdo/structure/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/mdo/calculation/, https://w3id.org/mdo/core/, https://w3id.org/mdo/provenance/, https://w3id.org/mdo/structure/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDO-FULL/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://github.com/huanyu-li/Materials-Design-Ontology/blob/master/LICENSE","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://github.com/huanyu-li/Materials-Design-Ontology/blob/master/LICENSE"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Huanyu Li"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Huanyu Li\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ee97be10-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ee97be10-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Rickard Armiento\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/eeef66b0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/eeef66b0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Patrick Lambrix\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ef03fb90-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ef03fb90-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDO-FULL/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/PHYSICS, homePage=https://physh.org/, institution=MatPortal curation (multi-source physics set), updated=2026-04-17T14:40:05.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDO-FULL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSCI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSH, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT], created=2026-04-17T14:40:05.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=PHYSICS, name=Physics Ontologies, description=Curated multi-source project entry for non-biomedical physics ontologies in MatPortal dev. The project groups foundational measurement ontologies, upper and domain ontologies for physical systems and materials, and ontology resources used to organize physics knowledge and publications., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/PHYSICS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/physics"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":52.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":259.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":8516},"MECH":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/materials-mechanics-ontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/materials-mechanics-ontology/1.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MECH","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://materialdigital.github.io/materials-mechanics-ontology","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The materials-mechanics ontology focuses mainly on adding concepts related to the fatigue domain. In addition to it, the ontology also describes more general concepts from MSE like crystallographic defects and microstructural entities. The ontology builds up on and imports PMDco v2.0.4.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://w3id.org/pmd/materials-mechanics-ontology","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Materials Mechanics Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/materials-mechanics-ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MECH/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:02:25.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MECH&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The materials mechanics ontology is an application-level ontology that was created for supporting named entity recognition tasks for materials fatigue domain. The ontology covers some fairly general MSE concepts that could prospectively be merged into PMDco or other upper materials ontologies such as descriptions of crystallographic defects and microstructural entities. Furthermore, concepts related to the materials fatigue subdomain are also heavily incorporated.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MECH/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MECH/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/MECH/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MECH&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MECH/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MECH/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MECH","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/materials-mechanics-ontology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/materials-mechanics-ontology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MECH/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0916-5990\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9d37b80-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9d37b80-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0744-8855\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9e9b100-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9e9b100-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MECH/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":244.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5753},"MM":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://materialsmine.org/ns"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://materialsmine.org/ns/1.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MM","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"MaterialsMine is a materials ontology for publishing data involving nanomaterials and metamaterials. It provides the semantic model used in the MaterialsMine ecosystem to organize materials entities and related publication metadata for structured description and reuse of curated materials datasets.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"MaterialsMine","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/Duke-MatSci/nanomine"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2149","omv:numberOfProperties":"325","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MM/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"107"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:05.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2021-10-19T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MM&q=","schema:comment":"[\"A materials ontology to support data publication involving nanomaterials and metamaterials.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MM/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MM/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"235","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/MM/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MM&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1803","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MM/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MM/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MM","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"118"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://materialsmine.org/ns","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://materialsmine.org/ns"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://semanticscience.org/ontology/sio.owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://semanticscience.org/ontology/sio.owl]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MM/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"13"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Jamie McCusker"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://tw.rpi.edu/instances/LiweiWang\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/51cbf600-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/51cbf600-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0752-6406\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/51e25970-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/51e25970-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8995-0050\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/51f84540-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/51f84540-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1085-6059\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/520ee840-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/520ee840-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5510-7863\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5225c3b0-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5225c3b0-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://tw.rpi.edu/instances/PurnaBoddapati\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/523cc410-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/523cc410-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5172-1196\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/52579960-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/52579960-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5296-4440\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/526f2530-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/526f2530-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://tw.rpi.edu/instances/UmarGhumman\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/52893610-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/52893610-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4653-7124\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/529f5090-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/529f5090-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7277-0069\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/52b4f3d0-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/52b4f3d0-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2551-1563\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/52c88d80-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/52c88d80-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8034-0667\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/52de1440-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/52de1440-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4162-8334\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/52f56930-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/52f56930-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7037-4567\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/530b48d0-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/530b48d0-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0366-8332\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/532293e0-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/532293e0-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4283-2780\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5338eb50-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5338eb50-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9081-6334\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5350e440-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5350e440-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6406-5247\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/53642c10-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/53642c10-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2061-2261\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5379aa30-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5379aa30-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MM/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":29.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":245.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7298},"MOCO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://matolab.org/ontology/container#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://gitlab.cc-asp.fraunhofer.de/fraunhofer-iwm-hub-materialdigital/semantic-containers/-/raw/master/ontologies/moco.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MOCO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Mat-O-Lab container ontology is a lightweight ontology for describing the structure of tabular or series data stored in HDF5 containers. It has already been used to represent time-force-displacement data from tensile tests and is open to extension for more complex data series such as sequences of DIC images.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Mat-O-Lab container ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"4","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOCO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:12.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2021-07-15T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MOCO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology is released under a Creative Commons license Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOCO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOCO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/MOCO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MOCO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOCO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOCO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MOCO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":16.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://matolab.org/ontology/container#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://matolab.org/ontology/container#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"beta"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOCO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Philipp von Hartrott"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Akhil Thomas\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/97e7a960-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/97e7a960-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Elena Trelles\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/97fcfbe0-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/97fcfbe0-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Philipp von Hartrott\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9811ea50-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9811ea50-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sascha Fliegner\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9826cf40-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9826cf40-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Fraunhofer IWM, DE\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9878dc00-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9878dc00-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOCO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/Mat-O-Lab, homePage=https://matolab.materials.digital/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:23.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSEO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:23.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=Mat-O-Lab, name=Materials Open Laboratory, description=Joint Venture Between Fraunhofer MATERIALS and BAM, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/Mat-O-Lab, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":26,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":238.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5724},"MOL_BRINELL":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purl.matolab.org/mseo/methods/example/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MOL_BRINELL","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://mat-o-lab.github.io/MSEO/ontology_cards/MOL_BRINELL.html","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"MatoLab Brinell Test Ontology describes the Brinell hardness-testing process in the Materials Open Lab project. It is a domain ontology for semantically representing Brinell test workflows and the data produced in that testing context.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"MatoLab Brinell Test Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/HosseinBeygiNasrabadi/Brinell-Test-Ontology-BTO-"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"37","omv:numberOfProperties":"21","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOL_BRINELL/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"3277"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:02.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2022-05-05T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MOL_BRINELL&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOL_BRINELL/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOL_BRINELL/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"5","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/MOL_BRINELL/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MOL_BRINELL&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"37","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOL_BRINELL/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOL_BRINELL/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MOL_BRINELL","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"23"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purl.matolab.org/mseo/methods/example/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purl.matolab.org/mseo/methods/example/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"beta"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOL_BRINELL/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"yue chen"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yue Chen\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/132750e0-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/132750e0-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Philipp von Hartrott\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/133b3850-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/133b3850-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Birgit Skrotzki\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/134daaa0-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/134daaa0-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Hossein Beygi Nasrabadi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1362f130-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1362f130-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Vinicius Carrillo Beber\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/137827c0-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/137827c0-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOL_BRINELL/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":29.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":224.0,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5913},"MOL_TENSILE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.materials.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/MoL_TensileTest"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://gitlab.cc-asp.fraunhofer.de/hart/matolab_mechanik/-/raw/master/mol_tt.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MOL_TENSILE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://materialdigital.github.io/tensile-test-ontology","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Matolab Tensile Test Ontology describes the tensile-test process in the Materials Open Lab project. It is a domain ontology for semantically representing tensile-test workflows and the data produced in that testing context.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Matolab Tensile Test Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/tensile-test-ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"372","omv:numberOfProperties":"97","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOL_TENSILE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"20"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T22:49:27.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2021-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MOL_TENSILE&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology was created by: Team Mechanik - Mat-O-Lab Materials <d74c5619.fraunhofer.onmicrosoft.com@emea.teams.ms>\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOL_TENSILE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOL_TENSILE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"23","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/MOL_TENSILE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MOL_TENSILE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"50","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOL_TENSILE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOL_TENSILE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MOL_TENSILE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"88"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.materials.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/MoL_TensileTest","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.materials.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/MoL_TensileTest"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"beta"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.materials.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/BWMD_ontology/mid]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.materials.fraunhofer.de/ontologies/BWMD_ontology/mid]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOL_TENSILE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Philipp von Hartrott, Markus Schilling]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOL_TENSILE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":250.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4057},"MOP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/mop.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/mop/releases/2022-05-11/mop.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MOP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEM_PROPERTIES\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEM_METHODS\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEMISTRY\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/NFDI4CAT\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/NFDI4CHEM\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Molecular Process Ontology (MOP) models general molecular process types (for example addition, cyclization, polymerization, methylation, and demethylation) and acts as a foundational module for reaction ontologies such as RXNO. It provides process-level semantics for machine-readable representation of molecular transformations and catalytic process relationships.","omv:resourceLocator":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/mop.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Methods and Properties Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"3686","omv:numberOfProperties":"11","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:04.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"13","dct:created":"2026-02-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MOP&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"43","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/MOP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MOP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"99","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MOP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"168"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/mop.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/mop.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEM_PROPERTIES\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEM_METHODS\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEMISTRY\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/NFDI4CAT\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/NFDI4CHEM\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"12"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/chemistry"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":254.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4815},"MP-SCHM":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/semmd/v0.6/schma/mpschm"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MP-SCHM","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"MP-SCHM is a lightweight schema ontology of annotation properties for material-property descriptions, including Dublin Core terms. It provides the metadata properties used to attach bibliographic, descriptive, and identification information to materials-property resources and related ontology terms.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Material Properties Annotation properties that includes the Dublin Core","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/cpauloh/semmd"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"443","omv:numberOfProperties":"153","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MP-SCHM/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"1384"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:38:03.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2016-11-22T17:15:38.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MP-SCHM&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MP-SCHM/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MP-SCHM/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"12","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/MP-SCHM/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MP-SCHM&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"420","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MP-SCHM/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MP-SCHM/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MP-SCHM","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"30"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/semmd/v0.6/schma/mpschm","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/semmd/v0.6/schma/mpschm"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MP-SCHM/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"6"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Michel Dumontier"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Clare Paul, Materials and Manufacturing Directorate, Air Force Research Laboratory, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a1422d20-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a1422d20-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"ASM International\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a19e9d60-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a19e9d60-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cogan Matthew Shimizu, Wright State University, Dayton Ohio\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a1b85b50-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a1b85b50-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Pascal Hitzler, Data Semantics Laboratory, Wright State University, Dayton Ohio\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a1cf2200-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a1cf2200-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MP-SCHM/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.6"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":226.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6412},"MSEO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purl.matolab.org/mseo/mid"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MSEO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"MSEO utilizes the Common Core Ontology stack giving materials scientists and engineers the ability to represent their experiments and resulting data. The goal is to create machine and human readable sematic data which can be easily digested by other science domains. It is a product of the joint venture Materials Open Lab Project between the Bundesanstalt für Materialforschung und -prüfung (BAM) and the Fraunhofer Group MATERIALS and used the BWMD ontology created by Fraunhofer IWM as a starting point.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/Mat-O-Lab/MSEO/main/MSEO_mid.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Material Science and Engineering Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/Mat-O-Lab/MSEO"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSEO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:02:29.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MSEO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This is the mid-level module of the Material Sience and Engineering Ontology MSEO.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSEO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSEO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/MSEO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MSEO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSEO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSEO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MSEO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purl.matolab.org/mseo/mid","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purl.matolab.org/mseo/mid"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://www.daml.org/2003/01/periodictable/PeriodicTable"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://www.daml.org/2003/01/periodictable/PeriodicTable","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSEO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Thomas Hanke"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSEO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/Mat-O-Lab, homePage=https://matolab.materials.digital/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:23.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BWMD-DOMAIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LPBFO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSEO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:23.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=Mat-O-Lab, name=Materials Open Laboratory, description=Joint Venture Between Fraunhofer MATERIALS and BAM, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/Mat-O-Lab, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":228.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2931},"MTO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/ontologies/Mechanical_Testing_Ontology/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MTO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://emmo-repo.github.io/domain-mechanical-testing","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The materials mechanical testing ontology (MTO) was developed by collecting the mechanical testing vocabulary from ISO 23718 standard, as well as the standardized testing processes described for various mechanical testing of materials like tensile testing, Brinell hardness test, Vickers hardness test, stress relaxation test, and fatigue testing.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/ontologies/mechanical-testing-ontology/-/raw/main/MTO2.1.6.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Mechanical Testing Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/emmo-repo/domain-mechanical-testing"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:02:35.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MTO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MTO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MTO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/ontologies/Mechanical_Testing_Ontology/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/ontologies/Mechanical_Testing_Ontology/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Miriam Eisenbart\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fd9f2040-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fd9f2040-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Thomas Hanke\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fdb3b9a0-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fdb3b9a0-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Birgit Skrotzki\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fdcab3b0-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fdcab3b0-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Hossein Beygi Nasrabadi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fde58010-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fde58010-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2.1.4"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMD, name=MaterialDigital / PMD, description=Platform MaterialDigital project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMDAO, name=MaterialDigital / PMD Application Ontologies, description=PMD application ontologies, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":24,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":241.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6002},"MWO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/mwo/mwo.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/mwo/mwo.owl/3.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MWO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://ise-fizkarlsruhe.github.io/mwo","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The purpose of the MatWerk ontology is to represent the scientific and infrastructural status of the Materials Science and Engineering (MSE) community. It will be used as a backbone for the MSE Knowledge Graph. This ontology is built on top of the NFDIcore ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ISE-FIZKarlsruhe/mwo/main/mwo.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"NFDI MatWerk Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/ISE-FIZKarlsruhe/mwo"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MWO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:02:38.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MWO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MWO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MWO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/MWO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MWO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MWO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MWO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MWO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/mwo/mwo.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/mwo/mwo.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MWO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/mwo/mwo.owl/2.0.0","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jörg Waitelonis\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/37124f20-edb4-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/37124f20-edb4-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Kostiantyn Hubaiev\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9b1955b0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9b1955b0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ebrahim Norouzi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9b2eba60-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9b2eba60-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Harald Sack\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9b440e90-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9b440e90-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Hossein Beygi Nasrabadi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fde58010-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fde58010-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Abril Azócar Guzmán\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9babb3d0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9babb3d0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Felix Fritzen\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9bc10030-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9bc10030-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Volker Hofmann\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9bd7f620-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9bd7f620-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Amir Laadhar\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9bf026b0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9bf026b0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Angelika Gedsun\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9f01ba50-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9f01ba50-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stefan Sandfeld\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9f188ea0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9f188ea0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ahmad Zainul Ihsan\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9f2f58f0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9f2f58f0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Said Fathalla\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9f444140-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9f444140-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MWO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/mwo/mwo.owl/2.0.0","owl:versionInfo":"3.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, homePage=https://nfdi-matwerk.de/solutions/all-solutions/semantics, institution=NFDI-MatWerk, updated=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ASMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMEO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CMSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MWO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PLDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PODO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RDOC], created=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NFDIMATWERK, name=NFDI-MatWerk Semantic Resources, description=Project entry for NFDI-MatWerk semantic resources curated in MatPortal dev. The project groups ontologies that are directly NFDI-MatWerk authored, NFDI-MatWerk infrastructure-use-case resources, or NFDI-MatWerk-listed semantic resources relevant to materials science and engineering interoperability., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/nfdimatwerk"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":52.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4852},"NASA-THESAURUS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://synaptica.net/owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NASA-THESAURUS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Automated fixed submission for local indexing recovery","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"NASA Thesaurus(Broken, admin only)","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/nasa/dictionaries"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"25","omv:numberOfProperties":"22","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NASA-THESAURUS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"192649"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:40.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-02-07T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NASA-THESAURUS&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Synaptica output using OWL syntax.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NASA-THESAURUS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NASA-THESAURUS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"2","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/NASA-THESAURUS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NASA-THESAURUS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"12","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NASA-THESAURUS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NASA-THESAURUS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/NASA-THESAURUS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"5"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://synaptica.net/owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://synaptica.net/owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NASA-THESAURUS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NASA-THESAURUS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"Synaptica OWL"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"private"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":224.0,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5104},"NIIMBLAGENT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Agent/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202601/biopharma/Agent/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NIIMBLAGENT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The NIIMBL Agent Ontology models the actors involved in biopharmaceutical manufacturing, including people, organizations, and engineered systems. It provides concepts for roles such as operators and validators, together with related identification and participation patterns, so manufacturing activities can be linked to the human, organizational, and equipment-side actors responsible for them.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/biopharma/Agent.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"NIIMBL Agent Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"14","omv:numberOfProperties":"7","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T15:08:06.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"This module contains terms and relations necessary for representing  various types of agents (actors) in biopharmaceutical manufacturing. The actors here correspond to both human actors as well as engineered systems and organizations.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-04-16T15:08:05.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLAGENT&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLAGENT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"14","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"9"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Agent/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Agent/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal NIIMBL Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"NIIMBL BD-1 Ontology Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10034510-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10034510-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ana Nikolov, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Boonserm Kulvatunyou, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jan Kemper, AstraZeneca\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Adlane Rebai, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gabriela Henning, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Milos Drobnjakovic, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cameron Gibbs, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen Kahmann, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melissa Weller, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marie-Aude Coutouly, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen J. Granite, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology/tree/master/biopharma, institution=Industrial Ontologies Foundry / NIIMBL, updated=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC], created=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NIIMBL, name=NIIMBL Biopharma Ontologies, description=Project entry for the NIIMBL biopharma ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for biopharmaceutical manufacturing, recipes, equipment, materials, process execution, monitoring, and quality data., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/niimbl"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":241.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7010},"NIIMBLEQUIP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Equipment/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202601/biopharma/Equipment/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NIIMBLEQUIP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The NIIMBL Equipment Ontology describes the equipment and equipment-related capabilities used in biopharmaceutical manufacturing. It covers equipment types, qualities, capabilities, specifications, and validation concepts, and includes terms for bioreactors, chromatography systems and media, filters, thawing systems, and related manufacturing equipment.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/biopharma/Equipment.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"NIIMBL Equipment Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/IndustrialOntologies/IOF"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"152","omv:numberOfProperties":"135","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T15:08:07.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"This module contains terms and relations enabling representation of equipment types, properties (qualities, capabilities, and functions), equipment specifications and validation (e.g., methods, testing, reporting, etc.).","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-04-16T15:08:07.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLEQUIP&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"16","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLEQUIP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"115","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"15"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Equipment/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Equipment/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ReferenceOntologyCandidates/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ReferenceOntologyCandidates/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal NIIMBL Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"NIIMBL BD-1 Ontology Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10034510-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10034510-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ana Nikolov, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Boonserm Kulvatunyou, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jan Kemper, AstraZeneca\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Adlane Rebai, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gabriela Henning, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Milos Drobnjakovic, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cameron Gibbs, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen Kahmann, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melissa Weller, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marie-Aude Coutouly, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen J. Granite, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology/tree/master/biopharma, institution=Industrial Ontologies Foundry / NIIMBL, updated=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC], created=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NIIMBL, name=NIIMBL Biopharma Ontologies, description=Project entry for the NIIMBL biopharma ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for biopharmaceutical manufacturing, recipes, equipment, materials, process execution, monitoring, and quality data., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/niimbl"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":248.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6995},"NIIMBLMAT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Material/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202601/biopharma/Material/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NIIMBLMAT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The NIIMBL Material Ontology models the material types that appear in biopharmaceutical manufacturing together with their associated properties and usage roles. It includes concepts for cells, cell lines, cell populations, culture media, process intermediates, final products, and other materials that move through the manufacturing process.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/biopharma/Material.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"NIIMBL Material Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"136","omv:numberOfProperties":"135","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T15:08:10.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"This module contains terms and relations enabling representation of material types and their associated properties. Terms for characterizing material usages in internal operation systems are also included (e.g., consumable, process intermediate, final product?).","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-04-16T15:08:10.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLMAT&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"19","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLMAT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"99","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"14"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Material/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Material/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ReferenceOntologyCandidates/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ReferenceOntologyCandidates/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal NIIMBL Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"NIIMBL BD-1 Ontology Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10034510-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10034510-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ana Nikolov, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Boonserm Kulvatunyou, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jan Kemper, AstraZeneca\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Adlane Rebai, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gabriela Henning, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Milos Drobnjakovic, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cameron Gibbs, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen Kahmann, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melissa Weller, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marie-Aude Coutouly, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen J. Granite, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology/tree/master/biopharma, institution=Industrial Ontologies Foundry / NIIMBL, updated=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC], created=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NIIMBL, name=NIIMBL Biopharma Ontologies, description=Project entry for the NIIMBL biopharma ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for biopharmaceutical manufacturing, recipes, equipment, materials, process execution, monitoring, and quality data., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/niimbl"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":246.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6937},"NIIMBLMATPS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/MaterialProcurementAndStorage/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202601/biopharma/MaterialProcurementAndStorage/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NIIMBLMATPS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The NIIMBL Material Procurement and Storage Ontology supports material tracking and traceability across procurement, storage, and regulated manufacturing operations. It includes identifiers and records such as CAS numbers, catalog numbers, certificates of analysis, sublots, and time expressions for production, first use, storage, and expiration so material handling can be connected to process control and compliance workflows.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/biopharma/MaterialProcurementAndStorage.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"NIIMBL Material Procurement and Storage Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/IndustrialOntologies/IOF"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"251","omv:numberOfProperties":"162","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T15:08:11.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"This module contains terms and relations for tracking and tracing of materials. The purpose of the module is to provide support for use cases related to connecting process control to raw material procurement as well as for use cases related to regulatory compliance.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-04-16T15:08:11.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLMATPS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"23","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLMATPS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"214","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"20"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/MaterialProcurementAndStorage/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/MaterialProcurementAndStorage/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ReferenceOntologyCandidates/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/certification/Certification/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/supplychain/SupplyChain/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ReferenceOntologyCandidates/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/certification/Certification/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/supplychain/SupplyChain/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal NIIMBL Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"NIIMBL BD-1 Ontology Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10034510-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10034510-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ana Nikolov, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Boonserm Kulvatunyou, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jan Kemper, AstraZeneca\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Adlane Rebai, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gabriela Henning, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Milos Drobnjakovic, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cameron Gibbs, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen Kahmann, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melissa Weller, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marie-Aude Coutouly, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen J. Granite, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology/tree/master/biopharma, institution=Industrial Ontologies Foundry / NIIMBL, updated=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC], created=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NIIMBL, name=NIIMBL Biopharma Ontologies, description=Project entry for the NIIMBL biopharma ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for biopharmaceutical manufacturing, recipes, equipment, materials, process execution, monitoring, and quality data., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/niimbl"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":248.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7049},"NIIMBLMEXEC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ManufacturingExecution/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202601/biopharma/ManufacturingExecution/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NIIMBLMEXEC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The NIIMBL Manufacturing Execution Ontology represents the actual execution of biopharmaceutical manufacturing processes with respect to recipes. It includes concepts for concrete manufacturing steps such as cell banking, cell culture expansion, filtration, chromatography, formulation, viral clearance, and other recipe-linked process occurrences.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/biopharma/ManufacturingExecution.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"NIIMBL Manufacturing Execution Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"270","omv:numberOfProperties":"137","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T15:08:09.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"This module contains terms and relations necessary for representing the actual occurrences of manufacturing processes with respect to recipes.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-04-16T15:08:08.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLMEXEC&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"32","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLMEXEC&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"233","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"22"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ManufacturingExecution/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ManufacturingExecution/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Equipment/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ReferenceOntologyCandidates/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Material/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/MonitoringAndControl/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Parameter/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Physical/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Recipe/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Equipment/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ReferenceOntologyCandidates/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Material/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/MonitoringAndControl/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Parameter/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Physical/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Recipe/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal NIIMBL Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"NIIMBL BD-1 Ontology Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10034510-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10034510-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ana Nikolov, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Boonserm Kulvatunyou, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jan Kemper, AstraZeneca\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Adlane Rebai, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gabriela Henning, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Milos Drobnjakovic, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cameron Gibbs, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen Kahmann, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melissa Weller, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marie-Aude Coutouly, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen J. Granite, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology/tree/master/biopharma, institution=Industrial Ontologies Foundry / NIIMBL, updated=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC], created=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NIIMBL, name=NIIMBL Biopharma Ontologies, description=Project entry for the NIIMBL biopharma ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for biopharmaceutical manufacturing, recipes, equipment, materials, process execution, monitoring, and quality data., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/niimbl"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":246.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6966},"NIIMBLMONCTRL":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/MonitoringAndControl/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202601/biopharma/MonitoringAndControl/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NIIMBLMONCTRL","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The NIIMBL Monitoring And Control Ontology represents the planning and execution of monitoring and control activities in laboratory-scale and manufacturing-scale biopharma settings. It includes concepts for control strategies, monitoring plans, material quality plans, samples, and sampling processes so quality oversight and operational control can be modeled in a consistent way.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/biopharma/MonitoringAndControl.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"NIIMBL Monitoring And Control Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"16","omv:numberOfProperties":"12","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T15:08:13.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"This module contains terms and relations necessary for representing the planning and execution of monitoring and/or controlling for both laboratory and manufacturing scale.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-04-16T15:08:12.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLMONCTRL&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLMONCTRL&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"16","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"8"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/MonitoringAndControl/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/MonitoringAndControl/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal NIIMBL Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"NIIMBL BD-1 Ontology Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10034510-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10034510-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ana Nikolov, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Boonserm Kulvatunyou, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jan Kemper, AstraZeneca\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Adlane Rebai, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gabriela Henning, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Milos Drobnjakovic, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cameron Gibbs, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen Kahmann, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melissa Weller, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marie-Aude Coutouly, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen J. Granite, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology/tree/master/biopharma, institution=Industrial Ontologies Foundry / NIIMBL, updated=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC], created=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NIIMBL, name=NIIMBL Biopharma Ontologies, description=Project entry for the NIIMBL biopharma ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for biopharmaceutical manufacturing, recipes, equipment, materials, process execution, monitoring, and quality data., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/niimbl"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":243.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6975},"NIIMBLPARAM":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Parameter/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202601/biopharma/Parameter/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NIIMBLPARAM","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The NIIMBL Parameter Ontology captures the parameters, indicators, and quality attributes used to assess and control biopharmaceutical processes and products. It includes concepts for process parameters, quality attributes, performance indicators, their specifications, and associated value expressions such as setpoints, normal operating ranges, and proven acceptable ranges.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/biopharma/Parameter.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"NIIMBL Parameter Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"143","omv:numberOfProperties":"135","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T15:08:14.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"This module contains terms and relations necessary for representing  process intermediate and product quality attributes, process indicators and process parameters.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-04-16T15:08:14.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLPARAM&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"20","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLPARAM&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"106","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"16"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Parameter/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Parameter/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ReferenceOntologyCandidates/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ReferenceOntologyCandidates/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal NIIMBL Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"NIIMBL BD-1 Ontology Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10034510-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10034510-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ana Nikolov, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Boonserm Kulvatunyou, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jan Kemper, AstraZeneca\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Adlane Rebai, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gabriela Henning, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Milos Drobnjakovic, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cameron Gibbs, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen Kahmann, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melissa Weller, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marie-Aude Coutouly, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen J. Granite, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology/tree/master/biopharma, institution=Industrial Ontologies Foundry / NIIMBL, updated=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC], created=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NIIMBL, name=NIIMBL Biopharma Ontologies, description=Project entry for the NIIMBL biopharma ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for biopharmaceutical manufacturing, recipes, equipment, materials, process execution, monitoring, and quality data., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/niimbl"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":246.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7240},"NIIMBLPHYS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Physical/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202601/biopharma/Physical/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NIIMBLPHYS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The NIIMBL Physical Model Ontology describes the physical spaces in which biopharmaceutical processing and storage take place. It models hierarchical and embedded site structures such as enterprises, sites, areas, production units, work centers, process cells, storage units, and related physical locations used in manufacturing operations.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/biopharma/Physical.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"NIIMBL Physical Model Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"134","omv:numberOfProperties":"135","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T15:08:16.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"This module contains terms and relations to represent the physical spaces where processing and storage occurs.  Spaces are specific and bounded geographic locations which can be heirarchical and embedded.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-04-16T15:08:15.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLPHYS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"15","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLPHYS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"97","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"14"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Physical/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Physical/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal NIIMBL Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"NIIMBL BD-1 Ontology Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10034510-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10034510-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ana Nikolov, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Boonserm Kulvatunyou, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jan Kemper, AstraZeneca\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Adlane Rebai, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gabriela Henning, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Milos Drobnjakovic, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cameron Gibbs, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen Kahmann, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melissa Weller, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marie-Aude Coutouly, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen J. Granite, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology/tree/master/biopharma, institution=Industrial Ontologies Foundry / NIIMBL, updated=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC], created=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NIIMBL, name=NIIMBL Biopharma Ontologies, description=Project entry for the NIIMBL biopharma ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for biopharmaceutical manufacturing, recipes, equipment, materials, process execution, monitoring, and quality data., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/niimbl"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":248.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7085},"NIIMBLRECIPE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Recipe/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202602/biopharma/Recipe/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NIIMBLRECIPE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The NIIMBL Recipe Ontology models the hierarchical, temporally ordered structure of biopharmaceutical recipes and their evolution from general definitions to batch-specific execution artifacts. It includes concepts for general, master, site, and control recipes, recipe procedures and operations, batch runs, and the derivation processes that relate one recipe level to another.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/biopharma/Recipe.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"NIIMBL Recipe Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"163","omv:numberOfProperties":"143","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-05-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"This module contains terms and relations for describing the hierarchical and temporally sequenced operations and actions which comprise the recipe.  Module contents also describes the evolution and maturation of the recipe over time as it is transformed from a general recipe (not specific for a site) to a specific instance recipe associated with a batch.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-05-28T18:01:45.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLRECIPE&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"18","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLRECIPE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"126","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"14"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Recipe/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/Recipe/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ReferenceOntologyCandidates/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ManufacturingSystemOrganization/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ReferenceOntologyCandidates/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ManufacturingSystemOrganization/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal NIIMBL Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"NIIMBL BD-1 Ontology Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10034510-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10034510-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ana Nikolov, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Boonserm Kulvatunyou, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jan Kemper, AstraZeneca\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Adlane Rebai, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gabriela Henning, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Milos Drobnjakovic, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cameron Gibbs, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen Kahmann, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melissa Weller, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marie-Aude Coutouly, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen J. Granite, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology/tree/master/biopharma, institution=Industrial Ontologies Foundry / NIIMBL, updated=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC], created=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NIIMBL, name=NIIMBL Biopharma Ontologies, description=Project entry for the NIIMBL biopharma ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for biopharmaceutical manufacturing, recipes, equipment, materials, process execution, monitoring, and quality data., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/niimbl"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":246.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7053},"NIIMBLROC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ReferenceOntologyCandidates/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202602/biopharma/ReferenceOntologyCandidates/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NIIMBLROC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The NIIMBL Reference Ontology Candidates ontology is a staging ontology for cross-cutting candidate concepts proposed for inclusion in broader IOF reference ontologies. It contains reusable industrial concepts such as manufacturing capability, process intermediate material, and production consumables that were developed in the biopharma context but are intended for broader semantic reuse.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/master/biopharma/ReferenceOntologyCandidates.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"NIIMBL Reference Ontology Candidates","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/IndustrialOntology/IOF"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"128","omv:numberOfProperties":"141","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-05-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-05-28T18:01:52.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLROC&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"15","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NIIMBLROC&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"91","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"14"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ReferenceOntologyCandidates/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/biopharma/ReferenceOntologyCandidates/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal NIIMBL Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ana Nikolov, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/102da760-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Boonserm Kulvatunyou, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10428360-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jan Kemper, AstraZeneca\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/105663c0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Adlane Rebai, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/106ad5b0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gabriela Henning, NIST\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/108372d0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Milos Drobnjakovic, OAGi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1097fcb0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cameron Gibbs, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10acc620-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen Kahmann, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10c3fb30-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melissa Weller, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10e00ed0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marie-Aude Coutouly, Millipore Sigma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/10f38aa0-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stephen J. Granite, CrownPoint Technologies, LLC\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1106bb60-1bd4-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, homePage=https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology/tree/master/biopharma, institution=Industrial Ontologies Foundry / NIIMBL, updated=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLAGENT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLEQUIP, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMATPS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMEXEC, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLMONCTRL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPARAM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLPHYS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLRECIPE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NIIMBLROC], created=2026-04-16T15:08:21.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NIIMBL, name=NIIMBL Biopharma Ontologies, description=Project entry for the NIIMBL biopharma ontology suite imported into MatPortal dev for biopharmaceutical manufacturing, recipes, equipment, materials, process execution, monitoring, and quality data., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NIIMBL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/niimbl"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":246.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6939},"NMRRVOCAB":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://172.18.0.1:9393/ontologies/NMRRVOCAB"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NMRRVOCAB","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A version of the Materials Data Vocabulary structured as Simple Knowledge Organization System (SKOS). The XML was originally created by the TemaTres software. This vocabulary describes the applicability to material science of records in the NIST Materials Resource Registry (NMRR - https://materials.registry.nist.gov/).","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Materials Data Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/usnistgov/nmrr"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NMRRVOCAB/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"994"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:05.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2021-04-15T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NMRRVOCAB&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NMRRVOCAB/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NMRRVOCAB/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/NMRRVOCAB/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NMRRVOCAB&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NMRRVOCAB/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NMRRVOCAB/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/NMRRVOCAB","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://172.18.0.1:9393/ontologies/NMRRVOCAB","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://172.18.0.1:9393/ontologies/NMRRVOCAB"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"SKOS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NMRRVOCAB/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#broader","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Andrea Medina-Smith"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NMRRVOCAB/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":216.0,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":9571},"ODEAMROOT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/AMAO"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ODEAMROOT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/ODEAM\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"ODE_AM Root Ontology is the integrated root module of the ODE_AM ontology suite, bundling core ODE_AM application modules (including AMAO, MAO, and process-specific modules) into one import graph. It provides a single entry point for cross-process additive-manufacturing knowledge representation and project-level interoperability.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"ODE_AM Root Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/material-digital/ODE_AM"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1577","omv:numberOfProperties":"308","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"235"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"6","dct:created":"2026-02-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ODEAMROOT&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology, designed for use in data management for metal additive manufacturing with focus on Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing (WAAM). The ontology only included classes in the scope of project ODE_AM. It primarily integrates existing classes from the Basic Formal Ontology (BFO) and the Common Core Ontologies (CCO), selectively chosen to fit the considered use cases in our project. This focused approach ensures efficient and relevant data categorization and retrieval tailored to our specific project requirements.\",\"This ontology, developed for use at Fraunhofer IGCV, comprises a detailed collection of entities and their associated descriptions, tailored to support a range of projects like ODE_AM and HybridDigital within the manufacturing domain. It includes specific categories such as materials, processes, machinery, and quality standards, all of which are vital for research and development in advanced manufacturing techniques.\",\"This ontology, created for use at Fraunhofer IGCV, includes essential classes specifically relevant to Project ODE_AM within the domain of Additive Manufacturing. It is designed with the capability for successive expansions to accommodate future developments and additional requirements in this field.\",\"It uses Basic Formal Ontology as a Top- and Common Core Ontologies as Mid-Level-Ontologies. Fraunhofer IGCV Manufacturing Application Ontology is used as direct import.\",\"It uses Basic Formal Ontology as Top- and Common Core Ontologies as Mid-Level-Ontologies.\",\"This ontology, designed for use in data management for metal additive manufacturing with focus on Composite Extrusion Modeling (CEM). The ontology only included classes in the scope of project ODE_AM. It primarily integrates existing classes from the Basic Formal Ontology (BFO) and the Common Core Ontologies (CCO), selectively chosen to fit the considered use cases in our project. This focused approach ensures efficient and relevant data categorization and retrieval tailored to our specific project requirements.\",\"This ontology, tailored for the powder bed fusion domain at Fraunhofer IGCV, comprises key classes that encapsulate various parameters integral to this specific additive manufacturing process.\",\"Fraunhofer IGCV AM Application Ontology is used as a direct import.\",\"This ontology, designed for use in data management within the Fraunhofer IGCV's project-specific web-app, includes only those classes that are directly relevant to the project's needs. It primarily integrates existing classes from the Basic Formal Ontology (BFO) and the Common Core Ontologies (CCO), selectively chosen to fit the considered use cases in our project. This focused approach ensures efficient and relevant data categorization and retrieval tailored to our specific project requirements.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"144","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ODEAMROOT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1176","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"57"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/AMAO","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/AMAO"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/AgentOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/ArtifactOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/EventOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/ExtendedRelationOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/GeospatialOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/InformationEntityOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/QualityOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/TimeOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/UnitsOfMeasureOntology]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/AgentOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/ArtifactOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/EventOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/ExtendedRelationOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/GeospatialOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/InformationEntityOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/QualityOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/TimeOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/UnitsOfMeasureOntology]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/ODEAM\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"11"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Thomas Bjarsch\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5362cca0-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/5362cca0-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mohamed Kamal, Heiko Beinersdorf\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/53775000-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/53775000-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mohamed Kamal,  Jan Reimann\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/538c5710-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/538c5710-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_ODE_AM, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:26.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:26.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_ODE_AM, name=MaterialDigital / ODE_AM, description=MaterialDigital subproject ODE_AM, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_ODE_AM, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":36.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":236.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6335},"OM":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontology-of-units-of-measure.org/resource/om-2"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":6.0,"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"http://www.ontology-of-units-of-measure.org/vocabularies/om-2/"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"OM","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"OM 2.0 is a general ontology for units, quantities, measures, dimensions, scales, and prefixes. It provides broad machine-readable coverage of SI and non-SI measurement concepts for scientific and engineering data integration., ??????????? (Ontology of units of Measure; OM) ???????????????????????????OM????????????????????????, De Ontologie van Maateenheden (OM) 2.0 modelleert concepten en relaties die belangrijk zijn voor wetenschappelijk onderzoek. Het heeft een sterke focus op eenheden, grootheden, maten, en dimensies., The Ontology of units of Measure (OM) 2.0 models concepts and relations important to scientific research. It has a strong focus on units, and dimensions.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/HajoRijgersberg/OM/master/om-2.0.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Ontology of units of Measure (OM)","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/HajoRijgersberg/OM"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"814","omv:numberOfProperties":"34","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2251"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-17T12:16:26.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"4","dct:created":"2026-04-17T12:16:25.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OM&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"25","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OM&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"485","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/OM","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"207"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontology-of-units-of-measure.org/resource/om-2","dct:identifier":"http://www.ontology-of-units-of-measure.org/vocabularies/om-2/"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontology-of-units-of-measure.org/resource/om-2"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"4"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Metrology Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Hajo Rijgersberg, Don Willems, Jan Top\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/71128c80-1c85-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/71128c80-1c85-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2.0.59"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, homePage=https://www.bipm.org/en/measurement-units, institution=MatPortal curation (multi-source metrology set), updated=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CQU, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MASON, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROVO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SIS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SOSA, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSN], created=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=METROLOGY, name=Metrology And Measurement Ontologies, description=Curated multi-source project entry for metrology ontologies in MatPortal dev. The project groups non-biomedical ontologies for units, quantities, dimensional analysis, digital calibration, uncertainty representation, sensor provenance, and measurement-aware domain semantics., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/PHYSICS, homePage=https://physh.org/, institution=MatPortal curation (multi-source physics set), updated=2026-04-17T14:40:05.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDO-FULL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSCI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSH, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT], created=2026-04-17T14:40:05.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=PHYSICS, name=Physics Ontologies, description=Curated multi-source project entry for non-biomedical physics ontologies in MatPortal dev. The project groups foundational measurement ontologies, upper and domain ontologies for physical systems and materials, and ontology resources used to organize physics knowledge and publications., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/PHYSICS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/metrology, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/physics]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":51.0,"normalizedScore":35,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":252.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6031},"ONTOCOMPCHEM":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://theworldavatar.com/ontology/ontocompchem/ontocompchem.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ONTOCOMPCHEM","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CATALYSIS\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEMISTRY\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/NFDI4CAT\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://theworldavatar.io/chemistry/documentation/ontologies/ontocompchem","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"OntoCompChem is an ontology for representing quantum-chemistry calculations, including computation objective, software, level of theory, charge/spin settings, and resulting properties such as converged energies, frontier orbitals, optimized geometries, and vibrational outputs. It is used to make computational chemistry results interoperable and queryable in knowledge-graph workflows.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"OntoCompChem","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/cambridge-cares/TheWorldAvatar"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"78","omv:numberOfProperties":"60","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOCOMPCHEM/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"157"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-02-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ONTOCOMPCHEM&q=","schema:comment":"[\"An ontology defined for representing computational calculations of species.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOCOMPCHEM/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOCOMPCHEM/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"14","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOCOMPCHEM/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ONTOCOMPCHEM&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"40","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOCOMPCHEM/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOCOMPCHEM/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/ONTOCOMPCHEM","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"24"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://theworldavatar.com/ontology/ontocompchem/ontocompchem.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://theworldavatar.com/ontology/ontocompchem/ontocompchem.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://www.daml.org/2003/01/periodictable/PeriodicTable"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://www.daml.org/2003/01/periodictable/PeriodicTable","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOCOMPCHEM/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CATALYSIS\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEMISTRY\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/NFDI4CAT\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://github.com/TheWorldAvatar/ontology/blob/main/LICENSE.txt","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"5"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://github.com/TheWorldAvatar/ontology/blob/main/LICENSE.txt"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOCOMPCHEM/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/chemistry"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":254.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6408},"ONTOMAT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.materialdigital.de/ontomat/ontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://www.materialdigital.de/ontomat/ontology/0.6"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ONTOMAT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/ONTOMATONTOLOGY\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"OntoMat Ontology is developed to integrate materials, manufacturing, characterization, and simulation information in a unified semantic model for FRP and related process chains. It combines material composition and property descriptions with process/operator representations and simulation context to support ontology-based data integration across lifecycle stages.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"OntoMat Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/ontomat-ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"396","omv:numberOfProperties":"128","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"8"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:02.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"5","dct:created":"2024-12-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ONTOMAT&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"15","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ONTOMAT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"235","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"70"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.materialdigital.de/ontomat/ontology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.materialdigital.de/ontomat/ontology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://rds.posccaesar.org/ontology/lis14/ont/core"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://rds.posccaesar.org/ontology/lis14/ont/core","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/ONTOMATONTOLOGY\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"6"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Maja Milicic Brandt\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/83048800-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/83048800-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Patrick Schneider\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/831bdd30-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/831bdd30-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Martin Koerdel\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/837eda30-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/837eda30-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.6.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":53.0,"normalizedScore":37,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":257.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5935},"ONT_PUB_TMPLT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/ont_pub_tmplt"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/ont_pub_tmplt/1.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ONT_PUB_TMPLT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/ONTOLOGYPUBLICATIONT\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology Publication Template for the PMD is a reference blueprint that demonstrates the formal metadata and publication conventions required for PMD partner ontologies. It is intentionally minimal in domain content and is meant to be copied and adapted so projects can publish versioned ontology artifacts and documentation in a consistent format.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/materialdigital1_ontology_collection/main/ont_pub_tmplt/tbox/ontology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Ontology Publication Template for the PMD","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/application-ontology-template"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"25","omv:numberOfProperties":"15","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"100"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:14.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2023-12-15T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ONT_PUB_TMPLT&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This is an example ontology to help PMD partner projects to get an overview over the formal requirements imposed by HAP 4. \\n                                           It's meant as a blueprint for updating the partner projects ontologies and thus does not carry any relevant concepts. This \\n                                           file is related to the github repository https://github.com/materialdigital/ontology_publication_template where there is \\n                                           more information about how to work with this example.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"2","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ONT_PUB_TMPLT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"16"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/ont_pub_tmplt","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/ont_pub_tmplt"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/ONTOLOGYPUBLICATIONT\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0000-0000-0000\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/442f61a0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/442f61a0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":51.0,"normalizedScore":35,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":252.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6940},"ORBAC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/bleuontologies/orbac.owl/refs/heads/main/orbac.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ORBAC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The ORBAC Ontology represents Organization-Based Access Control concepts in OWL, including organizations, roles, activities, views, contexts, and deontic policy types such as permissions, prohibitions, and obligations. It provides a formal policy model for expressing access decisions at an organizational abstraction level rather than only user-object rules.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/bleuontologies/orbac.owl/refs/heads/main/orbac.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"ORBAC Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/ahmedlaouar/orbac.owl"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"22","omv:numberOfProperties":"23","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ORBAC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:22.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-02-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ORBAC&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ORBAC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ORBAC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/ORBAC/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ORBAC&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"22","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ORBAC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ORBAC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/ORBAC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"5"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/bleuontologies/orbac.owl/refs/heads/main/orbac.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/bleuontologies/orbac.owl/refs/heads/main/orbac.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ORBAC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ORBAC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":236.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3993},"PBFAO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/PBFAO"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PBFAO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Fraunhofer IGCV Powder Bed Fusion Application Ontology is an ODE_AM module specialized for powder-bed-fusion process representation. It imports AMAO/MAO context and provides PBF-specific concepts for machines, exposure patterns, hatch parameters, and related process settings needed for structured LPBF data management and interoperability.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/PBFAO","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Fraunhofer IGCV Powder Bed Fusion Application Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:02:42.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PBFAO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"It uses Basic Formal Ontology as Top- and Common Core Ontologies as Mid-Level-Ontologies.\",\"This ontology, tailored for the powder bed fusion domain at Fraunhofer IGCV, comprises key classes that encapsulate various parameters integral to this specific additive manufacturing process.\",\"Fraunhofer IGCV AM Application Ontology is used as a direct import.\",\"This ontology, designed for use in data management within the Fraunhofer IGCV's project-specific web-app, includes only those classes that are directly relevant to the project's needs. It primarily integrates existing classes from the Basic Formal Ontology (BFO) and the Common Core Ontologies (CCO), selectively chosen to fit the considered use cases in our project. This focused approach ensures efficient and relevant data categorization and retrieval tailored to our specific project requirements.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PBFAO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PBFAO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/PBFAO","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/PBFAO"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_ODE_AM, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:26.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:26.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_ODE_AM, name=MaterialDigital / ODE_AM, description=MaterialDigital subproject ODE_AM, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_ODE_AM, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMD, name=MaterialDigital / PMD, description=Platform MaterialDigital project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMDAO, name=MaterialDigital / PMD Application Ontologies, description=PMD application ontologies, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":22,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":225.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3660},"PGO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/pgo"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/pgo/1.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PGO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://materialdigital.github.io/application-ontologies/precipitate_geometry_ontology_PGO","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Precipitate Geometry Ontology (PGO) is a PMD application ontology for representing precipitate-geometry information derived from transmission electron microscopy and related microstructural analysis workflows. It extends PMDco-aligned modeling so precipitate descriptors and linked process/property context can be integrated and queried together in materials knowledge graphs.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://w3id.org/pmd/pgo","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Platform MaterialDigital - Precipitate Geometry Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/application-ontologies/tree/main/precipitate_geometry_ontology_PGO"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:02:56.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PGO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The Precipitate Geometry Ontology (PGO) is a small ontology used to describe data originating from transmission electron microscopy (TEM) analyses of precipitates. \\nIt was created in the frame of the collaborative project Platform MaterialDigital (PMD, https://materialdigital.de). It is further part of a demonstrator showing possible interactions of semantic data created by the application of multiple ontologies and used by federated SPARQL querying - the \\\"Orowan Demonstrator\\\" (available at: https://github.com/materialdigital/demo-orowan).\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PGO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PGO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/pgo","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/pgo"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Markus Schilling\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/247ef750-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/247ef750-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Bernd Bayerlein\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/24911340-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/24911340-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMD, name=MaterialDigital / PMD, description=Platform MaterialDigital project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMDAO, name=MaterialDigital / PMD Application Ontologies, description=PMD application ontologies, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":24,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":241.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5539},"PHYSCI":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/skgo/physci"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PHYSCI","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://saidfathalla.github.io/SKGO/PhySci/index-en.html","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Physics Ontology is an OWL ontology for physics publications that models the structure of scientific articles together with domain content such as methods, problems, solutions, phenomena, discoveries, and instruments. It is intended to turn physics research literature into a machine-readable knowledge graph.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/saidfathalla/Science-knowledge-graph-ontologies/main/PhySci/physci.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"The Physics Ontology (PhySci)","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/saidfathalla/SKGO"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSCI/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-17T14:41:13.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-17T14:41:13.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PHYSCI&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSCI/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSCI/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSCI/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PHYSCI&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSCI/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSCI/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PHYSCI","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/skgo/physci","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/skgo/physci"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSCI/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Physics Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSCI/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/PHYSICS, homePage=https://physh.org/, institution=MatPortal curation (multi-source physics set), updated=2026-04-17T14:40:05.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDO-FULL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSCI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSH, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT], created=2026-04-17T14:40:05.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=PHYSICS, name=Physics Ontologies, description=Curated multi-source project entry for non-biomedical physics ontologies in MatPortal dev. The project groups foundational measurement ontologies, upper and domain ontologies for physical systems and materials, and ontology resources used to organize physics knowledge and publications., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/PHYSICS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/physics"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":225.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3576},"PHYSH":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://physh.org/rdf/2018/01/01/core#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PHYSH","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Physics Subject Headings is the American Physical Society's RDF and SKOS classification scheme for organizing physics topics across disciplines, facets, and concepts. It supports consistent subject indexing and discovery of physics literature and related scholarly content.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/physh-org/PhySH/master/physh.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Physics Subject Headings (PhySH)","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/physh-org/PhySH"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"5","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSH/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"3910"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-17T14:40:02.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-04-17T14:40:01.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PHYSH&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSH/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSH/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSH/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PHYSH&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"5","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSH/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSH/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PHYSH","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"5"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://physh.org/rdf/2018/01/01/core#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://physh.org/rdf/2018/01/01/core#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSH/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Physics Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSH/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/PHYSICS, homePage=https://physh.org/, institution=MatPortal curation (multi-source physics set), updated=2026-04-17T14:40:05.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDO-FULL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSCI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSH, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT], created=2026-04-17T14:40:05.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=PHYSICS, name=Physics Ontologies, description=Curated multi-source project entry for non-biomedical physics ontologies in MatPortal dev. The project groups foundational measurement ontologies, upper and domain ontologies for physical systems and materials, and ontology resources used to organize physics knowledge and publications., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/PHYSICS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/physics"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":226.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4744},"PLDO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cdos/pldo/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cdos/pldo/1.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PLDO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/OCDO/pldo","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Planar Defects Ontology (PLDO) models planar defects in crystalline materials (for example grain boundaries and stacking-fault related structures), including atomic-scale defect characterization concepts and associated properties. It is part of the crystallographic-defect ontology suite and supports interoperable planar-defect data representation.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/OCDO/pldo/main/pldo.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Planar Defect Ontology (PLDO)","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/OCDO/pldo"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PLDO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:03:01.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PLDO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PLDO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PLDO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/PLDO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PLDO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PLDO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PLDO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PLDO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cdos/pldo/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cdos/pldo/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PLDO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7564-7990\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/397e6d90-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/397e6d90-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6776-1213\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39feaa70-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39feaa70-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9560-4728\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a154560-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a154560-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PLDO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, homePage=https://nfdi-matwerk.de/solutions/all-solutions/semantics, institution=NFDI-MatWerk, updated=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ASMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMEO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CMSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MWO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PLDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PODO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RDOC], created=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NFDIMATWERK, name=NFDI-MatWerk Semantic Resources, description=Project entry for NFDI-MatWerk semantic resources curated in MatPortal dev. The project groups ontologies that are directly NFDI-MatWerk authored, NFDI-MatWerk infrastructure-use-case resources, or NFDI-MatWerk-listed semantic resources relevant to materials science and engineering interoperability., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/nfdimatwerk"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":236.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4636},"PMDCO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co/3.0.0-rc2"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PMDCO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDCO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://materialdigital.github.io/core-ontology/docs","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The PMD Core Ontology (PMDco) is a comprehensive framework for representing knowledge that encompasses fundamental concepts from the domains of materials science and engineering (MSE). The PMDco has been designed as a mid-level ontology to establish a connection between specific MSE application ontologies and the domain neutral concepts found in established top-level ontologies. The primary goal of the PMDco is to promote interoperability between diverse domains.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co/","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"PMD Core Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/core-ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:03:03.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PMDCO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PMDCO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PMDCO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co/3.0.0-rc1","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDCO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jannis Grundmann\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/24142410-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/24142410-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Philipp von Hartrott\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/242a7290-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/242a7290-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jörg Waitelonis\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/243f0d10-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/243f0d10-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sascha Fliegener\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/24542ab0-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/24542ab0-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Henk Birkholz\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/246c1a10-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/246c1a10-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Markus Schilling\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/247ef750-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/247ef750-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Bernd Bayerlein\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/24911340-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/24911340-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Thomas Hanke\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/24a624d0-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/24a624d0-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co/3.0.0-rc1","owl:versionInfo":"3.0.0-rc2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMD, name=MaterialDigital / PMD, description=Platform MaterialDigital project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDCO, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMDCO, name=MaterialDigital / PMD Core, description=PMD core ontology project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDCO, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, homePage=https://www.bipm.org/en/measurement-units, institution=MatPortal curation (multi-source metrology set), updated=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CQU, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MASON, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROVO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SIS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SOSA, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSN], created=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=METROLOGY, name=Metrology And Measurement Ontologies, description=Curated multi-source project entry for metrology ontologies in MatPortal dev. The project groups non-biomedical ontologies for units, quantities, dimensional analysis, digital calibration, uncertainty representation, sensor provenance, and measurement-aware domain semantics., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/metrology]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5877},"PMDCO2":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://material-digital.de/pmdco"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PMDCO2","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDCO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/ONTOLOGYALIGNMENT\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"pmd-alignment is an ontology-alignment module in the PMD ecosystem for improving interoperability between materials-science ontologies. Its documented scope is the alignment of major MSE ontology stacks (including PMDco, BFO, EMMO, and CCO) so mappings can support cross-ontology data interpretation and partial conversion workflows.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/ontology-alignment/main/alignment/pmd-alignment.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"pmd-alignment","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"105","omv:numberOfProperties":"114","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"4"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:18.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-02-06T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PMDCO2&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This is an experimental ontology for the PMD ontology playground.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"6","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PMDCO2&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"26","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PMDCO2","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"10"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://material-digital.de/pmdco","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://material-digital.de/pmdco"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDCO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/ONTOLOGYALIGNMENT\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"6"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMD, name=MaterialDigital / PMD, description=Platform MaterialDigital project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDCO, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMDCO, name=MaterialDigital / PMD Core, description=PMD core ontology project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDCO, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":231.0,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3819},"PMDGO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/glass-ontology/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PMDGO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/GLASDIGITAL\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://materialdigital.github.io/glasdigital-ontology","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"GlasDigital Ontology is a PMDco-based ontology for glass-manufacturing knowledge, including robotic melting process semantics and SciGlass terminology integration. It supports representation of process parameters, composition/structure/property information, and data-integration workflows used in GlasDigital?s ontology-based digital infrastructure.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://w3id.org/pmd/glass-ontology/","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"GlasDigital Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/glasdigital-ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:03:07.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PMDGO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The GlasDigital Ontology was developed for the GlasDigital project (https://www.materialdigital.de/project/4). It describes the robotic melting process at Bundesanstalt für Materialforschung und -prüfung (BAM), Berlin and also contains the terminology of the SciGlass database (The data has become open source since 2019. See: https://github.com/epam/SciGlass).\\n\\nA practical use case of the ontology is the Semantic Knowledge Base (SKB) developed with Fast Ontodocker (https://git.material-digital.de/ya-fanchen/fast-ontodocker), which covers the entire glass manufacturing process parameters and glass property searching, as well as the integration of SciGlass data.\\n\\nIt is based on the PMD Core Ontology (PMDco) v1 and a migration to the latest PMDco is planned.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PMDGO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PMDGO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/glass-ontology/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/glass-ontology/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/GLASDIGITAL\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ya-Fan Chen (https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4295-7815)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2a3355e0-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2a3355e0-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Simon Stier (https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0410-3616)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2a49a8e0-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2a49a8e0-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_GLASDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_GLASDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital / GlasDigital, description=MaterialDigital subproject GlasDigital, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_GLASDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":247.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5606},"PMDMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/core-ontology/refs/heads/develop-3.0.0/pmdco.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PMDMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://materialdigital.github.io/microscopy-ontology","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Microscopy Ontology (MO) is a PMDco-aligned application ontology for microscopy and microanalysis data integration. It extends PMD Core concepts with microscopy-specific terms for instruments, imaging and beam conditions, acquisition settings, and analysis outputs so that heterogeneous microscopy datasets can be represented and queried interoperably.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/application-ontologies/main/microscopy_ontology_MO/pmd_mo.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Microscopy Ontology (MO)","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/microscopy-ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:03:10.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PMDMO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PMDMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PMDMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/core-ontology/refs/heads/develop-3.0.0/pmdco.ttl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/core-ontology/refs/heads/develop-3.0.0/pmdco.ttl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/core-ontology/refs/heads/develop-3.0.0/pmdco.ttl"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/core-ontology/refs/heads/develop-3.0.0/pmdco.ttl","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7094-5371\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2d0eb9e0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2d0eb9e0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3717-7104\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2d2810b0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2d2810b0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMD, name=MaterialDigital / PMD, description=Platform MaterialDigital project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMDAO, name=MaterialDigital / PMD Application Ontologies, description=PMD application ontologies, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":24,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":237.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4853},"PMDSENSO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/sensotwin/applicationontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://w3id.org/sensotwin/applicationontology/1.0.1."},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PMDSENSO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/SENSOTWIN\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"PMD Collection SensoTwin is the consolidated SensoTwin ontology release for FRP digital-twin use cases. It covers materials, manufacturing and curing workflows, testing and simulation descriptors, and parameter/result entities, and provides PMD-aligned semantics for integrating project data into broader materials knowledge graphs.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/materialdigital1_ontology_collection/main/SensoTwin/tbox/PMDCollectionSensoTwin.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"PMD Collection SensoTwin","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/upaehler/SensoTwin"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"433","omv:numberOfProperties":"161","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"219"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:25.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2026-02-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PMDSENSO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology describes fibre composites according to the needs in the project SensoTwin, still under development.\\n\\nIt takes care of: \\nused materials\\nproduction processes \\ntesting processes, parameters and results\\nsimulation\\nand componentgeometry\\n\\nIncluded instances serve as proof of concept or as exemplary applications.\",\"Usage of Ontologies:\\nPMDCO\\nPMDSI (old)\\nqudt\\nProv\\nIAO\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"28","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PMDSENSO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"191","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"53"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/sensotwin/applicationontology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/sensotwin/applicationontology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/pmd/co, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o-inverses#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/pmd/co, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o-inverses#]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/SENSOTWIN\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"6"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ursula Pähler\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/7dba5f30-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/7dba5f30-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.1."},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_SENSOTWIN, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_SENSOTWIN, name=MaterialDigital / SensoTwin, description=MaterialDigital subproject SensoTwin, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_SENSOTWIN, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":51.0,"normalizedScore":35,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":257.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6645},"PODO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cdos/podo/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cdos/podo/1.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PODO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/OCDO/ldo","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Point Defects Ontology (PODO) focuses on point-defect representation in crystalline materials, including classes for vacancy, interstitial, substitutional impurity, antisite, Frenkel, and Schottky defects, plus related concentration/count data properties. It supports semantically consistent annotation of point-defect characteristics across computational and experimental datasets.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/OCDO/podo/main/podo.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Point Defects Ontology (PODO)","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/OCDO/podo"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PODO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:03:14.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PODO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PODO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PODO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/PODO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PODO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PODO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PODO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PODO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cdos/podo/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/cdos/podo/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PODO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7564-7990\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/397e6d90-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/397e6d90-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6776-1213\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39feaa70-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39feaa70-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9560-4728\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a154560-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a154560-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PODO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, homePage=https://nfdi-matwerk.de/solutions/all-solutions/semantics, institution=NFDI-MatWerk, updated=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ASMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMEO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CMSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MWO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PLDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PODO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RDOC], created=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NFDIMATWERK, name=NFDI-MatWerk Semantic Resources, description=Project entry for NFDI-MatWerk semantic resources curated in MatPortal dev. The project groups ontologies that are directly NFDI-MatWerk authored, NFDI-MatWerk infrastructure-use-case resources, or NFDI-MatWerk-listed semantic resources relevant to materials science and engineering interoperability., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/nfdimatwerk"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":236.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4623},"PPO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/ao/poly/ontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/ao/poly/0.1"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PPO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDCO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"PMDCo Poly Ontology represents polymers, polymer composites, and related process and property knowledge in the PMD/OntOMat context. Its scope follows OntoMat's focus on fiber-reinforced polymers and associated processes, providing a polymer-centered ontology layer that aligns this domain with PMD-compatible semantics.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"PMDCo Poly Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/PlantPhenoOntology/ppo"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1104","omv:numberOfProperties":"106","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"50"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:52.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"6","dct:created":"2026-02-06T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PPO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"54","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PPO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"149","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PPO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"77"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/ao/poly/ontology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/ao/poly/ontology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDCO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"11"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Patrick Schneider\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/7f8128f0-edb6-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/7f8128f0-edb6-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Martin Koerdel\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/7fda0090-edb6-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/7fda0090-edb6-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Thomas Hanke\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/7fef03b0-edb6-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/7fef03b0-edb6-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Maja Milicic Brandt\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/80088db0-edb6-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/80088db0-edb6-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMD, name=MaterialDigital / PMD, description=Platform MaterialDigital project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDCO, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMDCO, name=MaterialDigital / PMD Core, description=PMD core ontology project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDCO, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":53.0,"normalizedScore":37,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":257.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6919},"PRIMACOMP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/complete"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PRIMACOMP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/Materials-Data-Science-and-Informatics/MDMC-NEP-top-level-ontology","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"PRIMA Complete Ontology is the integrated provenance ontology package for materials science that combines PRIMA modules (core, dataset, experiment, data-analysis lifecycle, and computational workflow) in one importable ontology. It is designed to capture end-to-end provenance context across experimental and computational materials workflows.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"PRIMA Complete Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/Materials-Data-Science-and-Informatics/MDMC-NEP-top-level-ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"978","omv:numberOfProperties":"135","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"PRIMA","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PRIMACOMP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"42"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:38:07.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"3","dct:created":"2026-01-15T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PRIMACOMP&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This is the Provenance Information for Materials Science (PRIMA) Ontology, version 3.0, aligned with PMDco v3 and based on BFO (Basic Formal Ontology). This complete module imports all PRIMA modules (core, data-analysis-lifecycle, dataset, experiment, and computational) in their v3.0 versions.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PRIMACOMP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PRIMACOMP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"56","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/PRIMACOMP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PRIMACOMP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"105","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PRIMACOMP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PRIMACOMP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PRIMACOMP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"77"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":63.0,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/complete","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/complete"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/core, https://w3id.org/pmd/co/, https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/computational, https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/dal, https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/dataset, https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/experiment]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/core, https://w3id.org/pmd/co/, https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/computational, https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/dal, https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/dataset, https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/experiment]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PRIMACOMP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/complete?version=2.0","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"11"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ahmad Zainul Ihsan\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/438150b0-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/438150b0-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Rossella Aversa\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/43986d90-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/43986d90-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mehrdad Jalali\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/43ad7290-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/43ad7290-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Elda Osmenaj\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/44060330-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/44060330-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mirco Panighel\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/441c9740-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/441c9740-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PRIMACOMP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/complete?version=2.0","owl:versionInfo":"3.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":249.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7349},"PRIMACORE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/core"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PRIMACORE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/Materials-Data-Science-and-Informatics/MDMC-NEP-top-level-ontology","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"PRIMA Core Ontology is the foundational module of PRIMA, providing the central high-level classes and relations (entity/activity/agent and related research objects/roles) used by the other PRIMA modules to encode provenance information in materials-science workflows.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"PRIMA Core Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/Materials-Data-Science-and-Informatics/MDMC-NEP-top-level-ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"952","omv:numberOfProperties":"109","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"PRIMA","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PRIMACORE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"42"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:20.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"3","dct:created":"2026-01-15T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PRIMACORE&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This is the core module of the Provenance Information for Materials Science (PRIMA) Ontology, version 3.0, aligned with PMDco v3 and based on BFO (Basic Formal Ontology).\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PRIMACORE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PRIMACORE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"58","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/PRIMACORE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PRIMACORE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"108","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PRIMACORE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PRIMACORE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PRIMACORE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"77"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":63.0,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/core","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/core"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PRIMACORE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/core?version=2.0","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"11"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ahmad Zainul Ihsan\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/438150b0-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/438150b0-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Rossella Aversa\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/43986d90-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/43986d90-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mehrdad Jalali\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/43ad7290-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/43ad7290-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Elda Osmenaj\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/44060330-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/44060330-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mirco Panighel\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/441c9740-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/441c9740-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PRIMACORE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/prima/core?version=2.0","owl:versionInfo":"3.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":249.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5788},"PROCESSONTOLOGY":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/steel/ProcessOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PROCESSONTOLOGY","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/STAHL\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/STEELDIGITALONTOLOGY\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://materialdigital.github.io/stahl-digital-ontology-public","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"`steel_ProcessOntology` is the main process vocabulary used in the StahlDigital ontology stack, providing extensive steel-processing, testing, simulation, and parameter terms in multilingual labels for workflow-centric data representation. It underpins ontology-based workflow documentation and semantic data handling in StahlDigital use cases.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/stahldigital-ontology-public/main/docs/index.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"steel_ProcessOntology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/stahldigital-ontology-public"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:03:16.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PROCESSONTOLOGY&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PROCESSONTOLOGY&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/steel/ProcessOntology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/steel/ProcessOntology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/STAHL\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/STEELDIGITALONTOLOGY\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Clemens Fehrenbach, Alexander Butz, Alexander Wessel, Andreas Trondl, Silke Klitschke, Paul Zierep, Lukas Morand, Dirk Helm\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/7e2be0b0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/7e2be0b0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.1 (preliminary)"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_STAHLDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV], created=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_STAHLDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital / StahlDigital, description=MaterialDigital subproject StahlDigital, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_STAHLDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":24,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":232.0,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5516},"PROVO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PROVO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://www.w3.org/TR/prov-o/","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"PROV-O is the W3C provenance ontology for representing entities, activities, and agents involved in producing data. In metrology it is useful for documenting measurement-generation workflows, processing steps, and traceability chains around reported results.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"PROV-O: The PROV Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/w3c/prov-o"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"31","omv:numberOfProperties":"50","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROVO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"4"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-17T12:19:09.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-04-17T12:19:08.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PROVO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This document is published by the Provenance Working Group (http://www.w3.org/2011/prov/wiki/Main_Page). \\n\\nIf you wish to make comments regarding this document, please send them to public-prov-comments@w3.org (subscribe public-prov-comments-request@w3.org, archives http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-prov-comments/). All feedback is welcome.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROVO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROVO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROVO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PROVO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"11","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROVO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROVO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PROVO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"7"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROVO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"3"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Metrology Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROVO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"Recommendation version 2013-04-30"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, homePage=https://www.bipm.org/en/measurement-units, institution=MatPortal curation (multi-source metrology set), updated=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CQU, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MASON, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROVO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SIS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SOSA, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSN], created=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=METROLOGY, name=Metrology And Measurement Ontologies, description=Curated multi-source project entry for metrology ontologies in MatPortal dev. The project groups non-biomedical ontologies for units, quantities, dimensional analysis, digital calibration, uncertainty representation, sensor provenance, and measurement-aware domain semantics., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/metrology"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":230.0,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3674},"QUDT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://qudt.org/schema/coordinateSystems"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"QUDT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://qudt.org/doc/2016/DOC_SCHEMA-QUDT-v2.0.html","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"QUDT provides a computational model for quantities, units, dimensions, and related datatypes, with explicit dimensional analysis and conversion structures. It is widely used in systems engineering and measurement-intensive software to validate unit consistency and support interoperable quantitative data.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://qudt.org/schema/qudt.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Quantities, Units, Dimensions, and Data Types (QUDT)","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/qudt/qudt-public-repo"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"105","omv:numberOfProperties":"196","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"34"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-05-26T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-05-26T18:01:27.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=QUDT&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"11","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=QUDT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"99","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/QUDT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"28"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://qudt.org/schema/coordinateSystems","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://qudt.org/schema/coordinateSystems"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.linkedmodel.org/schema/vaem, http://qudt.org/3.2.1/schema/datatype, http://www.linkedmodel.org/schema/dtype, http://qudt.org/schema/coordinateSystems]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.linkedmodel.org/schema/vaem, http://qudt.org/3.2.1/schema/datatype, http://www.linkedmodel.org/schema/dtype, http://qudt.org/schema/coordinateSystems]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"5"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Metrology Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, homePage=https://www.bipm.org/en/measurement-units, institution=MatPortal curation (multi-source metrology set), updated=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CQU, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MASON, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROVO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SIS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SOSA, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSN], created=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=METROLOGY, name=Metrology And Measurement Ontologies, description=Curated multi-source project entry for metrology ontologies in MatPortal dev. The project groups non-biomedical ontologies for units, quantities, dimensional analysis, digital calibration, uncertainty representation, sensor provenance, and measurement-aware domain semantics., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/PHYSICS, homePage=https://physh.org/, institution=MatPortal curation (multi-source physics set), updated=2026-04-17T14:40:05.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDO-FULL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSCI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PHYSH, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT], created=2026-04-17T14:40:05.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=PHYSICS, name=Physics Ontologies, description=Curated multi-source project entry for non-biomedical physics ontologies in MatPortal dev. The project groups foundational measurement ontologies, upper and domain ontologies for physical systems and materials, and ontology resources used to organize physics knowledge and publications., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/PHYSICS, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/metrology, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/physics]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5232},"RDOC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/rdo/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/rdo/1.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RDOC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Reference Dataset Ontology (RDOC) defines concepts needed to qualify and describe reference datasets, including referencing, documentation, certification, standards, licenses, and reference-material context. In the NFDI-MatWerk/IUC02 scope, it combines this general reference-dataset model with creep-testing-specific metadata and data concepts so reference datasets in materials science are interoperable, searchable, and reusable.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Reference Dataset Ontology (RDOC)","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"74","omv:numberOfProperties":"59","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RDOC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:55.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-02-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=RDOC&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RDOC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RDOC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"4","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/RDOC/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=RDOC&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"53","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RDOC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RDOC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/RDOC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"32"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":16.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/rdo/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purls.helmholtz-metadaten.de/rdo/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RDOC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"3"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9560-4728\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a154560-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a154560-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9560-4728\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a154560-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a154560-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RDOC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, homePage=https://nfdi-matwerk.de/solutions/all-solutions/semantics, institution=NFDI-MatWerk, updated=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ASMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CHAMEO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CMSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DISO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MWO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PLDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PODO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RDOC], created=2026-04-16T16:36:39.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=NFDIMATWERK, name=NFDI-MatWerk Semantic Resources, description=Project entry for NFDI-MatWerk semantic resources curated in MatPortal dev. The project groups ontologies that are directly NFDI-MatWerk authored, NFDI-MatWerk infrastructure-use-case resources, or NFDI-MatWerk-listed semantic resources relevant to materials science and engineering interoperability., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/NFDIMATWERK, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/nfdimatwerk"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":53.0,"normalizedScore":37,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":248.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5757},"RELOD":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/relod/relodOntology/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RELOD","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"RelodOnto is a compact dataset-matching ontology centered on dataset linkage semantics. It defines source and target dataset entities, property-level match constructs, and relation types such as exact and similar property correspondences, enabling machine-readable representation of reconciliation and mapping results.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"RelodOnto","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"7","omv:numberOfProperties":"9","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RELOD/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:21.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2023-02-20T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=RELOD&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RELOD/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RELOD/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/RELOD/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=RELOD&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"7","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RELOD/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RELOD/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/RELOD","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"5"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":16.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":58.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/relod/relodOntology/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/relod/relodOntology/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RELOD/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Andre Valdestilhas"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RELOD/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":19,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":219.0,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4324},"RXNO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/rxno.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/rxno/releases/2021-12-16/rxno.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RXNO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEM_REACTIONS\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEMISTRY\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/NFDI4CAT\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/NFDI4CHEM\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Name Reaction Ontology (RXNO) provides a structured ontology of named organic reactions and links them to their roles in synthesis and to process-level concepts in MOP. It includes hundreds of reaction classes (for example Diels-Alder and Cannizzaro) for interoperable reaction annotation and semantic querying.","omv:resourceLocator":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/rxno.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Name Reaction Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/rsc-ontology/rxno"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1019","omv:numberOfProperties":"14","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"RXNO","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RXNO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:49.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"8","dct:created":"2026-02-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=RXNO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RXNO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RXNO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"95","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/RXNO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=RXNO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"192","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RXNO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RXNO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/RXNO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"53"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":85,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":74.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/rxno.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/rxno.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RXNO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEM_REACTIONS\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/CHEMISTRY\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/NFDI4CAT\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/NFDI4CHEM\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RXNO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/chemistry"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":257.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4889},"SCIMONTO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/SCIMOnto.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SCIMONTO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"SCIMOnto is an integrated monitoring ontology that combines the CFMO, ECMO, EvMO, IMO, and SMO modules in one framework. It unifies shared concepts for sensors, parameters, analyses, alerts, areas, and response actions, enabling cross-domain reasoning over crowd-flow, utility consumption, environmental state, incident handling, and structural monitoring data.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/SCIMOnto.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"SCIMOnto","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/zhu-huiwen/scimonto-ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"895","omv:numberOfProperties":"559","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCIMONTO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"29"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:28.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2026-02-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SCIMONTO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCIMONTO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCIMONTO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"53","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/SCIMONTO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SCIMONTO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"583","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCIMONTO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCIMONTO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SCIMONTO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"39"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/SCIMOnto.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://zhu-huiwen.github.io/scimonto-ontology/SCIMOnto.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCIMONTO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"10"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCIMONTO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":237.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3807},"SDO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/stahl/SteelDigitalOntology/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SDO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/STAHL\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/STEELDIGITALONTOLOGY\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://materialdigital.github.io/stahldigital-ontology-public","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"StahlDigital Ontology is the project ontology framework for steel-domain data in StahlDigital, used to semantically represent process, experiment, and simulation information for ontology-based workflows and FAIR data handling in steel R&D use cases.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"StahlDigital Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/stahldigital-ontology-demo"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"86","omv:numberOfProperties":"22","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:38:02.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-02-06T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SDO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SDO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"58","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SDO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"86"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/stahl/SteelDigitalOntology/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/stahl/SteelDigitalOntology/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/STAHL\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/STEELDIGITALONTOLOGY\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.1 (preliminary)"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_STAHLDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV], created=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_STAHLDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital / StahlDigital, description=MaterialDigital subproject StahlDigital, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_STAHLDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":230.0,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4317},"SDOV":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/steel/ProcessOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SDOV","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"StahlDigital Ontology Versioning captures versioned evolution of the StahlDigital ontology artifacts and associated workflow vocabulary, supporting controlled updates and traceable ontology releases within the StahlDigital semantic toolchain.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"StahlDigital Ontology Versioning","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/stahldigital-ontology-public"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"484","omv:numberOfProperties":"642","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"510"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:13.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2026-02-16T20:23:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SDOV&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"2","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SDOV&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"407","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SDOV","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"310"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/steel/ProcessOntology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/steel/ProcessOntology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Clemens Fehrenbach, Alexander Butz, Alexander Wessel, Andreas Trondl, Silke Klitschke, Paul Zierep, Lukas Morand, Dirk Helm\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/98d77310-edb2-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/98d77310-edb2-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_STAHLDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV], created=2026-02-16T21:34:22.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_STAHLDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital / StahlDigital, description=MaterialDigital subproject StahlDigital, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_STAHLDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":36.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":229.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6342},"SENSOTWIN":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/SensoTwinComplete"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/SensoTwinComplete/1.1.4"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SENSOTWIN","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"SensoTwin Ontology provides FRP-focused concepts for the SensoTwin project, spanning materials, production and testing processes, parameters/results, and simulation-relevant entities to support a sensor-integrated digital-twin workflow for rotor-blade use cases.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"SensoTwin Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/upaehler/SensoTwin"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"216","omv:numberOfProperties":"40","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"195"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:04.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-02-06T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SENSOTWIN&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology describes fibre composites according to the needs in the project SensoTwin\\n\\nIt takes care of: \\nused materials\\nproduction processes \\nTesting processes, parameters and results\\nStarting to Align to PMDCO\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"5","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SENSOTWIN&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"208","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"47"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/SensoTwinComplete","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/SensoTwinComplete"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"5"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_SENSOTWIN, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_SENSOTWIN, name=MaterialDigital / SensoTwin, description=MaterialDigital subproject SensoTwin, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_SENSOTWIN, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":228.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3630},"SIS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://ptb.de/sis/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://ptb.de/sis/v0.2.1/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SIS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://ptb.de/sis/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://www.ptb.de/sis","doap:bugDatabase":"https://gitlab1.ptb.de/d-ptb/d-si/ontology-d-si/-/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The SIS Ontology from PTB models semantically interoperable SI-based measurement results, including units, values, and GUM-compliant uncertainty structures. It is intended for digital calibration and metrology workflows that need machine-readable uncertainty and traceability information.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://ptb.gitlab.io/dcc/ontology-d-si/ontology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"SIS Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://ror.org/05r3f7h03\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/41266d20-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/41266d20-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"https://gitlab1.ptb.de/d-ptb/d-si/ontology-d-si"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"29","omv:numberOfProperties":"37","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"sis","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SIS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"7"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-17T12:18:56.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"Ontology presenting the schema for metrologically correct representation of quantity values including numerical value, kind of quantity, measurement unit and uncertainty declaration.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-04-17T12:18:55.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SIS&q=","schema:comment":"[\"\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SIS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SIS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SIS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SIS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"22","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SIS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SIS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SIS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"11"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":78.0,"normalizedScore":69,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://ptb.de/sis/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://ptb.de/sis/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SIS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Metrology Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9095-0063\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40b28610-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40b28610-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2190-6931\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40ca9500-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40ca9500-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6461-2554\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40dfcc20-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40dfcc20-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0941-5950\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40f3afe0-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40f3afe0-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2239-3955\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/4107fd20-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/4107fd20-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SIS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v0.2.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, homePage=https://www.bipm.org/en/measurement-units, institution=MatPortal curation (multi-source metrology set), updated=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CQU, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MASON, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROVO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SIS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SOSA, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSN], created=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=METROLOGY, name=Metrology And Measurement Ontologies, description=Curated multi-source project entry for metrology ontologies in MatPortal dev. The project groups non-biomedical ontologies for units, quantities, dimensional analysis, digital calibration, uncertainty representation, sensor provenance, and measurement-aware domain semantics., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/metrology"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":51.0,"normalizedScore":35,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":271.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5862},"SMADIONT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":3.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"urn:absolute/smadiont#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":15.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SMADIONT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"SmaDi-Ontology is a PMD project ontology for smart materials, designed to support ontology-based data access (OBDA) and semantic linking of smart-material data and model artifacts. It defines the conceptual backbone used in SmaDi?s ontology-based data/model access workflows.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/materialdigital1_ontology_collection/main/SmaDi/tbox/smadi_ont.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"SmaDi-Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/SmaDi-Project/OBDMA-System"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-17T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-17T18:01:06.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SMADIONT&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This is an ontology for the PMD-project SmaDi, designed for smart materials and with the focus on using it in the context of ontology-based data access (OBDA).\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SMADIONT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SMADIONT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":54.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"urn:absolute/smadiont#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"urn:absolute/smadiont#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mena Leemhuis\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3e35c7e0-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3e35c7e0-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_SMADI, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:26.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT], created=2026-02-16T21:34:26.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_SMADI, name=MaterialDigital / SmaDi, description=MaterialDigital subproject SmaDi, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_SMADI, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":24,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":222.0,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4432},"SMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/SCIMOnto-ontologies/SMO.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"SMO is the structural-monitoring module of SCIMOnto. It models structural sensing and analysis for parameters such as strain, displacement, stress, and crack-related indicators, together with condition-assessment alerts and maintenance actions. The ontology links instrumentation, monitored components and areas, and assessment workflows for infrastructure health monitoring.","omv:resourceLocator":"http://w3id.org/SCIMOnto-ontologies/SMO.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"SMO","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"387","omv:numberOfProperties":"152","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"22"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:50.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2026-02-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SMO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"35","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/SMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"144","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"39"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/SCIMOnto-ontologies/SMO.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/SCIMOnto-ontologies/SMO.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/iao.owl, http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/, http://www.w3.org/ns/ssn/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/iao.owl, http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/, http://www.w3.org/ns/ssn/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"10"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":225.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4411},"SOSA":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SOSA","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"SOSA is the lightweight core of the W3C and OGC Semantic Sensor Network stack. It models observations, sensors, samples, actuators, procedures, results, and features of interest for interoperable measurement-event data., This ontology is based on the SSN Ontology by the W3C Semantic Sensor Networks Incubator Group (SSN-XG), together with considerations from the W3C/OGC Spatial Data on the Web Working Group.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Sensor, Observation, Sample, and Actuator (SOSA) Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/w3c/sdw-sosa-ssn"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"16","omv:numberOfProperties":"23","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"sosa","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SOSA/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-17T12:19:05.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2017-04-17T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SOSA&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SOSA/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SOSA/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SOSA/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SOSA&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"3","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SOSA/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SOSA/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SOSA","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"16"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":85,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":65.0,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SOSA/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://www.w3.org/Consortium/Legal/2015/copyright-software-and-document","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://www.w3.org/Consortium/Legal/2015/copyright-software-and-document"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Metrology Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SOSA/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, homePage=https://www.bipm.org/en/measurement-units, institution=MatPortal curation (multi-source metrology set), updated=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CQU, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MASON, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROVO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SIS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SOSA, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSN], created=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=METROLOGY, name=Metrology And Measurement Ontologies, description=Curated multi-source project entry for metrology ontologies in MatPortal dev. The project groups non-biomedical ontologies for units, quantities, dimensional analysis, digital calibration, uncertainty representation, sensor provenance, and measurement-aware domain semantics., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/metrology"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":39.0,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":237.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3615},"SSN":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/ssn/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SSN","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.w3.org/ns/ssn/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://www.w3.org/2015/spatial/wiki/Semantic_Sensor_Network_Ontology","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Semantic Sensor Network Ontology models sensors, systems, deployments, capabilities, and observation-related context. In metrology workflows it provides the provenance and instrument-model layer around how measurements are produced and under which operating conditions., This ontology describes sensors, actuators and observations, and related concepts. It does not describe domain concepts, time, locations, etc. these are intended to be included from other ontologies via OWL imports.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://www.w3.org/ns/ssn/","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Semantic Sensor Network Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/w3c/sdw-sosa-ssn"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"23","omv:numberOfProperties":"38","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"ssn","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSN/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-17T12:19:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2017-04-17T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SSN&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Please report any errors to the W3C Spatial Data on the Web Working Group via the SDW WG Public List public-sdw-wg@w3.org\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSN/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSN/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"2","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSN/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SSN&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"4","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSN/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSN/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SSN","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"16"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/ssn/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/ssn/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSN/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://www.w3.org/Consortium/Legal/2015/copyright-software-and-document","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://www.w3.org/Consortium/Legal/2015/copyright-software-and-document"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Metrology Import"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSN/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"New modular version of the SSN ontology. \n\nThis ontology was originally developed in 2009-2011 by the W3C Semantic Sensor Networks Incubator Group (SSN-XG). For more information on the group's activities see: http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/ssn/. The ontology was revised and modularized in 2015-2017 by the W3C/OGC Spatial Data on the Web Working Group, see: https://www.w3.org/2015/spatial/wiki/Semantic_Sensor_Network_Ontology. \n\nIn particular, (a) the scope is extended to include actuation and sampling; (b) the core concepts and properties are factored out into the SOSA ontology. The SSN ontology imports SOSA and adds formal axiomatization consistent with the text definitions in SOSA, and adds classes and properties to accommodate the scope of the original SSN ontology. "},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, homePage=https://www.bipm.org/en/measurement-units, institution=MatPortal curation (multi-source metrology set), updated=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CQU, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLOSISUNIT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MASON, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OM, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROVO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/QUDT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SIS, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SOSA, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSN], created=2026-04-17T12:19:27.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=METROLOGY, name=Metrology And Measurement Ontologies, description=Curated multi-source project entry for metrology ontologies in MatPortal dev. The project groups non-biomedical ontologies for units, quantities, dimensional analysis, digital calibration, uncertainty representation, sensor provenance, and measurement-aware domain semantics., contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/METROLOGY, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/metrology"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":246.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3726},"SSOS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.niso.org/standards-committees/ssos/ssos01.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SSOS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Standards-Specific Ontology Standard (SSOS) provides a high-level generic ontology which describes the life cycle of consensus-based standardization projects and published standardization deliverables, i.e., standards. Developers, publishers, distributors, and users of standards, including national standards bodies, regional and international standards bodies, standards development organizations, and business, can use SSOS to better structure the life cycle information of their own standards or to better structure and automatically analyze and compare development stages of standardization activities and the life cycle of standards publications.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://www.niso.org/standards-committees/ssos/ssos01.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Standards-Specific Ontology Standard","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSOS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:03:24.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SSOS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSOS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSOS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/SSOS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SSOS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSOS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSOS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SSOS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":16.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":58.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.niso.org/standards-committees/ssos/ssos01.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.niso.org/standards-committees/ssos/ssos01.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"alpha"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSOS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"NISO SSOS Working Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SSOS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":17,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":231.0,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4396},"STY":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://data.bioontology.org/ontologies/STY/submissions/24"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"STY","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Semantic Types Ontology is a high-level semantic typing vocabulary that provides broad subject categories and relation types used to classify concepts consistently across large terminology systems. It functions as an upper typing layer rather than a process-specific materials ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Semantic Types Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"127","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/STY/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:15.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2024-11-04T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=STY&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/STY/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/STY/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"12","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/STY/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=STY&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"127","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/STY/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/STY/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/STY","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"9"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":16.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":58.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://data.bioontology.org/ontologies/STY/submissions/24","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://data.bioontology.org/ontologies/STY/submissions/24"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"UMLS"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"UMLS"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":11,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"http://www.w3.org/ns/formats/Turtle","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/STY/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":12.0,"normalizedScore":11,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"null","mod:maxDepth":"7"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/STY/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":17,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":193.0,"normalizedScore":40,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4900},"TESTTFSCO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purl.archive.org/tfsco"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/oborel/obo-relations/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"TESTTFSCO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://nomad-hzb.github.io/autoperosol","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology for thinfilm solar cells (TFSCO) - Test version is a pre-release version of the TFSCO ontology for representing the manufacturing and characterization of perovskite thin-film solar cells. It follows the same solar-cell domain scope as TFSCO and is used to validate evolving ontology content before stable releases are published.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Ontology for thinfilm solar cells (TFSCO) - Test version","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/nomad-hzb/autoperosol"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"633","omv:numberOfProperties":"52","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TESTTFSCO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"53"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:08.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"3","dct:created":"2025-10-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=TESTTFSCO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TESTTFSCO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TESTTFSCO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"65","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/TESTTFSCO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=TESTTFSCO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"250","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TESTTFSCO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TESTTFSCO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/TESTTFSCO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"34"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purl.archive.org/tfsco","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purl.archive.org/tfsco"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TESTTFSCO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"10"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TESTTFSCO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"pre release, latest changes: 2023-05-09"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":254.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":9533},"TFSCO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/ot2661/ontologies/2022/8/TFSCO"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/oborel/obo-relations/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"TFSCO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Thin-film solar cell ontology (TFSCO) is a domain ontology for the manufacturing and characterization of perovskite solar cells. It has been under development since 2022 and is also used in a NOMAD-based data structure that links ontology classes to research data through IRIs in a machine-readable way.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Ontology for thinfilm solar cells","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/nomad-hzb/autoperosol"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"633","omv:numberOfProperties":"55","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TFSCO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"53"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:13.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"3","dct:created":"2025-10-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=TFSCO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TFSCO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TFSCO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"65","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/TFSCO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=TFSCO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"315","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TFSCO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TFSCO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/TFSCO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"34"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/ot2661/ontologies/2022/8/TFSCO","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/ot2661/ontologies/2022/8/TFSCO"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TFSCO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"10"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TFSCO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"pre release, latest changes: 2023-05-09"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":243.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3678},"TSRTO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/relaxation-test/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"TSRTO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Tensile Stress Relaxation Test Ontology (TSRTO) was developed for representing the tensile stress relaxation testing process, testing equipment requirements, test pieces characteristics, and related testing parameters and their measurement procedure according to DIN EN ISO 10319-1 standard.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/relaxation-test/-/raw/main/TSRTO1.0.2.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Tensile Stress Relaxation Test Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/HosseinBeygiNasrabadi/Tensile-Stress-Relaxation-Test-Ontology-TSRTO"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"54","omv:numberOfProperties":"21","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"118"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:38:06.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2025-10-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=TSRTO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Tensile Stress Relaxation Test Ontology (TSRTO) has developed for representing the tensile stress relaxation testing process, testing equipment requirements, test pieces charactristics, and related testing parameters and their measurement procedure according to DIN EN ISO 10319-1 standard.\",\"KupferDigital project (www.materialdigital.de/project/1)\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=TSRTO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"54","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/TSRTO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"54"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/relaxation-test/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://gitlab.com/kupferdigital/process-graphs/relaxation-test/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Beygi Nasrabadi, Hossein (www.orcid.org/0000-0002-3092-0532)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/64c6b4a0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/64c6b4a0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Skrotzki, Birgit\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/64dda840-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/64dda840-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.2 (BFO, CCO, MSEO, MTO)"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMD, name=MaterialDigital / PMD, description=Platform MaterialDigital project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMDAO, name=MaterialDigital / PMD Application Ontologies, description=PMD application ontologies, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":36.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":240.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7451},"TTE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/ao/tte/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"TTE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://materialdigital.github.io/application-ontologies/tto","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"TTE is a tensile-test data-mapping example ontology that demonstrates how tensile-test records can be represented with TTO and PMDco-aligned semantics. It is aimed at practical RDF conversion and integration scenarios, showing how measurement data and metadata from tensile workflows are linked to standardized ontology classes and relations.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/application-ontologies/main/tensile_test_ontology_TTO/pmd_tto_data_mapping_example.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Tensile Test Ontology (TTO) data mapping example","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/tensile-test-ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:03:27.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=TTE&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=TTE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/TTE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/ao/tte/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/ao/tte/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Philipp von Hartrott\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/133b3850-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/133b3850-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jörg Waitelonis\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/243f0d10-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/243f0d10-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Markus Schilling\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/247ef750-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/247ef750-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jörg Waitelonis\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/37124f20-edb4-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/37124f20-edb4-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":233.0,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5403},"TTO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/tto/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/tto/3.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"TTO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://materialdigital.github.io/tensile-test-ontology","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"MaterialDigital Tensile Test Ontology (TTO) for representing tensile testing processes, equipment requirements, test piece characteristics, testing parameters, and measurement procedures according to ISO 6892-1., Dies ist die PMD-Ontologie für Zugversuche (Tensile Test Ontology ? TTO), die auf der Grundlage der Prüfnorm \"ISO 6892-1: Metallische Werkstoffe ? Zugversuche ? Teil 1: Prüfverfahren bei Raumtemperatur\" entwickelt wurde.\n\nDie TTO wurde im Rahmen des PMD-Projekts entwickelt. Die TTO bietet Konzeptualisierungen, die für die Beschreibung von Zugversuchen und entsprechenden Daten gemäß der jeweiligen Prüfnorm gültig sind. Durch die Verwendung der TTO zur Speicherung von Zugversuchsdaten sind alle Daten gut strukturiert und basieren auf einem gemeinsamen Vokabular, das von einer Expertengruppe vereinbart wurde (Erzeugung von FAIRen-Daten), was zu einer verbesserten Dateninteroperabilität führen wird. Durch den Import der PMD Core Ontology (PMDco) wird die Interoperabilität von Zugprüfungsdaten verbessert und die Abfrage in Kombination mit anderen Aspekten und Daten aus dem breiten Feld der Materialwissenschaft und Werkstofftechnik (MSE) erleichtert., This is thePMD ontology of the tensile test (Tensile Test Ontology - TTO) as developed on the basis of the test standard ISO 6892-1: Metallic materials - Tensile Testing - Part 1: Method of test at room temperature.\n\nThe TTO was developed in the frame of the PMD project. The TTO provides conceptualizations valid for the description of tensile tests and corresponding data in accordance with the respective test standard. By using TTO for storing tensile test data, all data will be well structured and based on a common vocabulary agreed on by an expert group (generation of FAIR data) which will lead to enhanced data interoperability. Due to the import of the PMD core ontology (PMDco), the interoperability of tensile test data is enhanced and querying in combination with other aspects and data within the broad field of material science and engineering (MSE) is facilitated.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/tensile-test-ontology/main/tto.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Tensile Test Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/tensile-test-ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1161","omv:numberOfProperties":"101","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"101"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-05-18T16:15:52.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"5","dct:created":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=TTO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"74","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=TTO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"112","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/TTO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"77"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/tto/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/tto/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"https://w3id.org/pmd/tto/2.0.1","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"10"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Curation"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Henk Birkholz\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/246c1a10-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/246c1a10-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Markus Schilling\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/247ef750-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/247ef750-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Bernd Bayerlein\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/24911340-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/24911340-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Philipp von Hartrott\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9811ea50-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9811ea50-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jörg Waitelonis\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c2bc03f0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c2bc03f0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1649-6832\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/07757940-3503-013f-223e-46e7a3ff78e8\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/07757940-3503-013f-223e-46e7a3ff78e8\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://w3id.org/pmd/tto/2.0.1","owl:versionInfo":"3.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMD, name=MaterialDigital / PMD, description=Platform MaterialDigital project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMDAO, name=MaterialDigital / PMD Application Ontologies, description=PMD application ontologies, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":53.0,"normalizedScore":37,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":254.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6984},"VIMMP_ONTOLOGIES":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purl.vimmp.eu/semantics/combined/combined-vimmp-ontologies.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"VIMMP_ONTOLOGIES","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Virtual Materials Marketplace (VIMMP) project is developing an open platform for providing and accessing services related to materials modelling. Within VIMMP, a system of marketplace-level ontologies is developed to characterize services, models, and interactions between users; the European Materials and Modelling Ontology (EMMO, recently renamed while keeping the original acronym) is employed as a top-level ontology. The ontologies are used to annotate data that are stored in the ZONTAL Space component of VIMMP and to support the ingest and retrieval of data and metadata at the VIMMP marketplace front-end.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Virtual Materials Marketplace (VIMMP) Ontologies","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Virtual Materials Marketplace (VIMMP) project consortium\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6cbe73c0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6cbe73c0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Virtual Materials Marketplace (VIMMP) project consortium\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d106b00-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d106b00-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1082","omv:numberOfProperties":"771","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VIMMP_ONTOLOGIES/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"897"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:36:20.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"7","dct:created":"2021-01-02T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"doi:10.1007/s13218-020-00648-9\",\"doi:10.1021/acs.jced.9b00739\",\"doi:10.5281/zenodo.3936795\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=VIMMP_ONTOLOGIES&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The authors acknowledge funding from the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and \\ninnovation programme under grant agreement no. 760907, Virtual Materials Marketplace (VIMMP).\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VIMMP_ONTOLOGIES/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VIMMP_ONTOLOGIES/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"99","dct:modified":"2021-01-02T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/VIMMP_ONTOLOGIES/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=VIMMP_ONTOLOGIES&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"393","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VIMMP_ONTOLOGIES/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VIMMP_ONTOLOGIES/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/VIMMP_ONTOLOGIES","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"67"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purl.vimmp.eu/semantics/combined/combined-vimmp-ontologies.ttl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purl.vimmp.eu/semantics/combined/combined-vimmp-ontologies.ttl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VIMMP_ONTOLOGIES/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"16"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Martin Thomas Horsch"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ilian T. Todorov (ORCID 0000-0001-7275-1784)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/68dea220-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/68dea220-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Martin Thomas Horsch (ORCID 0000-0002-9464-6739)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/68f556a0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/68f556a0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Michael A. Seaton (ORCID 0000-0002-4708-573X)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/690c28e0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/690c28e0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Silvia Chiacchiera (ORCID 0000-0003-0422-7870)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/69223790-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/69223790-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Adham Hashibon\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/69806030-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/69806030-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Martin Lísal (ORCID 0000-0001-8005-7143)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/699638f0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/699638f0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Vladimir Lobaskin (ORCID 0000-0002-5231-0639)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/69aa6a20-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/69aa6a20-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Vincent Stobiac\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/69bff620-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/69bff620-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Hauke Brüning\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/69d48c20-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/69d48c20-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Welchy Leite Cavalcanti\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/69e97490-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/69e97490-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Peter Klein\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6a005920-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6a005920-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gerhard Goldbeck (ORCID 0000-0002-4181-2852)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6a19e090-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6a19e090-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Björn Schembera (ORCID 0000-0003-2860-6621)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6a2faa00-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6a2faa00-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mara Chiricotto (ORCID 0000-0003-1609-5254)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6a44a6a0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6a44a6a0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Christoph Niethammer\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6a5a3b40-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6a5a3b40-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Daniele Toti (ORCID 0000-0002-9668-6961)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6a6f2c80-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6a6f2c80-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Natalia A. Konchakova\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6a840f30-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6a840f30-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Andreas Fiseni\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6a987ae0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6a987ae0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Andrea Scotto di Minico\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6aaf0560-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6aaf0560-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Esteban Bayro Kaiser (ORCID 0000-0002-5281-0836)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6ac3bc10-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6ac3bc10-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Barbara Andreon\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6ad9f230-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6ad9f230-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Youness Bami\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6aee9010-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6aee9010-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paola Carbone (ORCID 0000-0001-9927-8376)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6b042470-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6b042470-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Peter Schiffels\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6b18c9d0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6b18c9d0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jadran Vrabec (ORCID 0000-0002-7947-4051)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6b2e4260-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6b2e4260-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ignacio Pagonabarraga Mora (ORCID 0000-0002-6187-5025)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6b44c290-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6b44c290-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gianluca Boccardo (ORCID 0000-0003-1264-8237)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6b5b1620-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6b5b1620-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Philipp Neumann\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6b717550-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6b717550-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Helge Krieg\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6b8684a0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6b8684a0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yvan Fournier\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6b9c7780-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6b9c7780-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Éric Fayolle\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6bb02b60-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6bb02b60-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Georg J. Schmitz (0000-0003-4065-9742)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6bc57b50-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6bc57b50-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Karel ?indelka (ORCID 0000-0003-3925-924X)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6bdac0d0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6bdac0d0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Pascale Noyret\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6bef36a0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6bef36a0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Joshua D. Elliott (ORCID 0000-0002-0729-246X)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c042340-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c042340-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Javier Díaz Brañas\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c17e860-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c17e860-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jean-Pierre Minier\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c2c6a30-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c2c6a30-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Barbora Planková (ORCID 0000-0002-3309-6809)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c40d4e0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c40d4e0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Emanuele Ghedini (ORCID 0000-0003-3805-8761)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c5843c0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c5843c0-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VIMMP_ONTOLOGIES/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"Combined ontology release dated 2nd January 2021"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":226.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5803},"VTO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/vto/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/vto/3.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"VTO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Vickers Test Ontology (VTO) was developed for representing the Vickers testing process, testing equipment requirements, test pieces characteristics, and related testing parameters and their measurement procedure according to DIN EN ISO 6507-1 standard. VTO v3.0.0 (2025.11.03) reused BFO, RO, PMDco V3.0.0-alpha4, NFDIcore V3.0.0 and MWO V3.0.0 ontologies.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://w3id.org/pmd/vto/","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Vickers Test Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/vickers-testing-ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:03:37.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=VTO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Reused ontologies: BFO, RO, PMDco V3.0.0-alpha4, NFDIcore V3.0.0, MWO V3.0.0\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=VTO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/VTO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/vto/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/vto/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3092-0532\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c2a76780-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c2a76780-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jörg Waitelonis\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c2bc03f0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c2bc03f0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"3.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMD, name=MaterialDigital / PMD, description=Platform MaterialDigital project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMDAO, name=MaterialDigital / PMD Application Ontologies, description=PMD application ontologies, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":247.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5811},"WAAMAO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/WAAMAO"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"WAAMAO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing Application Ontology (WAAMAO) is an ODE_AM module for WAAM process representation, built on BFO and CCO and aligned with companion AM modules. It provides WAAM-specific terminology for process parameters, machine/process entities, and related manufacturing information to enable interoperable semantic data management in metal additive-manufacturing workflows.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/WAAMAO","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing Application Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/MaterialDigital/ODE_AM"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"40","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:37:17.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-02-06T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=WAAMAO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology, designed for use in data management for metal additive manufacturing with focus on Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing (WAAM). The ontology only included classes in the scope of project ODE_AM. It primarily integrates existing classes from the Basic Formal Ontology (BFO) and the Common Core Ontologies (CCO), selectively chosen to fit the considered use cases in our project. This focused approach ensures efficient and relevant data categorization and retrieval tailored to our specific project requirements.\",\"It uses Basic Formal Ontology as Top- and Common Core Ontologies as Mid-Level-Ontologies.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"4","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=WAAMAO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"9","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/WAAMAO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"30"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/WAAMAO","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ODE_AM/WAAMAO"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mohamed Kamal,  Jan Reimann\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/62144070-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/62144070-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_ODE_AM, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:26.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:26.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_ODE_AM, name=MaterialDigital / ODE_AM, description=MaterialDigital subproject ODE_AM, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_ODE_AM, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMD, name=MaterialDigital / PMD, description=Platform MaterialDigital project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMDAO, name=MaterialDigital / PMD Application Ontologies, description=PMD application ontologies, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":229.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6331},"WCSO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/wcso/wcso-full.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":6.0,"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"https://w3id.org/wcso/"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/wcso/releases/2026-04-20/wcso-full.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"WCSO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Wet-Chemical Syntheses Ontology (WCSO, WeChemSyn) provides a semantic framework for representing wet-chemical synthesis of (nano)particles, including experimental workflows, synthesis-process descriptions, and related data for Self-Driving Lab scenarios. It is developed at BAM and built on PMDco/BFO foundations to support interoperable and reusable synthesis knowledge representation across materials R&D pipelines., DieWet-Chemical Syntheses (WeChemSyn) Ontology (WCSO) bietet einen semantischen Rahmen für die strukturierte Darstellung von Wissen über die nass-chemische Synthese von (Nano)Partikeln. Die WCSO wurde an der Bundesanstalt für Materialforschung und -prüfung (BAM) in Berlin entwickelt und unterstützt die Formalisierung und Integration von Daten zur nass-chemischen Synthese über experimentelle Arbeitsabläufe, Prozesse und Materialeigenschaften hinweg. Sie baut auf der PMD Core Ontology (PMDco) auf. Die PMDco ist ein Mid-Level-Ontologie, die im Rahmen des Projekts Platform MaterialDigital (PMD) entwickelt wurde und die auf der Basic Formal Ontology (BFO) basiert. Durch die Verwendung der BFO als grundlegende (top-level) Ontologie gewährleistet die WCSO die semantische Interoperabilität mit einer Vielzahl von BFO-konformen Ontologien und Wissensgraphen im Bereich der Materialwissenschaften und Werkstofftechnik., The Wet-Chemical Syntheses (WeChemSyn) Ontology (WCSO) provides a semantic framework for the structured representation of knowledge related to the wet-chemical syntheses of (nano) particles. Developed at the Bundesanstalt für Materialforschung und -prüfung (BAM) / Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing in Berlin, Germany, WCSO supports the formalization and integration of data related to wet-chemical synthesis across experimental workflows, processes, and material properties. It builds upon the PMD Core Ontology (PMDco), a mid-level ontology created within the Platform MaterialDigital (PMD) project which is grounded in the Basic Formal Ontology (BFO). By adhering to BFO as a foundational (top-level) ontology, WCSO ensures semantic interoperability with a wide range of BFO-aligned ontologies and knowledge graphs in the materials science and engineering domain.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://w3id.org/wcso/wcso-full.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Welding Capability and Specification Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1141","omv:numberOfProperties":"103","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WCSO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"39"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-20T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"5","dct:created":"2026-04-20T18:00:56.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=WCSO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WCSO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WCSO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"76","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/WCSO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=WCSO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"121","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WCSO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WCSO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/WCSO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"77"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/wcso/wcso-full.owl","dct:identifier":"https://w3id.org/wcso/"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/wcso/wcso-full.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WCSO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"10"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Markus Schilling\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/247ef750-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/247ef750-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Bernd Bayerlein\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/24911340-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/24911340-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0009-0002-7960-3666\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/48f8ffc0-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/48f8ffc0-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3383-9999\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/49162370-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/49162370-edae-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WCSO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2026-04-20"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":249.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6682},"MPAP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":""},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":""},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":12.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"","foaf:homepage":"","void:uriRegexPattern":"","omv:acronym":"","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"","dct:subject":"","dct:coverage":"","dct:audience":"","foaf:page":"","doap:bugDatabase":"","skos:hiddenLabel":"","idot:exampleIdentifier":"","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"","vann:example":"","dct:alternative":"","doap:mailing-list":"","dct:description":"","omv:resourceLocator":"","omv:keywords":"","dct:title":"","dct:publisher":"","doap:repository":""},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"","mod:metrics":"{}","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"","omv:isOfType":"","omv:keyClasses":"","dct:dateSubmitted":"","dct:abstract":"","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"","dct:bibliographicCitation":"","pav:curatedOn":"","foaf:depiction":"","void:openSearchDescription":"","schema:comment":"","void:propertyPartition":"{}","dct:valid":"","void:classPartition":"{}","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"","void:dataDump":"","foaf:logo":"","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"","door:hasDisparateModelling":"","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"","schema:workTranslation":"","voaf:usedBy":"","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"{}","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"{}","mod:browsingUI":"{}","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"","schema:award":"","voaf:toDoList":"","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":""},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":""},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"","omv:status":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":16.0,"normalizedScore":80,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":88.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":""},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":""},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":""},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":""},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"","dct:isFormatOf":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"","voaf:generalizes":"","voaf:specializes":"","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":""},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"","mod:synonymProperty":"","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"","dct:isPartOf":"","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"","mod:prefLabelProperty":"","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"{}","voaf:specializes":"","schema:translationOfWork":"","voaf:generalizes":"","door:hasDisparateModelling":"","mod:hierarchyProperty":"","owl:priorVersion":"","dct:subject":"","dct:isFormatOf":"","schema:workTranslation":"","voaf:usedBy":"","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"","dct:license":"","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"","mod:definitionProperty":"","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"","dct:hasFormat":"","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"","mod:prefLabelProperty":"","mod:authorProperty":"","mod:obsoleteProperty":"","mod:synonymProperty":""},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"","mod:hierarchyProperty":"","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":""},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"","cc:morePermissions":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"","dct:rightsHolder":"[]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"","dct:creator":"","dct:contributor":"","pav:curatedBy":""},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"","dct:source":""},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"","dct:accrualMethod":"","dct:accrualPeriodicity":""},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"{}","owl:priorVersion":"","owl:versionInfo":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":""},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"","mod:competencyQuestion":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":""},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"property not found"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":""},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":1,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":131.0,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1125},"CCO-EVENT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/EventOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/2026-04-04/EventOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CCO-EVENT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Event Ontology module of the Common Core Ontologies designed to represent occurrences and processes.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/master/src/cco-modules/EventOntology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Common Core Event Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"529","omv:numberOfProperties":"158","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-EVENT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"81"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T18:12:09.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-EVENT&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology is designed to represent processes, especially those performed by agents, that occur within multiple domains.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-EVENT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-EVENT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"57","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-EVENT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-EVENT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-EVENT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-EVENT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CCO-EVENT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"22"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/EventOntology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/EventOntology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/InformationEntityOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/InformationEntityOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-EVENT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Alexandru Todor"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-EVENT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"Version 2.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4084},"CCO-AGENT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/AgentOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/2026-04-04/AgentOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CCO-AGENT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Agent Ontology module of the Common Core Ontologies designed to represent agents, organizations, and roles.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/master/src/cco-modules/AgentOntology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Common Core Agent Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"631","omv:numberOfProperties":"190","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-AGENT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"81"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T18:12:09.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-AGENT&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology is designed to represent agents, especially persons and organizations, and their roles.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-AGENT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-AGENT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"66","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-AGENT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-AGENT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-AGENT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-AGENT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CCO-AGENT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"22"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/AgentOntology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/AgentOntology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/EventOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/InformationEntityOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/EventOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/InformationEntityOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-AGENT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Alexandru Todor"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-AGENT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"Version 2.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4063},"CCO-ARTIFACT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ArtifactOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/2026-04-04/ArtifactOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CCO-ARTIFACT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Artifact Ontology module of the Common Core Ontologies designed to represent manufactured object types.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/master/src/cco-modules/ArtifactOntology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Common Core Artifact Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"774","omv:numberOfProperties":"158","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-ARTIFACT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"81"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T18:12:08.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-ARTIFACT&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology is designed to represent artifacts that are common to multiple domains along with their models, specifications, and functions.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-ARTIFACT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-ARTIFACT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"70","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-ARTIFACT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-ARTIFACT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"22","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-ARTIFACT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-ARTIFACT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CCO-ARTIFACT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"57"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ArtifactOntology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ArtifactOntology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/InformationEntityOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/InformationEntityOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-ARTIFACT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"11"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Alexandru Todor"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-ARTIFACT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"Version 2.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3748},"CCO-RELATION":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/2026-04-04/ExtendedRelationOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CCO-RELATION","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Extended Relation Ontology module of the Common Core Ontologies designed to represent relations between entities.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/master/src/cco-modules/ExtendedRelationOntology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Common Core Extended Relation Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"36","omv:numberOfProperties":"73","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-RELATION/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T18:12:10.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-RELATION&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology is designed to represent many of the relations (i.e. object properties) that hold between entities at the level of the mid-level Common Core Ontologies.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-RELATION/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-RELATION/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"6","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-RELATION/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-RELATION&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-RELATION/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-RELATION/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CCO-RELATION","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"4"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-RELATION/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"5"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Alexandru Todor"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-RELATION/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"Version 2.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3803},"CCO-FACILITY":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/FacilityOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/2026-04-04/FacilityOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CCO-FACILITY","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Facility Ontology module of the Common Core Ontologies designed to represent built structures and sites.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/master/src/cco-modules/FacilityOntology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Common Core Facility Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"859","omv:numberOfProperties":"158","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-FACILITY/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"81"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T18:12:10.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-FACILITY&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology is designed to represent buildings and campuses that  are designed to serve some specific purpose and which are common to multiple domains.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-FACILITY/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-FACILITY/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"87","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-FACILITY/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-FACILITY&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-FACILITY/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-FACILITY/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CCO-FACILITY","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"57"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/FacilityOntology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/FacilityOntology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/InformationEntityOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ArtifactOntology]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/InformationEntityOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ArtifactOntology]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-FACILITY/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"11"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Alexandru Todor"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-FACILITY/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"Version 2.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3751},"CCO-GEOSPATIAL":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/2026-04-04/GeospatialOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CCO-GEOSPATIAL","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Geospatial Ontology module of the Common Core Ontologies designed to represent regions of space and geographic features.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/master/src/cco-modules/GeospatialOntology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Common Core Geospatial Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"87","omv:numberOfProperties":"95","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-GEOSPATIAL/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T18:12:10.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-GEOSPATIAL&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology is designed to represent sites, spatial regions, and other entities, especially those that are located near the surface of Earth, as well as the relations that hold between them.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-GEOSPATIAL/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-GEOSPATIAL/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"11","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-GEOSPATIAL/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-GEOSPATIAL&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-GEOSPATIAL/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-GEOSPATIAL/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CCO-GEOSPATIAL","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"10"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-GEOSPATIAL/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Alexandru Todor"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-GEOSPATIAL/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"Version 2.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3719},"CCO-INFO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/InformationEntityOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/2026-04-04/InformationEntityOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CCO-INFO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Information Entity Ontology module of the Common Core Ontologies designed to represent information content and formats.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/master/src/cco-modules/InformationEntityOntology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Common Core Information Entity Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"230","omv:numberOfProperties":"158","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-INFO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"81"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T18:12:10.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-INFO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology is designed to represent generic types of information as well as the relationships between information and other entities.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-INFO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-INFO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"28","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-INFO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-INFO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-INFO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-INFO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CCO-INFO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"13"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/InformationEntityOntology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/InformationEntityOntology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-INFO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Alexandru Todor"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-INFO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"Version 2.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3770},"CCO-TIME":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/2026-04-04/TimeOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CCO-TIME","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Time Ontology module of the Common Core Ontologies designed to represent temporal entities and relations.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/master/src/cco-modules/TimeOntology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Common Core Time Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"69","omv:numberOfProperties":"100","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-TIME/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T18:12:12.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-TIME&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology is designed to represent temporal regions and the relations that hold between them.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-TIME/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-TIME/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"9","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-TIME/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-TIME&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-TIME/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-TIME/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CCO-TIME","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"13"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-TIME/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"7"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Alexandru Todor"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-TIME/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"Version 2.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3695},"CCO-UNITS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/UnitsOfMeasureOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/2026-04-04/UnitsOfMeasureOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CCO-UNITS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Units of Measure Ontology module of the Common Core Ontologies designed to represent standard measurement scales and units.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/master/src/cco-modules/UnitsOfMeasureOntology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Common Core Units of Measure Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"233","omv:numberOfProperties":"158","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-UNITS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"222"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T18:12:12.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-UNITS&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology is designed to represent standard measurement units that are used when measuring various attributes of entities.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-UNITS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-UNITS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"24","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-UNITS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-UNITS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-UNITS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-UNITS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CCO-UNITS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"26"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/UnitsOfMeasureOntology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/UnitsOfMeasureOntology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/InformationEntityOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/InformationEntityOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-UNITS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Alexandru Todor"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-UNITS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"Version 2.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3862},"SAREF4SYST":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4syst/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4syst/v1.1.2/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4syst/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SAREF4SYST","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4syst/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://www.etsi.org/deliver/etsi_ts/103500_103599/103548/01.01.02_60/ts_103548v010102p.pdf","doap:bugDatabase":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4syst/","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"SAREF4SYST is an extension of SAREF to represent generic connections between systems and sub-systems., The present document is the technical specification of SAREF4SYST, a generic extension of [ETSI TS 103 264 SAREF](https://www.etsi.org/deliver/etsi_ts/103200_103299/103264/02.01.01_60/ts_103264v020101p.pdf) that defines an ontology pattern which can be instantiated for different domains. SAREF4SYST defines Systems, Connections between systems, and Connection Points at which systems may be connected. These core concepts can be used generically to define the topology of features of interest, and can be specialized for multiple domains. The topology of features of interest is highly important in many use cases. If a room holds a lighting device, and if it is adjacent with an open window to a room whose luminosity is low, then by turning on the lighting device in the former room one may expect that the luminosity in the latter room will rise.\n\nThe SAREF4SYST ontology pattern can be instantiated for different domains. For example to describe zones inside a building (systems), that share a frontier (connections). Properties of systems are typically state variables (e.g. agent population, temperature), whereas properties of connections are typically flows (e.g. heat flow).\n\nSAREF4SYST has two main aims: on the one hand, to extend SAREF with the capability or representing general topology of systems and how they are connected or interact and, on the other hand, to exemplify how ontology patterns may help to ensure an homogeneous structure of the overall SAREF ontology and speed up the development of extensions.\n\nSAREF4SYST consists both of a core ontology, and guidelines to create ontologies following the SAREF4SYST ontology pattern. The core ontology is a lightweight OWL-DL ontology that defines 3 classes and 9 object properties.\n\nUse cases for ontology patterns are described extensively in  [ETSI TR 103 549 Clauses 4.2 and 4.3](https://www.etsi.org/deliver/etsi_tr/103500_103599/103549/01.01.01_60/tr_103549v010101p.pdf).\n\nFor the Smart Energy domain:\n\n- Electric power systems can exchange electricity with other electric power systems. The electric energy can flow both ways in some cases (from the Public Grid to a Prosumer), or in only one way (from the Public Grid to a Load). Electric power systems can be made up of different sub-systems. Generic sub-types of electric power systems include producers, consumers, storage systems, transmission systems. \n- Electric power systems may be connected one to another through electrical connection points. An Electric power system may have multiple connection points (Multiple Winding Transformer generally have one single primary winding with two or more secondary windings). Generic sub-types of electrical connection points include plugs, sockets, direct-current, single-phase, three-phase, connection points. \n- An Electrical connection may exist between two Electric power systems at two of their respective connection points. Generic sub-types of electrical connections include Single-phase Buses, Three-phase Buses. A single-phase electric power system can be connected using different configurations at a three-phase bus (RN, SN, TN types).\n\nFor the Smart Building domain:\n\n- Buildings, Storeys, Spaces, are different sub-types of Zones. Zones can contain sub-zones. Zones can be adjacent or intersect with other zones. \n- Two zones may share one or more connections. For example some fresh air may be created inside a storey if it has two controllable openings to the exterior at different cardinal points. \n\nA graphical overview of the SAREF4SYST ontology is provided in Figure 1. In such figure:\n\n- Rectangles are used to denote Classes. The label of the rectangle is the identifier of the Class.\n- Plain arrows are used to represent Object Properties between Classes. The label of the arrow is the identifier of the Object Property. The origin of the arrow is the domain Class of the property, and the target of the arrow is the range Class of the property.\n- Dashed arrows with identifiers between stereotype signs (i.e. \"`<< >>`\") refer to OWL axioms that are applied to some property. Four pairs of properties are inverse one of the other; the property `s4syst:connectedTo` is symmetric, and properties `s4syst:hasSubSystem` and `s4syst:hasSubSystem` are transitive.\n- A symbol =1 near the target of an arrow denotes that the associated property is functional. A symbol ? denotes a local existential restriction.\n\n\n![SAREF4SYST overview](diagrams/overview.png)\n","omv:resourceLocator":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4syst/v1.1.2/saref4syst.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"SAREF Extension for Systems","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.etsi.org/\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9e083b00-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9e083b00-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"4","omv:numberOfProperties":"9","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"s4syst","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4SYST/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T18:12:12.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"The present document specifies a new reference ontology pattern for the [SAREF semantic model](https://saref.etsi.org/), which leverages the experience of the [EUREKA ITEA 12004 SEAS (Smart Energy Aware Systems) project](http://w3id.org/seas/), and the development of the [OGC&W3C SSN (Semantic Sensor Network) ontology](https://www.w3.org/TR/vocab-ssn/). It also defines how this pattern may be instantiated for the verticals, and point to examples for the Smart Energy and the Smart Building domains. The present document is based on the requirements and guidelines defined in the associated [ETSI TS 103 549 document](https://www.etsi.org/deliver/etsi_tr/103500_103599/103549/01.01.01_60/tr_103549v010101p.pdf).","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2019-06-06T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4syst/\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SAREF4SYST&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4SYST/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4SYST/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"2020-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4SYST/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SAREF4SYST&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4SYST/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4SYST/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SAREF4SYST","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"3"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":78.0,"normalizedScore":69,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4syst/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4syst/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4SYST/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://forge.etsi.org/etsi-software-license","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://forge.etsi.org/etsi-software-license"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ETSI SmartM"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://maxime-lefrancois.info/me#\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/64e2a260-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/64e2a260-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"https://saref.etsi.org/sources/saref4syst/\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4SYST/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.1.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":268.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6208},"BIPM-SI-PREFIXES":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://si-digital-framework.org/SI/prefixes/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://si-digital-framework.org/1.0.0/prefixes/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/TheBIPM/SI_Digital_Framework","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BIPM-SI-PREFIXES","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology representing SI Prefixes, multipliers, and names.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/TheBIPM/SI_Digital_Framework/main/knowledge_graphs/SI_Reference_Point/prefixes.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"BIPM SI Reference Point Prefixes Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"4","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-PREFIXES/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"30"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:10:41.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIPM-SI-PREFIXES&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The SI Reference Point Ontology developed by the BIPM is\\nlicensed under CC-BY-3.0-IGO. You are free to share (copy and redistribute\\nthe material in any medium or format) and adapt (remix, transform, and\\nbuild upon the material) for any purpose, even commercially, for any\\npurpose, even commercially. The licensor cannot revoke these freedoms as\\nlong as you follow the license terms. You must give appropriate credit\\n(by using the original ontology IRI for the whole ontology and original\\nterm IRIs for individual terms), provide a link to the license, and\\nindicate if any changes were made. You may do so in any reasonable\\nmanner, but not in any way that suggests the licensor endorses you or\\nyour use.\",\"Ontology, part of the SI Reference Point, covering prefixes for the SI measurement units.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-PREFIXES/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-PREFIXES/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-PREFIXES/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIPM-SI-PREFIXES&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"4","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-PREFIXES/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-PREFIXES/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-PREFIXES","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"4"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://si-digital-framework.org/SI/prefixes/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://si-digital-framework.org/SI/prefixes/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-PREFIXES/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"BIPM SI Digital Framework team"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-PREFIXES/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4847},"DPP-CIRC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/monirehpourjafarian/ontologies/2024/7/untitled-ontology-121"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/CircThreadH2020/Ontology-design-Pattern-for-Digital-Product-Passport","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DPP-CIRC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern for Digital Product Passports focusing on circular economy, recycling, and materials recovery (CircThread H2020).","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/CircThreadH2020/Ontology-design-Pattern-for-Digital-Product-Passport/main/DPP_ODPS/DigitalProductPassport/DPP","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"DPP Circular Economy Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"19","omv:numberOfProperties":"16","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-CIRC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:10:45.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DPP-CIRC&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-CIRC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-CIRC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-CIRC/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DPP-CIRC&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"16","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-CIRC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-CIRC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DPP-CIRC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"11"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/monirehpourjafarian/ontologies/2024/7/untitled-ontology-121","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/monirehpourjafarian/ontologies/2024/7/untitled-ontology-121"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-CIRC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"CircThread consortium"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-CIRC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":221.0,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3511},"ENMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/enanomapper/ontologies/refs/heads/master/enanomapper.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://www.enanomapper.net/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ENMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology for nanomaterials safety, characterization, exposures, and toxicological studies.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/enanomapper/ontologies/refs/heads/master/enanomapper.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"eNanoMapper Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ENMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:36:15.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ENMO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ENMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ENMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ENMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ENMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ENMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ENMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/ENMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/enanomapper/ontologies/refs/heads/master/enanomapper.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/enanomapper/ontologies/refs/heads/master/enanomapper.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ENMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"eNanoMapper Maintainers"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ENMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"master"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2987},"OSMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.molmod.info/semantics/osmo.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://www.vimmp.eu/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"OSMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"VIMMP ontology representing simulation workflows, solvers, variables, models, and optimization processes in materials science.","omv:resourceLocator":"http://www.molmod.info/semantics/osmo.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Ontology for Simulation, Modelling, and Optimization","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OSMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:36:18.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OSMO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OSMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OSMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OSMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OSMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OSMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OSMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/OSMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.molmod.info/semantics/osmo.ttl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.molmod.info/semantics/osmo.ttl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OSMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"VIMMP Ontology Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OSMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2877},"AUTOMATIONML":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-AutomationML/master/AutomationML.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/hsu-aut/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"AUTOMATIONML","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern mapping AutomationML structure to semantic web standards.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-AutomationML/master/AutomationML.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"AutomationML ODP","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATIONML/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:44:34.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=AUTOMATIONML&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATIONML/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATIONML/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATIONML/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=AUTOMATIONML&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATIONML/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATIONML/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/AUTOMATIONML","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-AutomationML/master/AutomationML.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-AutomationML/master/AutomationML.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATIONML/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Automatik / Standards Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATIONML/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2912},"IEC62443":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-IEC62443/main/iec62443.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/hsu-aut/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IEC62443","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern for industrial automation security risk assessment based on IEC 62443.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-IEC62443/main/iec62443.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"IEC 62443 Industrial Cybersecurity ODP","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IEC62443/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:44:37.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IEC62443&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IEC62443/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IEC62443/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IEC62443/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IEC62443&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IEC62443/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IEC62443/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IEC62443","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-IEC62443/main/iec62443.ttl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-IEC62443/main/iec62443.ttl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IEC62443/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Automatik / Standards Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IEC62443/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2878},"IEEE1872":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-IEEE1872-2/main/AuR_IEEE1872-2.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/hsu-aut/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IEEE1872","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern representing autonomous robotics domain ontology based on IEEE 1872.2.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-IEEE1872-2/main/AuR_IEEE1872-2.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"IEEE 1872 Autonomous Robotics ODP","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IEEE1872/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:44:40.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IEEE1872&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IEEE1872/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IEEE1872/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IEEE1872/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IEEE1872&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IEEE1872/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IEEE1872/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IEEE1872","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-IEEE1872-2/main/AuR_IEEE1872-2.ttl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-IEEE1872-2/main/AuR_IEEE1872-2.ttl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IEEE1872/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Automatik / Standards Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IEEE1872/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2933},"NAMUR2658":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDIVDENAMUR2658/main/VDIVDENAMUR2658.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/hsu-aut/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NAMUR2658","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern for NAMUR 2658 Module Type Package (MTP) modeling modular plants.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDIVDENAMUR2658/main/VDIVDENAMUR2658.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"VDI VDE NAMUR 2658 MTP ODP","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NAMUR2658/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:44:42.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NAMUR2658&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NAMUR2658/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NAMUR2658/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NAMUR2658/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NAMUR2658&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NAMUR2658/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NAMUR2658/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/NAMUR2658","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDIVDENAMUR2658/main/VDIVDENAMUR2658.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDIVDENAMUR2658/main/VDIVDENAMUR2658.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NAMUR2658/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Automatik / Standards Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NAMUR2658/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2888},"VDI5100":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDI5100/main/VDI5100.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/hsu-aut/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"VDI5100","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern based on VDI 5100 standard SAIL (System Architecture for Intralogistics).","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDI5100/main/VDI5100.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"VDI 5100 Intralogistics SAIL ODP","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI5100/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:44:45.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=VDI5100&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI5100/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI5100/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI5100/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=VDI5100&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI5100/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI5100/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/VDI5100","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDI5100/main/VDI5100.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDI5100/main/VDI5100.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI5100/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Automatik / Standards Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI5100/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2899},"ISO7498":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-ISO7498-1/main/ISO7498.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/hsu-aut/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ISO7498","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern representing OSI network layers based on ISO 7498-1 standard.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-ISO7498-1/main/ISO7498.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"ISO 7498 OSI Communications ODP","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISO7498/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:44:48.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ISO7498&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISO7498/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISO7498/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISO7498/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ISO7498&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISO7498/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISO7498/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/ISO7498","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-ISO7498-1/main/ISO7498.ttl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-ISO7498-1/main/ISO7498.ttl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISO7498/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Automatik / Standards Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISO7498/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2875},"UNECE-UOM":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-UNECE-UoM/main/UNECE_UoM.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/hsu-aut/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"UNECE-UOM","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern representing units of measure based on the UNECE Rec 20 standard.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-UNECE-UoM/main/UNECE_UoM.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"UNECE Units of Measure ODP","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/UNECE-UOM/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:44:52.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=UNECE-UOM&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/UNECE-UOM/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/UNECE-UOM/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/UNECE-UOM/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=UNECE-UOM&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/UNECE-UOM/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/UNECE-UOM/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/UNECE-UOM","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-UNECE-UoM/main/UNECE_UoM.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-UNECE-UoM/main/UNECE_UoM.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/UNECE-UOM/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Automatik / Standards Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/UNECE-UOM/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2918},"HTO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/hto.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"HTO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/HEATTREATMENTONTOLOG\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"HTO is the PMD application ontology for heat-treatment workflows. It extends PMDco to describe thermal-processing plans, treatment steps, relevant equipment and parameters, and resulting material-state and property information so that heat-treatment data can be represented in a consistent, queryable way across projects.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/materialdigital/application-ontologies/main/heat_treatment_ontology_HTO/pmdao_HTO.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Platform Material Digital Application Ontology (PMDao) - Heat Treatment Module","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/materialdigital/heat-treatment-application-ontology"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-04-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-04-16T18:02:04.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=HTO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=HTO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/HTO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/hto.ttl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/hto.ttl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMD\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/PMDAO\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/MATERIALDIGITAL\",\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/categories/HEATTREATMENTONTOLOG\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2025-11-25"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[{id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/APPLICATIONONTOL, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AUTOMATCE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CPTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIGITRUBBERFULLO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EPOXY_M_LY556_GF, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KNOWNOW, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/KUPDIGI, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MD012, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ODEAMROOT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOMAT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONT_PUB_TMPLT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDSENSO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PROCESSONTOLOGY, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SDOV, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SENSOTWIN, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMADIONT, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTE, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MATERIALDIGITAL, name=MaterialDigital, description=MaterialDigital umbrella project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MATERIALDIGITAL, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCO2, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PPO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:24.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMD, name=MaterialDigital / PMD, description=Platform MaterialDigital project, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMD, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}, {id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, homePage=https://www.materialdigital.de/projects/, institution=null, updated=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, ontologyUsed=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CEMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/LOG, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PBFAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PGO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDMO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSRTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VTO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WAAMAO, https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HTO], created=2026-02-16T21:34:25.000+00:00, creator=[https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin], acronym=MD_PMDAO, name=MaterialDigital / PMD Application Ontologies, description=PMD application ontologies, contacts=null, @id=https://data.dev.matportal.org/projects/MD_PMDAO, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":22,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":227.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3532},"MDS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://cwrusdle.bitbucket.io/PVCellOntology/Ontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MDS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://mds-onto.readthedocs.io","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Materials Data Science(MDS) is an ontology encompassing multiple domains relevant to materials science, chemical synthesis and characterizations, photovoltaics and geospatial datasets. The terms used for classes, subclasses and instances are mapped to PMDCo and BFO Ontologies.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Materials Data Science Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/sdle/MDS-Onto"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"14","omv:numberOfProperties":"5","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-02-16T21:35:57.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-10-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MDS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"4","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/ontologies/MDS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.stage.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MDS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"4","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MDS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"4"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://cwrusdle.bitbucket.io/PVCellOntology/Ontology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://cwrusdle.bitbucket.io/PVCellOntology/Ontology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"3"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"MatPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Arafath Nihar\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c591de0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c591de0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Benjamin Pierce\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c738d10-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c738d10-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Roger H. French\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c8a6f40-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c8a6f40-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Balashanmuga Priyan Rajamohan\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6ca32ad0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6ca32ad0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Hayden Caldwell\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6cbcd3a0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6cbcd3a0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jiana Kanbo\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6cde00d0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6cde00d0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Laura S. Bruckman\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6cf7dfb0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6cf7dfb0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Erika I. Barcelos\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d0e7d80-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d0e7d80-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Kris Davis\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d2c2cd0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d2c2cd0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yinghui Wu\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d416860-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d416860-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alexander C. Harding Bradley\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d5c23b0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d5c23b0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mengjie Li\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d70e5e0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d70e5e0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Kiefer Lin\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d877210-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d877210-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Raymond Wieser\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d9bf190-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d9bf190-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jarod Kaltenbaugh\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6db681a0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6db681a0-edaf-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MDS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":29.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":224.0,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":9701},"CCO-CURRENCY":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/CurrencyUnitOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/2026-04-04/CurrencyUnitOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CCO-CURRENCY","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Currency Unit Ontology module of the Common Core Ontologies designed to represent money and units of financial measurement.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/master/src/cco-modules/CurrencyUnitOntology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Common Core Currency Unit Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"207","omv:numberOfProperties":"158","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-CURRENCY/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"209"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T18:12:08.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-CURRENCY&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology is designed to represent currencies that are issued and used by countries.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-CURRENCY/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-CURRENCY/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"24","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-CURRENCY/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-CURRENCY&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-CURRENCY/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-CURRENCY/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CCO-CURRENCY","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"13"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/CurrencyUnitOntology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/CurrencyUnitOntology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/InformationEntityOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/InformationEntityOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-CURRENCY/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Alexandru Todor"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-CURRENCY/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"Version 2.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3810},"CCO-QUALITY":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/QualityOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/2026-04-04/QualityOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CCO-QUALITY","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Quality Ontology module of the Common Core Ontologies designed to represent attributes and properties.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/master/src/cco-modules/QualityOntology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Common Core Quality Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"316","omv:numberOfProperties":"158","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-QUALITY/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"81"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T18:12:10.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-QUALITY&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology is designed to represent a range of attributes of entities especially qualities, realizable entities, and process profiles.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-QUALITY/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-QUALITY/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"30","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-QUALITY/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CCO-QUALITY&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-QUALITY/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-QUALITY/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CCO-QUALITY","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"26"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/QualityOntology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/QualityOntology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/InformationEntityOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/ExtendedRelationOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/GeospatialOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/InformationEntityOntology, https://www.commoncoreontologies.org/TimeOntology]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-QUALITY/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/GPL-3.0-only.html"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Alexandru Todor"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CCO-QUALITY/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"Version 2.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3725},"SAREF":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/core/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/core/v4.1.1/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://saref.etsi.org/core/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SAREF","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://www.etsi.org/deliver/etsi_ts/103200_103299/103264/04.01.01_60/ts_103264v040101p.pdf","doap:bugDatabase":"https://saref.etsi.org/core/","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"SAREF is a reference ontology for smart applications, enabling interoperability between IoT devices, data, and services., The Smart Applications REFerence ontology (SAREF) is intended to enable interoperability between solutions from different providers and among various activity sectors in the Internet of Things (IoT), thus contributing to the development of the global digital market.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://saref.etsi.org/core/v4.1.1/saref.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Smart Applications REFerence Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.etsi.org/\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9e083b00-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9e083b00-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"33","omv:numberOfProperties":"72","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T18:12:12.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2024-10-31T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://saref.etsi.org/core/\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SAREF&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Information about changes to version 3.2.1:\\n\\nNOTE: Rationale and decisions for many of the changes in V3.2.1 are available in issues in project https://saref.etsi.org/sources/saref-core/issues.\\n\\n- Definition of saref:FeatureOfInterest is clarified, not only properties are measured, but properties and states can be observed and controlled.\\n- Definition of saref:FeatureOfInterest: Clarify it is a specific real world entity.\\n- Definition of saref:FeatureOfInterest: allValuesFrom axioms are unnecessary and have been deleted.\\n- Introduced class saref:FeatureKind\\n- Use SKOS to organize generic classes in taxonomies.\\n- Introduce hasClassKind for Class is Feature, Device, Property, State, Function, Command.\\n- Add local restrictions on consistsOf on feature of interest\\n- Defined domain of saref:hasManufacturer to union of feature kind and feature of interest.\\n- Defined domain of saref:hasModel to union of feature kind and feature of interest.\\n- Most axioms on saref:Device were useless and have been deleted.\\n- definition of saref:Device clarifies it is a real world entity.\\n- saref:Device is explicitly a subclass of saref:FeatureOfInterest and s4syst:System.\\n- saref:actsUpon now holds not only between a command and a state. It generalizes actsUpon, observes, controls. Domain and range are unions of several classes.\\n- Introduced property saref:isActedUponBy.\\n- Introduced property saref:observes, as sub-property of saref:actsUpon. and generalization of measures.\\n- Introduced property saref:controls, as sub-property of saref:actsUpon. and generalization of saref:controlsProperty.\\n- Introduced property saref:isControlledBy.\\n- saref:measuresProperty is deprecated: will be deleted in the next release of SAREF\\n- saref:isMeasuredByDevice is deprecated: will be deleted in the next release of SAREF\\n- saref:isControlledByDevice is deprecated: will be deleted in the next release of SAREF\\n- saref:controlsProperty is deprecated: will be deleted in the next release of SAREF\\n- Definition of saref:Appliance is grounded on tasks and commodities.\\n- Definition of Sensor is simplified and grounded on saref:observes. Local restriction on saref:hasFunction is deleted.\\n- Definition of Actuator is simplified and grounded on saref:controls. Local restriction on saref:hasFunction is deleted.\\n- Definition of Meter is simplified and grounded on saref:observes. Local restriction on saref:hasFunction is deleted.\\n- Deprecated saref:HVAC for it is only an example.\\n- Deprecated saref:Switch for it is only an example.\\n- Deprecated saref:DoorSwitch for it is only an example.\\n- Deprecated saref:LightSwitch for it is only an example.\\n- Deprecated saref:SmokeSensor for it is only an example.\\n- Deprecated saref:TemperatureSensor for it is only an example.\\n- The following tasks are deprecated, and may be deleted in the next release of SAREF: saref:Cleaning, saref:Comfort, saref:Drying, saref:EnergyEfficiency, saref:Entertainment, saref:Lighting, saref:MeterReading, saref:Safety, saref:Washing, saref:WellBeing.\\n- Definition of saref:Commodity is simplified.\\n- saref:Electricity is deprecated: will be defined as an instance of saref:Commodity in the next release of SAREF\\n- saref:Gas is deprecated: will be defined as an instance of saref:Commodity in the next release of SAREF\\n- saref:Coal is deprecated: will be defined as an instance of saref:Commodity in the next release of SAREF\\n- saref:Water is deprecated: will be defined as an instance of saref:Commodity in the next release of SAREF\\n- New category of commodities saref:EnergyCommodity\\n- New category of commodities saref:NaturalResourceCommodity\\n- Introduced saref:consumes, saref:isConsumedBy, saref:produces, saref:isProducedBy, saref:stores, saref:isStoredBy.\\n- The definition and scope of usage for saref:Property is clarified. Axiomatization is simplified.\\n- applicability of saref:hasProperty is relaxed to also saref:FeatureKind\\n- Introduced saref:PropertyOfInterest to solved the ambiguity between generic vs specific properties.\\n- Introduced saref:hasPropertyOfInterest and saref:isPropertyOfInterestOf. Cannot use saref:hasProperty due to the combination of cardinality restrictions and sub-property chain axioms makes the ontology exist the OWL 2 DL prodile.\\n- Introduced saref:PropertyValue to simplify the association of a measure to a property, without always needing it to be a measurement made by a device.\\n- Clarified definition of saref:hasValue.\\n- Relaxed domain of saref:isMeasuredIn so it can apply to saref:PropertyValue as well as saref:Measurement. The new range will be enforced in the next release of SAREF.\\n- Introduced saref:hasPropertyValue.\\n- Introduced saref:isValueOfProperty.\\n- The following classes are deprecated and may be defined as instances of saref:Property in the next release of SAREF: saref:Energy, saref:Humidity, saref:Light, saref:Motion, saref:Occupancy, saref:Power, saref:Pressure, saref:Price, saref:Smoke, saref:Temperature\\n- saref:EnergyUnit is deprecated. Will be deleted in the next release of SAREF\\n- saref:IlluminanceUnit is deprecated. Will be deleted in the next release of SAREF\\n- saref:PowerUnit is deprecated. Will be deleted in the next release of SAREF\\n- saref:PressureUnit is deprecated. Will be deleted in the next release of SAREF\\n- saref:TemperatureUnit is deprecated. Will be deleted in the next release of SAREF\\n- Clarified and generalized definition of saref:State. Can now apply to all features of interest, not just devices.\\n- Relaxed domain of saref:hasState.\\n- Introduced saref:isStateOf.\\n- Introduced saref:StateOfInterest, parallel to saref:PropertyOfInterest.\\n- Introduced saref:hasStateOfInterest and saref:isStateOfInterestOf, parallel to saref:hasPropertyOfInterest and saref:isPropertyOfInterestOf.\\n- The following classes are deprecated and may be defined as instances of saref:State in the next release of SAREF: saref:CloseState, saref:MultiLevelState, saref:OffState, saref:OnOffState, saref:OnState, saref:OpenCloseState, saref:OpenState, saref:StartState, saref:StartStopState, saref:StopState.\\n- Simplified definition and axiomatization of saref:Function. Added examples.\\n- saref:SensingFunction is deprecated: may be defined as an instance of saref:Function in the next release of SAREF\\n- saref:hasSensingRange is deprecated together with saref:SensingFunction. And may be defined as an instance of saref:Property in the next release of SAREF\\n- saref:hasSensorType is deprecated together with saref:SensingFunction. Use saref:hasDeviceKind instead.\\n- saref:EventFunction is deprecated: may be defined as an instance of saref:Function in the next release of SAREF\\n- saref:hasThresholdMeasurement is deprecated together with saref:EventFunction. And may be defined as an instance of saref:Property in the next release of SAREF\\n- saref:MeteringFunction is deprecated: may be defined as an instance of saref:Function in the next release of SAREF\\n- deprecated saref:hasMeterReading together with saref:Measurement and saref:MeteringFunction\\n- deprecated saref:hasMeterReadingType together with saref:MeteringFunction\\n- saref:LevelControlFunction, saref:StartStopFunction, saref:OpenCloseFunction, saref:OnOffFunction,  \\n- saref:ActuatingFunction are deprecated: may be defined as an instance of saref:Function in the next release of SAREF.\\n- Domain of saref:hasFunction is relaxed.\\n- Introduced saref:isFunctionOf.\\n- Introduced saref:FunctionOfInterest, parallel to saref:PropertyOfInterest.\\n- Simplified definition and axiomatization of saref:Command. Added examples.\\n- Domain of saref:hasCommand is relaxed to saref:Function or saref:FunctionOfInterest.\\n- Introduced mandatory and optional commands.\\n- Introduced saref:hasInput and saref:hasOutput.\\n- Introduced saref:CommandOfInterest, parallel to saref:PropertyOfInterest.\\n- The following classes are deprecated and may be defined as instances of saref:Command in the next release of SAREF: saref:ToggleCommand, saref:GetCommand, saref:NotifyCommand, saref:GetSensingDataCommand, saref:GetCurrentMeterValueCommand, saref:GetMeterDataCommand, saref:GetMeterHistoryCommand, saref:SetAbsoluteLevelCommand, saref:SetRelativeLevelCommand, saref:SetLevelCommand, saref:StepDownCommand, saref:StepUpCommand, saref:PauseCommand, saref:StartCommand, saref:StopCommand, saref:CloseCommand, saref:OpenCommand, saref:OnCommand, saref:OffCommand.\\n- Simplified definition of saref:Service. Added examples.\\n- Relaxed domain and range of saref:represents.\\n- Clarified definition of saref:offers.\\n- Clarified definition of saref:isOfferedBy.\\n- saref:SwitchOnService is deprecated for it is just an example. It may be deleted in the next release of SAREF\\n- Introduced saref:Operation and associated properties from oneM2M base ontology.\\n- Introduced saref:ProcedureExecution.\\n- Introduce saref:madeBy (resp. saref:madeExecution) as generalization of saref:measurementMadeBy (resp. saref:makesMeasurement).\\n- saref:makesMeasurement is deprecated as one of the properties related to saref:Measurement. It may be deleted in the next release of SAREF\\n- saref:makesMeasurement is deprecated as one of the properties related to saref:Measurement. It may be deleted in the next release of SAREF\\n- Introduced saref:hasResult as part of general will to make SAREF and SOSA/SSN converge.\\n- Introduced saref:hasResultTime as part of general will to make SAREF and SOSA/SSN converge.\\n- Introduced saref:hasPhenomenonTime as part of general will to make SAREF and SOSA/SSN converge.\\n- Tried to clarify definition of saref:hasTimestamp. Still unclear.\\n- Deprecated saref:Measurement in favour of saref:Observation, to generalize to observation of states and convergence with SOSA/SSN.\\n- Deprecated saref:isMeasurementOf together with saref:Measurement.\\n- Deprecated saref:isMeasurementOf together with saref:Measurement.\\n- Deprecated saref:isMeasurementOf together with saref:Measurement.\\n- Deprecated saref:isMeasurementOf together with saref:Measurement.\\n- Class saref:Profile has been re-specified, to take into account findings from SAREF4ENER V1.2.1.\\n- Relaxed domain of saref:hasProfile to saref:FeatureKind or saref:Device\\n- Deprecated saref:hasTime and use OWL Time instead whenever possible.\\n- Deprecated saref:Time and use OWL Time instead whenever possible.\\n- Deprecated saref:hasTypicalConsumption. May be defined as an instance of saref:Property in the next release of SAREF.\\n\",\"Information about changes to version 2.1.1:\\n\\n- The classes and properties related to how to represent devices in building spaces (such as the saref:BuildingSpace class,  saref:BuildingObject class and saref:isLocatedIn property) have been removed from SAREF and incorporated  into the SAREF4BLDG extension related to buildings, including the reuse of the W3C? WGS84 geo positioning vocabulary.\\n- The saref:DeviceCategory and saref:FunctionCategory classes have been removed. Instead, the hierarchy of device categories has been implemented directly as subclasses of the saref:Device class.\\n- The information specific for energy efficiency has been moved to the SAREF4ENER extension. For example, the saref:Profile class has been redefined to accommodate only the properties that are general enough for any type of profile, not only for energy and power. Details on how to specifically model a power profile can be found in the SAREF4ENER extension. \\n- The subclasses of the saref:Energy class  have been removed (i.e., Average Energy, Maximum Energy, Minimum Energy, Total Energy, HVAC Energy, Hot Water Energy and Lighting Energy).\\n- The saref:Property class has been split into two classes (saref:Property and saref:Measurement), as it is done in the SAREF4ENVI extension, in order to properly accommodate the distinction between the concept of property (an observable quality of something) and the concept of measurement (a concrete value observed for a property).\\n- Too restrictive cardinality restrictions have been revised, sometimes making them optional rather than mandatory (better to make properties mandatory in the extensions that specialize SAREF for a specific purpose, rather than restricting SAREF, whose purpose is more general). For example, definitions of units of measurement using an enumeration (owl:oneOf) were too restrictive because they did not allow using other units than those enumerated. Therefore, the individuals of each class are still there, but the owl:oneOf enumeration has been removed.\\n- The saref:UnitOfMeasure subclasses use individuals from the OM ontology for unit of measures, but this is not the only solution. It has been clarified in the comments that the OM ontology is an example, but other ontologies can be used.\\n- The global restrictions (rdfs:domain and rdfs:range) in object properties have been completely removed not to hinder interoperability. Object properties are now only restricted locally in the classes. \\n- The subclasses of saref:Task have been transormed in individuals.\\n- The saref:hasTask property has been removed from the saref:Profile class to resolve an ambiguity with the saref:Task class.\",\"Information about changes to version 4.1.1:\\n\\nNOTE: Rationale and decisions for many of the changes in V4.1.1 are available in issues in project https://labs.etsi.org/rep/saref/saref-core/-/milestones/3#tab-issues\\n\\n- Deprecated classes and properties have been deleted\\n- Reworded definition of saref:Sensor and saref:Meter\\n- saref:hasValue is now optional on saref:PropertyValue\\n- improved parallel between Property and State descriptions\\n- introduced saref:StateValue\\n- Removed examples of commodity categories\\n- Added notes and examples in multiple sections\\n- Added clause 5.14 about composite properties\\n- Reworked figures throughout the document\\n- Added migration guide from V3.1.1 to V4.1.1\\n- Updated the oneM2M base ontology to SAREF mapping\\n- Added principle on generic versus specific entities distinction\\n- Added references to EN 303 760\\n\",\"Information about changes to version 3.1.1:\\n\\nNOTE:\\tIn some cases, references have been added to indicate the issue in the ETSI Forge (https://saref.etsi.org/sources/saref-core/issues) where the change was discussed and implemented.\\n\\n- Added the saref:FeatureOfInterest class and the properties used to relate it to saref:Measurement (saref:hasMeasurement and saref:isMeasurementOf) and to saref:Property (saref:hasProperty and saref:isPropertyOf).\\n- Added the saref:measurementMadeBy property as inverse of saref:makesMeasurement.\\n- The saref:relatesToProperty and saref:relatesToMeasurement properties are now inverse of each other.\\n- The range of saref:hasValue, which was defined as xsd:float, has been removed to support other datatypes for measurements.\\n- The range of datatype properties, which was defined as xsd:string, has been removed in order to support strings with language tags (rdf:langString). This affects saref:hasDescription, saref:hasManufacturer, saref:hasModel and saref:hasName, which now have implicitly a range of rdfs:Literal.\\n- The saref:hasName property has been removed and the use of rdfs:label is recommended. \\n- The saref:hasDescription property has been deprecated and the use of rdfs:comment is recommended. \\n- Too restrictive restrictions have been removed and in some cases the ontology documentation has been updated to reflect this: a saref:Command having at most one saref:hasDescription; a saref:Task being accomplished by at least one saref:Device; a saref:Device having a typical consumption of only energy or power; a saref:Commodity being measured in units of measure; restrictions on the values of saref:accomplishes that only covered specific use cases; universal restrictions on the saref:actsUpon property have been changed to existential ones; restrictions on the commands that a saref:Function may have, since there could be others not included in the defined enumerations; restrictive documentation of saref:EventFunction and saref:SmokeSensor.\\n- Bugs have been fixed: some devices (saref:DoorSwitch, saref:EnergyMeter, saref:LigthSwitch, saref:SmokeSensor, and saref:TemperatureSensor) were defined as subclass of a device and at the same time as consisting of such device; a saref:LightSwitch controls light and does not measure light, since it is an actuator; incorrect documentation of saref:OnState and saref:OffState.\\n- The saref:BuildingRelated, saref:EnergyRelated and saref:FunctionRelated classes have been removed, since the different extensions already classify the device types.\\n- The instances of the subclasses of saref:Command have been removed, since they represent examples.\\n- The instances of saref:UnitOfMeasure have been moved to examples.\\n- The classes related to the SAREF4ENER extension have been removed: saref:Generator, saref:Storage, saref:Load and saref:EnergyMeter.\\n- Some instances of saref:Device have been moved to examples: saref:WashingMachine, saref:LightingDevice, saref:MicroRenewable, saref:Multimedia, and saref:Network.\\n- Added domain and range axioms wherever the definition of a property unambiguously identifies the domain or the range of the property.\\n- The OWL Time ontology is not imported anymore.\\n- The documentation of some ontology terms has been updated for clarification.\\n- Language tags have been added to all labels and comments.\\n\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"3","dct:modified":"2024-03-06T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SAREF&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"4","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SAREF","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"22"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":77.0,"normalizedScore":68,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/core/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/core/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://forge.etsi.org/etsi-software-license","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://forge.etsi.org/etsi-software-license"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ETSI SmartM"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://www.garcia-castro.com/foaf.rdf#me\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c892580-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c892580-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://maxime-lefrancois.info/me#\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/64e2a260-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/64e2a260-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://w3id.org/people/mpoveda/\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/650c50a0-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/650c50a0-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.linkedin.com/in/bouterca\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/65334b70-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/65334b70-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.linkedin.com/in/david-gnabasik-0056a0ba/\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/65580770-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/65580770-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.linkedin.com/in/giulia-biagioni\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/657e1100-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/657e1100-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.linkedin.com/in/lauradaniele\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e5e944d0-4984-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e5e944d0-4984-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v4.1.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":265.0,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6195},"SAREF4BLDG":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4bldg/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4bldg/v2.1.1/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4bldg/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SAREF4BLDG","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4bldg/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://www.etsi.org/deliver/etsi_ts/103400_103499/10341003/02.01.01_60/ts_10341003v020101p.pdf","doap:bugDatabase":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4bldg/","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"SAREF4BLDG is an extension of SAREF to represent buildings, building topologies, and spatial components (digital twins for physical infrastructure)., This ontology extends the SAREF ontology for the building domain by defining building devices and how they are located in a building. This extension is based on the ISO 16739:2013 Industry Foundation Classes (IFC) standard for data sharing in the construction and facility management industries. The descriptions of the classes and properties extracted from IFC have been taken from the IFC documentation.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4bldg/v2.1.1/saref4bldg.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"SAREF Extension for Buildings","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.etsi.org/\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9e083b00-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9e083b00-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"99","omv:numberOfProperties":"159","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"s4bldg","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4BLDG/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"170"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T18:12:12.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-04-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4bldg/\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SAREF4BLDG&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Information about changes compared to version 1.1.2: \\n - see https://labs.etsi.org/rep/saref/saref4bldg/-/milestones/1.\",\"Information about changes compared to version 1.1.1: \\n - Updated namespaces for compatibility with SAREF v3.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4BLDG/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4BLDG/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"7","dct:modified":"2025-04-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4BLDG/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SAREF4BLDG&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"5","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4BLDG/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4BLDG/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SAREF4BLDG","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"23"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":78.0,"normalizedScore":69,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4bldg/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4bldg/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"https://saref.etsi.org/core/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"https://saref.etsi.org/core/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4BLDG/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4bldg/v1.1.2/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://forge.etsi.org/etsi-software-license","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"7"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://forge.etsi.org/etsi-software-license"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ETSI SmartM"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://www.garcia-castro.com/foaf.rdf#me\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c892580-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c892580-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://purl.org/net/mpoveda\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9cb30050-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9cb30050-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://www.maxime-lefrancois.info/\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9d5a1fa0-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9d5a1fa0-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://pdi.fbk.eu/people/profile/dragoni\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9d840720-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9d840720-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"https://saref.etsi.org/sources/saref4bldg/\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4BLDG/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4bldg/v1.1.2/","owl:versionInfo":"v2.1.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":275.0,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6068},"SAREF4INMA":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4inma/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4inma/v1.1.2/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4inma/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SAREF4INMA","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4inma/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://www.etsi.org/deliver/etsi_ts/103400_103499/10341005/01.01.02_60/ts_10341005v010102p.pdf","doap:bugDatabase":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4inma/","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"SAREF4INMA is an extension of SAREF to represent production processes, machinery, items, and batches in industrial manufacturing digital twins., SAREF4INMA is an extension of SAREF for the industry and manufacturing domain. SAREF4INMA focuses on extending SAREF for the industry and manufacturing domain to solve the lack of interoperability between various types of production equipment that produce items in a factory and, once outside the factory, between different organizations in the value chain to uniquely track back the produced items to the corresponding production equipment, batches, material and precise time in which they were manufactured. SAREF4INMA is specified and published by ETSI in the TS 103 410-5 associated to this ontology file. SAREF4INMA was created to be aligned with related initiatives in the smart industry and manufacturing domain in terms of modelling and standardization, such as the Reference Architecture Model for Industry 4.0 (RAMI), which combines several standards used by the various national initiatives in Europe that support digitalization in manufacturing. The full list of use cases, standards and requirements that guided the creation of SAREF4INMA are described in the associated ETSI TR 103 507. ","omv:resourceLocator":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4inma/v1.1.2/saref4inma.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"SAREF Extension for Industry and Manufacturing","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.etsi.org/\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9e083b00-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9e083b00-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"35","omv:numberOfProperties":"35","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"s4inma","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4INMA/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T18:12:13.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2015-03-29T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4inma/\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SAREF4INMA&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4INMA/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4INMA/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"8","dct:modified":"2019-04-30T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4INMA/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SAREF4INMA&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4INMA/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4INMA/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SAREF4INMA","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"15"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":78.0,"normalizedScore":69,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4inma/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4inma/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4INMA/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://forge.etsi.org/etsi-software-license","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://forge.etsi.org/etsi-software-license"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ETSI SmartM"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://www.garcia-castro.com/foaf.rdf#me\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c892580-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c892580-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.linkedin.com/in/albafernandezizquierdo\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e5c1d390-4984-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e5c1d390-4984-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.linkedin.com/in/lauradaniele\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e5e944d0-4984-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e5e944d0-4984-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.linkedin.com/in/mderoode\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e6107c70-4984-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e6107c70-4984-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.linkedin.com/in/matthijs-punter-0799902\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e6b95d10-4984-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e6b95d10-4984-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://purl.org/net/mpoveda\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9cb30050-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9cb30050-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"https://saref.etsi.org/sources/saref4inma/\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4INMA/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.1.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":270.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6257},"MULLMA":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/multilayeredmaterial"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/multilayeredmaterial/1.0.0/multilayeredmaterial"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/emmo-repo/domain-multilayeredmaterial","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MULLMA","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/multilayeredmaterial/0.0.1/multilayeredmaterial","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/emmo-repo/domain-multilayeredmaterial","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/emmo-repo/domain-multilayeredmaterial/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"An EMMO-based domain ontology to model the structure, layering, composition, and properties of multi-layered materials.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/emmo-repo/domain-multilayeredmaterial/main/multilayeredmaterial.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Multi-layered Materials Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://emmc.eu\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6dc97df0-4990-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6dc97df0-4990-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"104","omv:numberOfProperties":"151","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"mullma","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MULLMA/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"14"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:20.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"Ontology to model multi-layered materials.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2025-03-07T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MULLMA&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Requires HermiT reasoner plugin in order to visualize all inferences and class hierarchy (ctrl+R hotkey in Protege).\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MULLMA/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MULLMA/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"8","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MULLMA/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MULLMA&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"102","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MULLMA/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MULLMA/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MULLMA","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"5"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":73.0,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/multilayeredmaterial","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/multilayeredmaterial"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/emmo/contributors, https://w3id.org/emmo/mereocausality, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/contrast, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/holistic, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/persistence, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/perspective, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/semiotics, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/structural, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/persholistic]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/emmo/contributors, https://w3id.org/emmo/mereocausality, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/contrast, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/holistic, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/persistence, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/perspective, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/semiotics, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/structural, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/persholistic]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MULLMA/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"11"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Gerhard Goldbeck"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5174-8508\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14295e00-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14295e00-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4181-2852\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/13fd2080-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/13fd2080-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5174-8508\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14295e00-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14295e00-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MULLMA/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.0.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":259.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6585},"IOF-AV":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202301/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IOF-AV","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IOF-AV","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IOF-AV","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IOF-AV","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. IOF Annotation Vocabulary.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IOF-AV/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"IOF Annotation Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2ccc3350-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2ccc3350-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-AV/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:22.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOF-AV&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-AV/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-AV/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-AV/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOF-AV&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-AV/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-AV/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IOF-AV","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"1"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":72.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-AV/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0dfcb470-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0dfcb470-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0e111f50-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0e111f50-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd5721b0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd5721b0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2b536a20-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2b536a20-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-AV/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":39.0,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":244.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6942},"BIMERRW":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/weather"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRW","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BIMERRW","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/weather","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRW","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRW","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. BIMERR Weather.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRW/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"BIMERR Weather","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://oeg.fi.upm.es/\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6ddf6c50-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6ddf6c50-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"31","omv:numberOfProperties":"27","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"weat","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRW/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"79"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:23.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"Ontology for weather phenomena and exterior conditions.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIMERRW&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRW/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRW/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"5","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRW/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIMERRW&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRW/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRW/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BIMERRW","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"9"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/weather","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/weather"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRW/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"4"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Salvador González-Gerpe https://www.linkedin.com/in/artificialintelligence-researcher-salvadorgonzalezgerpe\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c7c8100-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c7c8100-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Serge Chavez-Feria https://github.com/Serge3006\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d2c3e50-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d2c3e50-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"María Poveda-Villalón http://w3id.org/people/mpoveda\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d558f40-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6d558f40-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRW/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":248.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6357},"MEP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://pi.pauwel.be/voc/distributionelement"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/MEP","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MEP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://pi.pauwel.be/voc/distributionelement#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/MEP","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/MEP","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Distribution Element Ontology., The Distribution Element Ontology provides an ontology based on the IfcDistributionElement subtree in the IFC specification, containing a taxonomy of classes that allow to define common distribution elements (actuators, flowterminals, ...).","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/MEP/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Distribution Element Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"484","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"mep","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MEP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:25.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2018-12-27T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MEP&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MEP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MEP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"2020-07-29T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MEP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MEP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"199","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MEP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MEP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MEP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"23"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://pi.pauwel.be/voc/distributionelement","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://pi.pauwel.be/voc/distributionelement"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MEP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"4"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MEP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"December 24th 2020"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":245.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4348},"BIMERRIO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/information-objects#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRIO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BIMERRIO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRIO","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRIO","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. BIMERR Information Objects.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRIO/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"BIMERR Information Objects","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://www.oeg-upm.net/\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3055a710-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3055a710-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1","omv:numberOfProperties":"17","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRIO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:26.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIMERRIO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRIO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRIO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRIO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIMERRIO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRIO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRIO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BIMERRIO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"1"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/information-objects#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/information-objects#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRIO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://purl.org/NET/rdflicense/cc-by4.0","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://purl.org/NET/rdflicense/cc-by4.0"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"María Poveda-Villalón\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c53f920-4994-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c53f920-4994-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Serge Chávez-Feria\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6ce68880-4999-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6ce68880-4999-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRIO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.0.3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":247.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6995},"IMAMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/karray/ontologies/2016/0/IMAMO"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IMAMO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IMAMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IMAMO","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IMAMO","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Industrial MAintenance Management Ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IMAMO/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Industrial MAintenance Management Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"108","omv:numberOfProperties":"10","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IMAMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:26.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IMAMO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"IMAMO V2.0 conceptualized & developped by Hedi Karray. Contact: mkarray@enit.fr, Université fédérale de Toulouse-Midi-Pyrénées. ENIT.\\nReference publication: \\\"A formal ontology for industrial maintenance\\\", MH Karray, B Chebel-Morello, N Zerhouni - Applied Ontology, 2012\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IMAMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IMAMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"4","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IMAMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IMAMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"108","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IMAMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IMAMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IMAMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"37"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/karray/ontologies/2016/0/IMAMO","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/karray/ontologies/2016/0/IMAMO"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IMAMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"3"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IMAMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"V2.0- OWL version"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3640},"OBPA":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/obpa#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/obpa/0.3"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/OBPA","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"OBPA","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/OBPA","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/OBPA","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Ontology for building permit authorities.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/OBPA/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Ontology for building permit authorities","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"49","omv:numberOfProperties":"40","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OBPA/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"13"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:27.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OBPA&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Vocabulary for describing organizational structures of building permit authorities\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OBPA/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OBPA/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"5","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OBPA/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OBPA&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"34","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OBPA/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OBPA/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/OBPA","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"19"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/obpa#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/obpa#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OBPA/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"3"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sebastian Seiss and Judith Fauth\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fe156b20-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fe156b20-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OBPA/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":249.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6529},"BIMERRAO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/annotation-objects#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRAO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BIMERRAO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRAO","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRAO","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. BIMERR Annotation Objects.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRAO/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"BIMERR Annotation Objects","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://www.oeg-upm.net/\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3055a710-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3055a710-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"7","omv:numberOfProperties":"30","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"ao","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRAO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:28.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIMERRAO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The Annotation Objects ontology aims to model the annotations and comments made during a renovation project with respect to specific building elements, spaces, etc.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRAO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRAO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRAO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIMERRAO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRAO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRAO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BIMERRAO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"6"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/annotation-objects#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/annotation-objects#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRAO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"María Poveda-Villalón\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c53f920-4994-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c53f920-4994-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Serge Chávez-Feria\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c7a62e0-4994-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c7a62e0-4994-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRAO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.0.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":248.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5925},"BIMERRMP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/material-properties#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRMP","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BIMERRMP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRMP","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRMP","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. BIMERR Material Properties., The material properties ontology provides the vocabulary to describe the composition of building elements.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRMP/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"BIMERR Material Properties","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://www.oeg-upm.net/\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3055a710-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3055a710-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"140","omv:numberOfProperties":"21","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"mat","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRMP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:30.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIMERRMP&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRMP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRMP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRMP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIMERRMP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"128","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRMP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRMP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BIMERRMP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"26"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/material-properties#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/material-properties#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRMP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"3"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"María Poveda-Villalón (Ontology Engineering Group, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2f26d5d0-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2f26d5d0-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Serge Chávez-Feria (Ontology Engineering Group, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2f4c3ac0-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2f4c3ac0-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRMP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.0.8"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":248.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5814},"DCVARIABLES":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Variables"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DCVARIABLES","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DCVARIABLES","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Variables","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DCVARIABLES","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Digital Construction Variables., The objectified property representation is orthogonal to the other definitions in the ontologies: any property can be objectified and consequently be subject of constraints. ","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DCVARIABLES/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Digital Construction Variables","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"27","omv:numberOfProperties":"30","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"dicv","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCVARIABLES/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"8"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:34.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"Ontology of properties, property states, measurements, constraints, and values. The ontology allows the objectification of basic properties, and therefor the addition of their quantity types, units of measure, value time, variables and constraints.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2020-01-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DCVARIABLES&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCVARIABLES/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCVARIABLES/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"3","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCVARIABLES/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DCVARIABLES&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"6","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCVARIABLES/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCVARIABLES/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DCVARIABLES","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"10"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Variables","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Variables"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCVARIABLES/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"3"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Seppo Törmä\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a866b670-498f-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a866b670-498f-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCVARIABLES/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":255.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6340},"SAREF4ENVI":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4envi/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4envi/v1.1.2/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SAREF4ENVI","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SAREF4ENVI","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4envi/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://www.etsi.org/deliver/etsi_ts/103400_103499/10341002/01.01.02_60/ts_10341002v010102p.pdf","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SAREF4ENVI","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. SAREF4ENVI: extension for the Environment domain., This ontology extends the SAREF ontology for the environment domain, specifically for the light pollution domain, including concepts like photometers, light, etc.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SAREF4ENVI/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"SAREF4ENVI: extension for the Environment domain","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.etsi.org/\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9e083b00-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9e083b00-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"30","omv:numberOfProperties":"36","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"s4envi","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4ENVI/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"24"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:34.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2020-06-05T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SAREF4ENVI&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Information about changes compared to version 1.1.1: \\n - Updated namespaces for compatibility with SAREF v3.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4ENVI/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4ENVI/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"7","dct:modified":"2020-06-05T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4ENVI/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SAREF4ENVI&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4ENVI/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4ENVI/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SAREF4ENVI","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"14"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":78.0,"normalizedScore":69,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4envi/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4envi/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4ENVI/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://forge.etsi.org/etsi-software-license","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"4"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://forge.etsi.org/etsi-software-license"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://www.garcia-castro.com/foaf.rdf#me\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c892580-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c892580-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://purl.org/net/mpoveda\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9cb30050-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9cb30050-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"https://saref.etsi.org/sources/saref4envi/\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4ENVI/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.1.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":268.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6323},"SAREF4CITY":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4city/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4city/v1.1.2/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SAREF4CITY","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SAREF4CITY","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4city/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://www.etsi.org/deliver/etsi_ts/103400_103499/10341004/01.01.02_60/ts_10341004v010102p.pdf","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SAREF4CITY","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. SAREF4CITY: extension for the Smart Cities domain., This ontology extends the SAREF ontology for the Smart City domain. This work has been developed in the context of the STF 534 (https://portal.etsi.org/STF/STFs/STFHomePages/STF534.aspx), which was established with the goal to create three SAREF extensions, one of them for the Smart City domain.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SAREF4CITY/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"SAREF4CITY: extension for the Smart Cities domain","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.etsi.org/\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9e083b00-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9e083b00-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"109","omv:numberOfProperties":"69","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"s4city","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4CITY/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"10"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:35.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2020-06-05T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SAREF4CITY&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Information about changes compared to version 1.1.1: \\n - Updated namespaces for compatibility with SAREF v3.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4CITY/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4CITY/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"5","dct:modified":"2020-06-05T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4CITY/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SAREF4CITY&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"8","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4CITY/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4CITY/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SAREF4CITY","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"23"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":78.0,"normalizedScore":69,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4city/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4city/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"https://saref.etsi.org/core/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"https://saref.etsi.org/core/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4CITY/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://forge.etsi.org/etsi-software-license","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"5"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://forge.etsi.org/etsi-software-license"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://www.garcia-castro.com/foaf.rdf#me\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c892580-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c892580-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://w3id.org/people/mpoveda\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9634c7b0-499f-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9634c7b0-499f-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.linkedin.com/in/paolaespinoza-arias/\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/965dd360-499f-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/965dd360-499f-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"https://saref.etsi.org/sources/saref4city/\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4CITY/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.1.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":273.0,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6027},"OPENADR":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/def/openadr"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/OPENADR","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"OPENADR","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/OPENADR","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/OPENADR","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. OpenADR ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/OPENADR/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"OpenADR ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"77","omv:numberOfProperties":"98","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPENADR/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"6"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:36.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OPENADR&q=","schema:comment":"[\"http://purl.org/NET/rdflicense/cc-by4.0\",\"This ontology describes the openADR protocol based on the documentation provided by the openADR Profile B\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPENADR/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPENADR/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"5","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPENADR/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OPENADR&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"6","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPENADR/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPENADR/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/OPENADR","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"24"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/def/openadr","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/def/openadr"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPENADR/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://purl.org/NET/rdflicense/cc-by4.0","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"3"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://purl.org/NET/rdflicense/cc-by4.0"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alba Fernández Izquierdo\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c11e0b0-499d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c11e0b0-499d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://www.garcia-castro.com/foaf.rdf#me\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c892580-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c892580-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Andrea Cimmino\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c38fca0-499d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c38fca0-499d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPENADR/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.2.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":254.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7487},"SCOPRO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/indonto/ontologies/2014/0/SCOPRO"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SCOPRO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SCOPRO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SCOPRO","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SCOPRO","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Supply Chain Process Ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SCOPRO/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Supply Chain Process Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"201","omv:numberOfProperties":"57","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCOPRO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:37.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SCOPRO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCOPRO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCOPRO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCOPRO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SCOPRO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"109","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCOPRO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCOPRO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SCOPRO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"17"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/indonto/ontologies/2014/0/SCOPRO","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/indonto/ontologies/2014/0/SCOPRO"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCOPRO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"5"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alicia C. Böhm\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bd2127f0-4990-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bd2127f0-4990-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marcela Vegetti\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bdbf8ae0-4990-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bdbf8ae0-4990-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gabriela P. Henning\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bde9af20-4990-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bde9af20-4990-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Horacio P. Leone\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/be0e95d0-4990-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/be0e95d0-4990-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCOPRO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":245.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5513},"DCLIFECYCLE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Lifecycle"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DCLIFECYCLE","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DCLIFECYCLE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Lifecycle","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DCLIFECYCLE","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Digital Construction Lifecycle.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DCLIFECYCLE/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Digital Construction Lifecycle","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"167","omv:numberOfProperties":"290","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"dicl","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCLIFECYCLE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"11"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:37.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2020-06-18T12:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DCLIFECYCLE&q=","schema:comment":"[\"An ontology to represent the enhancement of building data throughout the construction lifecycle stages\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCLIFECYCLE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCLIFECYCLE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"15","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCLIFECYCLE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DCLIFECYCLE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"44","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCLIFECYCLE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCLIFECYCLE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DCLIFECYCLE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"14"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Lifecycle","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Lifecycle"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Contexts, https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Entities, https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Processes, https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Agents, https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Variables]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Contexts, https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Entities, https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Processes, https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Agents, https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Variables]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCLIFECYCLE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Janakiram Karlapudi (janakiram.karlapudi@tu-dresden.de)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/f8741390-4990-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/f8741390-4990-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCLIFECYCLE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.5"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":262.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6518},"BRICK":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://brickschema.org/schema/1.3/Brick"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BRICK","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BRICK","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://brickschema.org","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BRICK","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Brick A uniform metadata schema for buildings.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BRICK/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Brick A uniform metadata schema for buildings","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1452","omv:numberOfProperties":"107","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BRICK/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2566"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:37.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"6","dct:created":"2016-11-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BRICK&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BRICK/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BRICK/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"115","dct:modified":"2022-10-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BRICK/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BRICK&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"476","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BRICK/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BRICK/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BRICK","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"102"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://brickschema.org/schema/1.3/Brick","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://brickschema.org/schema/1.3/Brick"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BRICK/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://github.com/BrickSchema/brick/blob/master/LICENSE","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"7"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://github.com/BrickSchema/brick/blob/master/LICENSE"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BRICK/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.3.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":257.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6495},"BIPM-SI-UNITS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://si-digital-framework.org/SI/units/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://si-digital-framework.org/1.0.0/units/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/TheBIPM/SI_Digital_Framework","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BIPM-SI-UNITS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology part of the SI Reference Point covering SI measurement units and prefixes.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/TheBIPM/SI_Digital_Framework/main/knowledge_graphs/SI_Reference_Point/units.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"BIPM SI Reference Point Units Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"13","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-UNITS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"116"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:10:41.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIPM-SI-UNITS&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The SI Reference Point Ontology developed by the BIPM is\\nlicensed under CC-BY-3.0-IGO. You are free to share (copy and redistribute\\nthe material in any medium or format) and adapt (remix, transform, and\\nbuild upon the material) for any purpose, even commercially, for any\\npurpose, even commercially. The licensor cannot revoke these freedoms as\\nlong as you follow the license terms. You must give appropriate credit\\n(by using the original ontology IRI for the whole ontology and original\\nterm IRIs for individual terms), provide a link to the license, and\\nindicate if any changes were made. You may do so in any reasonable\\nmanner, but not in any way that suggests the licensor endorses you or\\nyour use.\",\"Ontology, part of the SI Reference Point, covering measurement units (SI base units and SI units with special names) and prefixes.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-UNITS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-UNITS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-UNITS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIPM-SI-UNITS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"13","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-UNITS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-UNITS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-UNITS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"13"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://si-digital-framework.org/SI/units/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://si-digital-framework.org/SI/units/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-UNITS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"BIPM SI Digital Framework team"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-UNITS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4000},"DPP-ODP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-odp/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-odp/0.1/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPPO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DPP-ODP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-odp/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPPO","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Core design pattern ontology module for modeling Digital Product Passports., This is a minimal core Ontology Design Pattern defining what a DPP is, i.e. information about a product.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/LiUSemWeb/DPPO/dev/ontology/dpp-odp/0.1/dpp-odp.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Digital Product Passport Ontology Design Pattern","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"2","omv:numberOfProperties":"2","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"dpp-odp","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-ODP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:10:44.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2023-10-30T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DPP-ODP&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-ODP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-ODP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-ODP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DPP-ODP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-ODP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-ODP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DPP-ODP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"2"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-odp/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-odp/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-ODP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPP/blob/master/LICENSE","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPP/blob/master/LICENSE"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"LiU SemWeb team"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Maike Jansen\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/66f42990-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/66f42990-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Eva Blomqvist\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/67ad5cd0-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/67ad5cd0-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Huanyu Li\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/67873240-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/67873240-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Robin Keskisärkkä\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/67d2fda0-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/67d2fda0-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-ODP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":245.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6546},"BIPM-SI":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://si-digital-framework.org/SI#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://si-digital-framework.org/1.0.0/SI#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/TheBIPM/SI_Digital_Framework","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BIPM-SI","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Core ontology part of the SI Reference Point developed by BIPM, covering measurement units, base units, and SI prefixes.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/TheBIPM/SI_Digital_Framework/main/knowledge_graphs/SI_Reference_Point/si.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"BIPM SI Reference Point Core Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"27","omv:numberOfProperties":"56","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"7"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:10:41.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIPM-SI&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The SI Reference Point Ontology developed by the BIPM is\\nlicensed under CC-BY-3.0-IGO. You are free to share (copy and redistribute\\nthe material in any medium or format) and adapt (remix, transform, and\\nbuild upon the material) for any purpose, even commercially, for any\\npurpose, even commercially. The licensor cannot revoke these freedoms as\\nlong as you follow the license terms. You must give appropriate credit\\n(by using the original ontology IRI for the whole ontology and original\\nterm IRIs for individual terms), provide a link to the license, and\\nindicate if any changes were made. You may do so in any reasonable\\nmanner, but not in any way that suggests the licensor endorses you or\\nyour use.\",\"Ontology, part of the SI Reference Point, covering measurement units (SI base units and SI units with special names) and prefixes.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIPM-SI&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"15","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"13"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://si-digital-framework.org/SI#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://si-digital-framework.org/SI#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"BIPM SI Digital Framework team"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3996},"NFDICORE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ISE-FIZKarlsruhe/nfdicore/main/nfdicore.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/ISE-FIZKarlsruhe/nfdicore","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NFDICORE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"NFDI Core Ontology (NFDICORE) for linking research data metadata across the German National Research Data Infrastructure (NFDI) initiatives.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ISE-FIZKarlsruhe/nfdicore/main/nfdicore.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"NFDI Core Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NFDICORE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:36:26.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NFDICORE&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NFDICORE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NFDICORE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NFDICORE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=NFDICORE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NFDICORE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NFDICORE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/NFDICORE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ISE-FIZKarlsruhe/nfdicore/main/nfdicore.ttl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ISE-FIZKarlsruhe/nfdicore/main/nfdicore.ttl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NFDICORE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"FIZ Karlsruhe"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/NFDICORE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"main"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/nfdimatwerk"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2937},"ONTOCAPE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/nfdi4cat/Ontology-Overview-of-NFDI4Cat/main/ontologies/OntoCAPE.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://www.avt.rwth-aachen.de/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ONTOCAPE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Large-scale ontology for the domain of Computer-Aided Process Engineering (CAPE) covering physical quantities, unit operations, materials, and mathematical models.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/nfdi4cat/Ontology-Overview-of-NFDI4Cat/main/ontologies/OntoCAPE.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Ontology for Computer-Aided Process Engineering","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOCAPE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:36:29.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ONTOCAPE&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOCAPE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOCAPE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOCAPE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ONTOCAPE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOCAPE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOCAPE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/ONTOCAPE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/nfdi4cat/Ontology-Overview-of-NFDI4Cat/main/ontologies/OntoCAPE.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/nfdi4cat/Ontology-Overview-of-NFDI4Cat/main/ontologies/OntoCAPE.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOCAPE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"RWTH Aachen Process Systems Engineering"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ONTOCAPE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/chemistry"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2924},"DINEN61360":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-DINEN61360/master/DINEN61360.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/hsu-aut/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DINEN61360","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern for common product data dictionaries based on DIN EN 61360.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-DINEN61360/master/DINEN61360.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"DIN EN 61360 Product Data ODP","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DINEN61360/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:47:23.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DINEN61360&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DINEN61360/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DINEN61360/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DINEN61360/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DINEN61360&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DINEN61360/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DINEN61360/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DINEN61360","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-DINEN61360/master/DINEN61360.ttl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-DINEN61360/master/DINEN61360.ttl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DINEN61360/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Automatik / Standards Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DINEN61360/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2834},"VDI2860":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDI2860/master/VDI2860.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/hsu-aut/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"VDI2860","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern for atomic handling actions and assembly based on VDI 2860.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDI2860/master/VDI2860.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"VDI 2860 Handling Operations ODP","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI2860/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:47:37.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=VDI2860&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI2860/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI2860/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI2860/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=VDI2860&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI2860/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI2860/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/VDI2860","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDI2860/master/VDI2860.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDI2860/master/VDI2860.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI2860/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Automatik / Standards Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI2860/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2932},"MOO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/nd-crane/moo/main/release/ontology/latest/ontology.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/nd-crane/moo","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MOO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology to support the use of additive manufacturing for the production of parts in maintenance operations.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/nd-crane/moo/main/release/ontology/latest/ontology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Maintenance Operations Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:55:54.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MOO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MOO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MOO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/nd-crane/moo/main/release/ontology/latest/ontology.ttl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/nd-crane/moo/main/release/ontology/latest/ontology.ttl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"nd-crane"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MOO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2875},"GLUE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/glue"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://w3id.org/glue","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"GLUE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/dtai-kg/GLUE-Ontology","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/dtai-kg/GLUE-Ontology/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Schema for representing adhesives, substrate materials, material families, adhesive quality measures, and industrial adhesion applications.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/dtai-kg/GLUE-Ontology/main/glue_ontology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"GLUE Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"11","omv:numberOfProperties":"120","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLUE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T17:16:51.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"An ontology that describes adhesives, related substrates, materials and applications.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"http://w3id.org/glue\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=GLUE&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLUE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLUE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLUE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=GLUE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"3","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLUE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLUE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/GLUE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"10"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/glue","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/glue"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLUE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Ioannis Dasoulas, Anastasia Dimou]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Simon Vandevalle\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d6895eb0-4961-013f-2762-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d6895eb0-4961-013f-2762-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Anastasia Dimou\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d5ff2af0-4961-013f-2762-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d5ff2af0-4961-013f-2762-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ioannis Dasoulas\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d62864a0-4961-013f-2762-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d62864a0-4961-013f-2762-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jeroen Jordens\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d6611520-4961-013f-2762-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d6611520-4961-013f-2762-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/GLUE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/chemistry, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":245.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6462},"RO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ro.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ro/releases/2025-12-17/ro.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/oborel/obo-relations/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The OBO Relation Ontology (RO) is a collection of relations for use in biomedical and manufacturing domain ontologies., The OBO Relations Ontology (RO) is a collection of OWL relations (ObjectProperties) intended for use across a wide variety of biological ontologies.","omv:resourceLocator":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ro.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Relation Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"59","omv:numberOfProperties":"706","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"91"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:30:05.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=RO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"10","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=RO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"13","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/RO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"7"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ro.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ro.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"7"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"RO Maintainers"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/RO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2025-12-17"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":256.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4548},"UO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/uo.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/uo/releases/2026-01-16/uo.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/bio-ontology-research-group/unit-ontology","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"UO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/bio-ontology-research-group/unit-ontology","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/bio-ontology-research-group/unit-ontology/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Unit Ontology is an ontology for standard units of measurement used across biomedical and physical sciences.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/bio-ontology-research-group/unit-ontology/master/uo.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Unit Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"574","omv:numberOfProperties":"2","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/UO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"276"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T18:12:13.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://github.com/bio-ontology-research-group/unit-ontology\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=UO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/UO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/UO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"167","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/UO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=UO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"166","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/UO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/UO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/UO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"38"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":75.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/uo.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/uo.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/UO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"5"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Alexandru Todor"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/UO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2026-01-16"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":260.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4319},"HDPO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/emmo-hpo/hpo"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://w3id.org/emmo-hpo/1.0.0-beta1/hpo"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/emmo-repo/hyperdimensional-polymer-ontology","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"HDPO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://w3id.org/emmo-hpo/hpo","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/emmo-repo/hyperdimensional-polymer-ontology","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/emmo-repo/hyperdimensional-polymer-ontology/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"EMMO-based domain extension for hyperdimensional representation of polymer materials., An ontology to capture the staggering diversity of polymeric materials and their applications.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/emmo-repo/hyperdimensional-polymer-ontology/main/hpo.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Hyperdimensional Polymer Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"EMMC ASBL\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14c63030-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14c63030-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1839","omv:numberOfProperties":"261","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"hpo","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HDPO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"17"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:19:54.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"The Hyperdimensional Polymer Ontology (HPO) is an ontology meant to capture the staggering diversity of polymeric materials and their applications.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"11","dct:created":"2023-12-22T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=HDPO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Contacts:\\n    Gerhard Goldbeck\\n    Goldbeck Consulting Ltd (UK)\\n    email: gerhard@goldbeck-consulting.com\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HDPO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HDPO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"142","dct:modified":"2024-04-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HDPO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=HDPO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1355","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HDPO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HDPO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/HDPO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"197"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":73.0,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/emmo-hpo/hpo","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/emmo-hpo/hpo"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/emmo/contributors, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/computerscience, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/isq, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/manufacturing, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/materials, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/math, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/metrology, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/models, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/properties, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/units/sidimensionalunits, https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo, https://w3id.org/emmo/mereocausality, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/contrast, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/holistic, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/persistence, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/perspective, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/reductionistic, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/semiotics, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/structural, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/agency, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/data, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/persholistic, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/physicalistic, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/standardmodel, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/symbolic, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/workflow, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/chemistry, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/perceptual]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/emmo/contributors, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/computerscience, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/isq, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/manufacturing, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/materials, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/math, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/metrology, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/models, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/properties, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/units/sidimensionalunits, https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/characterisation-methodology/chameo, https://w3id.org/emmo/mereocausality, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/contrast, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/holistic, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/persistence, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/perspective, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/reductionistic, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/semiotics, https://w3id.org/emmo/perspectives/structural, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/agency, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/data, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/persholistic, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/physicalistic, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/standardmodel, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/symbolic, https://w3id.org/emmo/reference/workflow, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/chemistry, https://w3id.org/emmo/disciplines/perceptual]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HDPO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"22"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"EMMO Maintainers"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Otello Maria Roscioni\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/baa75e10-49b2-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/baa75e10-49b2-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gerhard Goldbeck\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/badc9520-49b2-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/badc9520-49b2-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Daniele Toti\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bb2af730-49b2-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bb2af730-49b2-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Pierluigi Del Nostro\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bb036e20-49b2-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bb036e20-49b2-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gerhard Goldbeck\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bbf47460-49b2-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bbf47460-49b2-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Otello Maria Roscioni\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bbcda230-49b2-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bbcda230-49b2-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Pierluigi Del Nostro\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bc1a6930-49b2-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bc1a6930-49b2-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Daniele Toti\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bc3efbf0-49b2-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bc3efbf0-49b2-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/HDPO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":261.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6443},"BIMERRM":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/bimerr-metadata"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRM","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BIMERRM","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRM","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRM","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. BIMERR Metadata., Ontology module that includes the medata and annotation terms needed in the BIMERR project.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRM/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"BIMERR Metadata","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"0","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRM/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:20.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIMERRM&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRM/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRM/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRM/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIMERRM&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRM/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRM/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BIMERRM","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"0"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/bimerr-metadata","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/bimerr-metadata"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRM/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://purl.org/NET/rdflicense/cc-by4.0","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://purl.org/NET/rdflicense/cc-by4.0"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRM/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.0.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6285},"COINS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.coinsweb.nl/cbim-2.0.rdf"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/COINS","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"COINS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/COINS","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/COINS","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. COINS Building Information System.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/COINS/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"COINS Building Information System","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"43","omv:numberOfProperties":"44","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/COINS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"6"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:21.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=COINS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/COINS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/COINS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"6","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/COINS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=COINS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"3","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/COINS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/COINS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/COINS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"11"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.coinsweb.nl/cbim-2.0.rdf","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.coinsweb.nl/cbim-2.0.rdf"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/COINS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"6"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/COINS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"COINS 2.0 by COINS technical management group"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4073},"DBO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.google.com/digitalbuildings/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DBO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DBO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DBO","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DBO","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Digital Buildings Ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DBO/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Digital Buildings Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1334","omv:numberOfProperties":"7","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DBO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"35"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:22.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"29","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DBO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DBO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DBO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"64","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DBO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DBO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"436","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DBO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DBO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DBO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"401"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.google.com/digitalbuildings/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.google.com/digitalbuildings/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DBO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"6"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DBO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.0.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4376},"BPO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/bpo"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/bpo/1-2"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BPO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BPO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/bpo#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BPO","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BPO","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Building Product Ontology., The Building Product Ontology defines concepts to describe (building) products in a schematic way. It provides methods to describe assembly structures and attach properties to any component without restricting their types, as is often the case in template-driven product descriptions. To allow the description of complex properties, it also contains terms for unordered, two-dimensional lists.\n\nThe BPO's bpo is on the schematic description of product only, not including geometry or material compositions. Therefore, it can be used to describe theoretical product components without geometric representations as well as those with geometric representations without restrictions. For classification purposes, it uses the buildingSMART Data Dictionary (bSDD) by referencing to the terms' bSDD GUID. If geometric descriptions are desired for components, the authors suggest to use the Ontology for Managing Geometry (OMG, https://w3id.org/omg) resp. the File Ontology for Geometry formats (FOG, https://w3id.org/omg).\n\nThe BPO is based on the SolConPro ontology, which was first presented in:\nWagner, A., Moeller, L.K., Leifgen, C., Rueppel, U., (2018). SolConPro: Describing multi-functional building products using semantic web technologies. In: European Conference on Product and Process Modelling, 12-14 September 2018, Copenhagen, Denmark. In: 12 . CRC Press \n\nThis work is part of the research project Semantic Construction Project Engineering (www.projekt-bpo.de), founded by the German Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy (BMWi).","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BPO/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Building Product Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"25","omv:numberOfProperties":"28","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"bpo","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BPO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:24.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BPO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BPO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BPO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"6","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BPO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BPO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"11","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BPO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BPO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BPO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"12"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":78.0,"normalizedScore":69,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/bpo","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/bpo"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BPO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"https://w3id.org/bpo/1-1","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BPO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://w3id.org/bpo/1-1","owl:versionInfo":"1.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":254.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4692},"BIMERRKPI":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/key-performance-indicator#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRKPI","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BIMERRKPI","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/key-performance-indicator#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRKPI","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRKPI","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. BIMERR Key Performance Indicator., The Key Performance Indicator module aims to model the metrics defined at the beginning of building renovation activities to monitor the conformance with typical requirements related to energy efficient buildings.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRKPI/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"BIMERR Key Performance Indicator","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"18","omv:numberOfProperties":"39","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"kpi","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRKPI/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:24.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIMERRKPI&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRKPI/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRKPI/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"2","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRKPI/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIMERRKPI&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRKPI/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRKPI/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BIMERRKPI","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"15"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/key-performance-indicator#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/key-performance-indicator#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRKPI/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://purl.org/NET/rdflicense/cc-by4.0","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://purl.org/NET/rdflicense/cc-by4.0"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"María Poveda Villalón\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fd43c2c0-498a-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fd43c2c0-498a-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Serge Chávez Feria\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fd6a21d0-498a-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fd6a21d0-498a-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRKPI/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.1.6"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":248.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6798},"BCAO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://github.com/linmor-sys/BCAO.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BCAO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BCAO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BCAO","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BCAO","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Building Circularity Assessment Ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BCAO/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Building Circularity Assessment Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"37","omv:numberOfProperties":"36","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BCAO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:26.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BCAO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"MSc thesis project with the aim of proposing an ontology for Building's Circularity Assessment (BCAO)\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BCAO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BCAO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BCAO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BCAO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"37","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BCAO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BCAO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BCAO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"10"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://github.com/linmor-sys/BCAO.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://github.com/linmor-sys/BCAO.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BCAO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BCAO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":240.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4945},"OMPD-SPO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://spec.equonto.org/ontology/maintenance-procedure/static-procedure-ontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://spec.equonto.org/ontology/202312/maintenance-procedure/static-procedure-ontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/OMPD-SPO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"OMPD-SPO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/OMPD-SPO","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/OMPD-SPO","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Ontology for Maintenance Procedure Documentation - Static Procedure Ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/OMPD-SPO/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Ontology for Maintenance Procedure Documentation - Static Procedure Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Equonto Pty. Ltd.\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/32e95a00-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/32e95a00-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Equonto Pty. Ltd.\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/32b09620-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/32b09620-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"80","omv:numberOfProperties":"118","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OMPD-SPO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:26.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"The OMPD Static Procedure Ontology captures static information found in most insdutrial maintenance procedures.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OMPD-SPO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OMPD-SPO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OMPD-SPO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"11","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OMPD-SPO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OMPD-SPO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"42","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OMPD-SPO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OMPD-SPO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/OMPD-SPO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"12"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":72.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://spec.equonto.org/ontology/maintenance-procedure/static-procedure-ontology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://spec.equonto.org/ontology/maintenance-procedure/static-procedure-ontology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://rds.posccaesar.org/ontology/lis14/ont/core, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://rds.posccaesar.org/ontology/lis14/ont/core, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OMPD-SPO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"4"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"The University of Western Australia & Equonto Pty. Ltd.\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/30677f50-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/30677f50-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melinda Hodkiewicz: The University of Western Australia\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/318ab9a0-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/318ab9a0-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tim French: The University of Western Australia\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/31dac540-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/31dac540-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Caitlin Woods: The University of Western Australia and Equonto\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/320c23e0-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/320c23e0-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OMPD-SPO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":39.0,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":249.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6246},"SCO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.w3id.org/sco"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SCO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SCO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SCO","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"null","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SCO/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Sustainability Core Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:27.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SCO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SCO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SCO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.w3id.org/sco","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://www.w3id.org/sco"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3739},"DCPROCESSES":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Processes"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DCPROCESSES","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DCPROCESSES","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Processes","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DCPROCESSES","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Digital Construction Processes., Process ontology for digital construction","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DCPROCESSES/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Digital Construction Processes","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"130","omv:numberOfProperties":"233","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"dicp","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCPROCESSES/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"11"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:28.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"Processes ontology defines the concepts and relations for activities and resources. ","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2019-12-20T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DCPROCESSES&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCPROCESSES/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCPROCESSES/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"16","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCPROCESSES/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DCPROCESSES&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"25","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCPROCESSES/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCPROCESSES/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DCPROCESSES","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"14"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Processes","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Processes"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Contexts, https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Entities, https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Variables]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Contexts, https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Entities, https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Variables]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCPROCESSES/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Seppo Törmä\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a866b670-498f-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a866b670-498f-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yuan Zheng\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a88da720-498f-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a88da720-498f-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCPROCESSES/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":260.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6466},"DCENTITIES":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Entities"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DCENTITIES","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DCENTITIES","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DCENTITIES","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Digital Construction Entities.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DCENTITIES/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Digital Construction Entities","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"107","omv:numberOfProperties":"193","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCENTITIES/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"8"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:29.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2020-01-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DCENTITIES&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Digital Construction Entities Ontology defines the basic classes and properties needed for the representation of construction and renovation projects. Examples are building object, location, material batch, equipment, agent, information content entity, activity and related time concepts. The ontology is based on BFO. \"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCENTITIES/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCENTITIES/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"13","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCENTITIES/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DCENTITIES&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"13","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCENTITIES/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCENTITIES/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DCENTITIES","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"14"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Entities","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Entities"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCENTITIES/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Seppo Törmä\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a866b670-498f-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a866b670-498f-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yuan Zheng\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a88da720-498f-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a88da720-498f-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCENTITIES/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":44.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":252.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6394},"OMPD-CMTO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://spec.equonto.org/ontology/maintenance-procedure/conditional-maintenance-task-ontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://spec.equonto.org/ontology/202312/maintenance-procedure/conditional-maintenance-task-ontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/OMPD-CMTO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"OMPD-CMTO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/OMPD-CMTO","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/OMPD-CMTO","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Ontology for Maintenance Procedure Documentation - Conditional Maintenance Task Ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/OMPD-CMTO/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Ontology for Maintenance Procedure Documentation - Conditional Maintenance Task Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Equonto Pty. Ltd.\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/081f7770-49a0-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/081f7770-49a0-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Equonto Pty. Ltd.\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/08594890-49a0-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/08594890-49a0-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"9","omv:numberOfProperties":"12","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OMPD-CMTO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:30.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"The OMPD Conditional Maintenance Task Ontology captures functional failures and corrective maintenance tasks (to be conditionally executed on the occurrence of a function failure) found in some industrial maintenance procedures. This ontology captures information currently stored in maintenance procedure documentation in a generalizable way and supports its core users (maintenance technicians, maintenance engineers and maintenance schedulers) in their work. This ontology is designed to be used alongside the Static Procedure Ontology (https://spec.equonto.org/ontology/maintenance-procedure/static-procedure-ontology/) for a more detailed description of maintenance procedures. Users can find details of the design methodology for this ontology at https://content.iospress.com/articles/applied-ontology/ao230279","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OMPD-CMTO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OMPD-CMTO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OMPD-CMTO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"4","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OMPD-CMTO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OMPD-CMTO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"5","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OMPD-CMTO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OMPD-CMTO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/OMPD-CMTO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"5"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":72.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://spec.equonto.org/ontology/maintenance-procedure/conditional-maintenance-task-ontology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://spec.equonto.org/ontology/maintenance-procedure/conditional-maintenance-task-ontology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OMPD-CMTO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"The University of Western Australia & Equonto Pty. Ltd.\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/06aa8de0-49a0-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/06aa8de0-49a0-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Caitlin Woods: The University of Western Australia and Equonto\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/079a4a10-49a0-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/079a4a10-49a0-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melinda Hodkiewicz: The University of Western Australia\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/074ab010-49a0-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/074ab010-49a0-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tim French: The University of Western Australia\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/07727e60-49a0-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/07727e60-49a0-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OMPD-CMTO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":39.0,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":244.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5804},"Z-BRE4K":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.Z-bre4k.org/ontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/Z-BRE4K","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"Z-BRE4K","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/Z-BRE4K","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/Z-BRE4K","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Z-bre4k.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/Z-BRE4K/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Z-bre4k","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"55","omv:numberOfProperties":"79","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/Z-BRE4K/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:31.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=Z-BRE4K&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Created by EPFL from work of Z-bre4k project\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/Z-BRE4K/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/Z-BRE4K/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"6","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/Z-BRE4K/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=Z-BRE4K&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"55","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/Z-BRE4K/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/Z-BRE4K/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/Z-BRE4K","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"7"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.Z-bre4k.org/ontology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.Z-bre4k.org/ontology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/Z-BRE4K/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"4"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/Z-BRE4K/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3721},"SCOR":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/eis/vocab/scor#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SCOR","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SCOR","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/eis/vocab/scor#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/vocol/scor/wiki","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/vocol/scor/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Supply Chain Operation Reference.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://github.com/vocol/scor/releases","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Supply Chain Operation Reference","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"eccenca GmbH\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9900290-498e-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9900290-498e-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"eccenca GmbH\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9cdf2b0-498e-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9cdf2b0-498e-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"University of Bonn\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9600640-498e-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e9600640-498e-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"https://github.com/vocol/scor.git"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"285","omv:numberOfProperties":"254","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"scor","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCOR/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"224"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:33.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2015-03-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SCOR&q=","schema:comment":"[\"A vocabulary which represents the Supply Chain Operations Reference (SCOR) standard.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCOR/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCOR/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"2015-11-05T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCOR/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SCOR&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"5","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCOR/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCOR/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SCOR","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"15"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/eis/vocab/scor#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/eis/vocab/scor#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://schema.org/, http://usefulinc.com/ns/doap#, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns#, http://rdfs.org/ns/void#, http://purl.org/ontology/olo/core#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://schema.org/, http://usefulinc.com/ns/doap#, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns#, http://rdfs.org/ns/void#, http://purl.org/ontology/olo/core#]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCOR/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://www.opendatacommons.org/licenses/pddl/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"3"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://www.opendatacommons.org/licenses/pddl/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sebastian Tramp\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e7ee39e0-498e-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e7ee39e0-498e-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Niklas Petersen\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e8143f20-498e-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e8143f20-498e-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Irlán Grangel-González\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e83b3b10-498e-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e83b3b10-498e-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Niklas Petersen\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e8832da0-498e-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e8832da0-498e-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SCOR/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"SNAPSHOT"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":39.0,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":255.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6728},"BIMERRSD":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/sensor-data#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRSD","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BIMERRSD","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRSD","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRSD","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. BIMERR Sensor Data Ontology., The Sensor Data ontology has been developed to represent measurements generated by sensors located inside building spaces. It also includes specific concepts and properties to model sensors and actuators records that follow the SenML standard. This model allows the representation of resolved and unresolved records if required. (Check SenML standard for more details: https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc8428#)","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BIMERRSD/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"BIMERR Sensor Data Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://www.oeg-upm.net/\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3055a710-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3055a710-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"10","omv:numberOfProperties":"16","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"sd","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRSD/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:34.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIMERRSD&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRSD/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRSD/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"3","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRSD/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIMERRSD&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRSD/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRSD/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BIMERRSD","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"6"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/sensor-data#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://bimerr.iot.linkeddata.es/def/sensor-data#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRSD/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://purl.org/NET/rdflicense/cc-by4.0","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://purl.org/NET/rdflicense/cc-by4.0"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"María Poveda-Villalón\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c53f920-4994-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c53f920-4994-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Serge Chávez-Feria.\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/aa8f1120-4997-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/aa8f1120-4997-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMERRSD/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.0.3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":248.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6941},"EMMO-MECH-TEST":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://emmo.info/emmo/domain/mechanical-testing"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://emmo.info/emmo/domain/mechanical-testing/1.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/EMMO-MECH-TEST","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"EMMO-MECH-TEST","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/EMMO-MECH-TEST","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/EMMO-MECH-TEST","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Domain Mechanical Testing.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/EMMO-MECH-TEST/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Domain Mechanical Testing","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"EMMC ASBL\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14c63030-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14c63030-edb8-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"410","omv:numberOfProperties":"17","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO-MECH-TEST/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:35.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"A domain ontology for Mechanical Testing based on EMMO.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"4","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=EMMO-MECH-TEST&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology is a joint colaboration between different projects: OYSTER, UrWerk and MarketPlace.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO-MECH-TEST/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO-MECH-TEST/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"60","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO-MECH-TEST/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=EMMO-MECH-TEST&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"178","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO-MECH-TEST/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO-MECH-TEST/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/EMMO-MECH-TEST","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"90"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":72.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://emmo.info/emmo/domain/mechanical-testing","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://emmo.info/emmo/domain/mechanical-testing"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO-MECH-TEST/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"6"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gerhard Goldbeck\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/30a3d560-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/30a3d560-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Adham Hashibon\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/69806030-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/69806030-edb9-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Joana Francisco Morgado\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ac076390-499a-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ac076390-499a-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Daniele Toti\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/abe01bc0-499a-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/abe01bc0-499a-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yoav Nahshon\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ac2f57e0-499a-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ac2f57e0-499a-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Goldbeck Consulting Ltd (UK)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/316c7fc0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/316c7fc0-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Fraunhofer IWM, DE\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9878dc00-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9878dc00-edb5-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/EMMO-MECH-TEST/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":253.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6820},"DEMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://a.com/ontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DEMO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DEMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DEMO","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DEMO","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Discrete Event Modeling Ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DEMO/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Discrete Event Modeling Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"150","omv:numberOfProperties":"76","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DEMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"111"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:36.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DEMO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DEMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DEMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"37","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DEMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DEMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"79","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DEMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DEMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DEMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"34"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://a.com/ontology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://a.com/ontology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DEMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DEMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":240.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3647},"MSDL":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://infoneer.txstate.edu/ontology/MSDL"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/MSDL","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MSDL","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/MSDL","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/MSDL","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Manufacturing Service Description Language.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/MSDL/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Manufacturing Service Description Language","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"646","omv:numberOfProperties":"575","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSDL/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2835"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:35.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MSDL&q=","schema:comment":"[\"MSDL 4.0 is compliant with Basic Formal Ontology (BFO 2.0). This is a working draft of MSDL and the class structure is subject to change.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSDL/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSDL/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"41","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSDL/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MSDL&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"413","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSDL/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSDL/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MSDL","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"36"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://infoneer.txstate.edu/ontology/MSDL","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://infoneer.txstate.edu/ontology/MSDL"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/iao.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ro.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ro/annotations.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ro/core.owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/iao.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ro.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ro/annotations.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/ro/core.owl]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSDL/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"13"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Farhad Ameri\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dc264a40-499e-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dc264a40-499e-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MSDL/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":249.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5858},"DPP-CORE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-core/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-core/0.1/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPPO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DPP-CORE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-core/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPPO","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPPO/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Digital Product Passport Core Ontology (DPP-CORE)., This is a minimal core ontology for DPPs, specialising the DPP ODP.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/LiUSemWeb/DPPO/main/ontology/dpp-core/0.1/dpp-core.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Digital Product Passport Core Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"10","omv:numberOfProperties":"2","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"dpp-core","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-CORE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:18:11.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2023-10-30T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DPP-CORE&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-CORE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-CORE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-CORE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DPP-CORE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"0","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-CORE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-CORE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DPP-CORE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"4"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":73.0,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-core/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-core/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-odp/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://w3id.org/dppo/ontology/dpp-odp/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-CORE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPP/blob/master/LICENSE","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://github.com/LiUSemWeb/DPP/blob/master/LICENSE"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"LiU Semantic Web Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Maike Jansen\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/630206a0-49b6-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/630206a0-49b6-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Huanyu Li\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ee97be10-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ee97be10-edba-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Eva Blomqvist\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/63a324c0-49b6-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/63a324c0-49b6-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Robin Keskisärkkä\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/63c97640-49b6-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/63c97640-49b6-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DPP-CORE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":252.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6560},"DCCS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://ptb.de/dccs/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://ptb.de/dccs/v0.0.2/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://gitlab1.ptb.de/d-ptb/dcc/ontology-dcc","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DCCS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://ptb.de/dccs/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"https://gitlab1.ptb.de/d-ptb/dcc/ontology-dcc/-/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology presenting the schema for metrologically correct representation of digital calibration certificates (DCC). Developed by PTB.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://gitlab1.ptb.de/d-ptb/dcc/ontology-dcc/-/raw/main/ontology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Digital Calibration Certificate Semantic Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://ror.org/05r3f7h03\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/41266d20-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/41266d20-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"https://gitlab1.ptb.de/d-ptb/dcc/ontology-dcc"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"86","omv:numberOfProperties":"84","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"dccs","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCCS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"18"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:12:44.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"Ontology presenting the schema for metrologically correct representation of calibration certificates.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.48505/nims.5395\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DCCS&q=","schema:comment":"[\"\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCCS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCCS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"12","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCCS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DCCS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"46","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCCS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCCS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DCCS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"35"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":78.0,"normalizedScore":69,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://ptb.de/dccs/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://ptb.de/dccs/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCCS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"3"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"[Jan Loewe, Moritz Jordan]"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0941-5950\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40f3afe0-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40f3afe0-1c86-013f-9646-7a762864eccb\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCCS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v0.0.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":266.0,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6703},"BIPM-SI-CONST":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://si-digital-framework.org/constants/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://si-digital-framework.org/1.0.0/constants/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/TheBIPM/SI_Digital_Framework","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BIPM-SI-CONST","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology representing SI Defining Constants and their values.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/TheBIPM/SI_Digital_Framework/main/knowledge_graphs/SI_Reference_Point/constants.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"BIPM SI Reference Point Constants Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"6","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-CONST/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"12"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:12:44.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIPM-SI-CONST&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The SI Reference Point Ontology developed by the BIPM is\\nlicensed under CC-BY-3.0-IGO. You are free to share (copy and redistribute\\nthe material in any medium or format) and adapt (remix, transform, and\\nbuild upon the material) for any purpose, even commercially, for any\\npurpose, even commercially. The licensor cannot revoke these freedoms as\\nlong as you follow the license terms. You must give appropriate credit\\n(by using the original ontology IRI for the whole ontology and original\\nterm IRIs for individual terms), provide a link to the license, and\\nindicate if any changes were made. You may do so in any reasonable\\nmanner, but not in any way that suggests the licensor endorses you or\\nyour use.\",\"Ontology, part of the SI reference point, covering the seven underpinning constants of the SI\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-CONST/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-CONST/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-CONST/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIPM-SI-CONST&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"6","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-CONST/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-CONST/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-CONST","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"6"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://si-digital-framework.org/constants/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://si-digital-framework.org/constants/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-CONST/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/igo/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"BIPM SI Digital Framework team"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIPM-SI-CONST/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4059},"METADATA4ING":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://git.rwth-aachen.de/nfdi4ing/metadata4ing/metadata4ing/-/raw/develop/metadata4ing.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://nfdi4ing.de/special-interest-groups-sig/metadata-ontologies/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"METADATA4ING","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"An ontology for describing the generation of research data within a scientific activity, developed by NFDI4Ing.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://git.rwth-aachen.de/nfdi4ing/metadata4ing/metadata4ing/-/raw/develop/metadata4ing.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Metadata4Ing","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/METADATA4ING/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:36:12.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=METADATA4ING&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/METADATA4ING/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/METADATA4ING/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/METADATA4ING/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=METADATA4ING&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/METADATA4ING/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/METADATA4ING/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/METADATA4ING","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://git.rwth-aachen.de/nfdi4ing/metadata4ing/metadata4ing/-/raw/develop/metadata4ing.ttl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://git.rwth-aachen.de/nfdi4ing/metadata4ing/metadata4ing/-/raw/develop/metadata4ing.ttl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/METADATA4ING/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"NFDI4Ing metadata working group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/METADATA4ING/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"develop"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/nfdimatwerk"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3308},"PEROVSKITEMAT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://growgraph.dev/ontologies/perovskitemat"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://growgraph.dev/ontologies/perovskitemat/1.2.3"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/NAS-Lund/matsci-perovskite-ontologies","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PEROVSKITEMAT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/NAS-Lund/matsci-perovskite-ontologies","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/NAS-Lund/matsci-perovskite-ontologies/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"An ontology containing concepts and individuals specific to perovskite materials, linked to the general matsci-ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/NAS-Lund/matsci-perovskite-ontologies/main/perovskitemat.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Perovskite Materials Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"23","omv:numberOfProperties":"5","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PEROVSKITEMAT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"15"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T17:16:54.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://github.com/NAS-Lund/matsci-perovskite-ontologies\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PEROVSKITEMAT&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Perovskite-specific ontology split from perovOntology. It contains only concepts and individuals that are specific to perovskite materials.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PEROVSKITEMAT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PEROVSKITEMAT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"2","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PEROVSKITEMAT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PEROVSKITEMAT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PEROVSKITEMAT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PEROVSKITEMAT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PEROVSKITEMAT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"12"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://growgraph.dev/ontologies/perovskitemat","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://growgraph.dev/ontologies/perovskitemat"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PEROVSKITEMAT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Alexandru Todor"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"growgraph.dev\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2daae680-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2daae680-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PEROVSKITEMAT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.2.3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":249.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6106},"OEKG":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://github.com/ebrahimnorouzi/OEKG"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/ebrahimnorouzi/OEKG","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"OEKG","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/ebrahimnorouzi/OEKG","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/ebrahimnorouzi/OEKG/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology Evaluation Knowledge Graph (OEKG) for ontologies in Materials Science and Engineering.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ebrahimnorouzi/OEKG/main/mse_ontologies.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Ontology Evaluation Knowledge Graph","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OEKG/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"94"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T17:16:54.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://github.com/ebrahimnorouzi/OEKG\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OEKG&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OEKG/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OEKG/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OEKG/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OEKG&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OEKG/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OEKG/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/OEKG","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"1"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://github.com/ebrahimnorouzi/OEKG","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://github.com/ebrahimnorouzi/OEKG"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OEKG/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/Apache-2.0.html","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/Apache-2.0.html"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Ebrahim Norouzi"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OEKG/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":255.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7240},"BONSAI":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://ontology.bonsai.uno"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/BONSAMURAIS/ontology","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BONSAI","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"BONSAI Core Ontology represents product lifecycle assessments (LCA), activity/process structures, materials, and industrial ecology flows.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BONSAMURAIS/ontology/master/core/ontology_v0.2.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"BONSAI Core LCA Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BONSAI/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:59:09.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BONSAI&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BONSAI/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BONSAI/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BONSAI/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BONSAI&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BONSAI/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BONSAI/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BONSAI","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://ontology.bonsai.uno","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://ontology.bonsai.uno"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BONSAI/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"BONSAI Maintainers"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BONSAI/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":220.0,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3693},"TSO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/JoseIllSCCH/TechnicalStandardsOntology/main/TechnicalStandarsOntology.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/JoseIllSCCH/TechnicalStandardsOntology","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"TSO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Technical Standards Ontology (TSO) for describing security standards, provisions, and compliance profiles.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/JoseIllSCCH/TechnicalStandardsOntology/main/TechnicalStandarsOntology.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Technical Standards Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:44:26.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=TSO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=TSO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/TSO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/JoseIllSCCH/TechnicalStandardsOntology/main/TechnicalStandarsOntology.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/JoseIllSCCH/TechnicalStandardsOntology/main/TechnicalStandarsOntology.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Jose Ignacio"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/TSO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3075},"DIN8580":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-DIN8580/master/DIN8580.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/hsu-aut/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DIN8580","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern for DIN 8580 standard classifying manufacturing processes.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-DIN8580/master/DIN8580.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"DIN 8580 Manufacturing Processes ODP","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIN8580/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:44:29.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DIN8580&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIN8580/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIN8580/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIN8580/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DIN8580&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIN8580/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIN8580/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DIN8580","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-DIN8580/master/DIN8580.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-DIN8580/master/DIN8580.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIN8580/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Automatik / Standards Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DIN8580/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3001},"PACKML":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-PackML/master/PackML.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/hsu-aut/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PACKML","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern representing PackML machine state machine behavior.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-PackML/master/PackML.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"PackML Machine State ODP","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PACKML/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:44:31.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PACKML&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PACKML/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PACKML/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PACKML/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PACKML&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PACKML/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PACKML/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PACKML","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-PackML/master/PackML.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-PackML/master/PackML.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PACKML/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Automatik / Standards Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PACKML/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3052},"IOF-PPS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/productionplanning/ProductionPlanning/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202602/productionplanning/ProductionPlanning/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IOF-PPS","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IOF-PPS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IOF-PPS","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/iofoundry/ontology/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. IOF-PPS.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/iofoundry/ontology/main/productionplanning/ProductionPlanning.rdf","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"IOF Production Planning and Scheduling Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2ccc3350-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2ccc3350-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"142","omv:numberOfProperties":"143","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-PPS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:16:47.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"Production Planning ontology is a domain reference ontology for process and production planning activities within various industries. It includes general terms common for different types of manufacturing industries, such as discrete manufacturing, process manufacturing, batch manufacturing, biomanufacturing, and others. Being reference ontology, it is expacted that users of the production planning ontology will extend its classes in ways compatible with common vocabulary in manufacturing domains, such as aerospace, automotive, food industries, and others.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOF-PPS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-PPS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-PPS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"14","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-PPS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOF-PPS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"104","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-PPS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-PPS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IOF-PPS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"14"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":72.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/productionplanning/ProductionPlanning/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/productionplanning/ProductionPlanning/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-PPS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fd44b350-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fd44b350-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2c5f25d0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2c5f25d0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fd83b600-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fd83b600-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fda0c0a0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fda0c0a0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fdb79c30-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fdb79c30-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fdcc3a00-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fdcc3a00-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fde24900-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fde24900-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fdf7bae0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fdf7bae0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fe0e46e0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/fe0e46e0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-PPS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":39.0,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":249.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7388},"IDO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rds.posccaesar.org/ontology/lis14/ont/core"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://rds.posccaesar.org/ontology/lis14/ont/core/4.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://www.posccaesar.org","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IDO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Industrial Data Ontology (ISO 15926-14 / LIS-14) is an upper ontology for industrial engineering, operations, and lifecycle data, inspired by the ISO 15926-2 data model and Basic Formal Ontology., The Industrial Data Ontology is an upper ontology for industrial data","omv:resourceLocator":"https://rds.posccaesar.org/ontology/lis14/ont/core/4.0/LIS-14.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Industrial Data Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.posccaesar.org\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a5818c60-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a5818c60-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"49","omv:numberOfProperties":"94","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IDO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:30:08.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IDO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The Industrial Data Ontology is an upper ontology for industrial data, inspired by the ISO 15926-2 data model and Basic Formal Ontology.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IDO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IDO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"9","dct:modified":"2024-11-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IDO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IDO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"41","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IDO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IDO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IDO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"6"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rds.posccaesar.org/ontology/lis14/ont/core","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rds.posccaesar.org/ontology/lis14/ont/core"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IDO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"4"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"POSC Caesar Association"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7167-7321\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a40656d0-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a40656d0-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6228-1317\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/da8bd4c0-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/da8bd4c0-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0009-0005-8440-2238\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/daf2ac80-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/daf2ac80-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7336-3932\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a42d8660-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a42d8660-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5509-8899\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/da64be50-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/da64be50-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7167-7321\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a40656d0-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a40656d0-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9736-8316\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/daba4880-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/daba4880-49b9-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IDO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"4.0 Proposed DIS November 2024"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":249.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5991},"I40KG":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://i40-tools.github.io/I40KG/docs/index.html"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/i40-Tools/I40KG","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"I40KG","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Industry 4.0 Knowledge Graph represents standards, organizations, and frameworks for the Industry 4.0 area (aligned with RAMI 4.0).","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/i40-Tools/I40KG/master/i40kg.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Industry 4.0 Knowledge Graph","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/I40KG/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:59:06.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=I40KG&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/I40KG/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/I40KG/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/I40KG/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=I40KG&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/I40KG/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/I40KG/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/I40KG","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://i40-tools.github.io/I40KG/docs/index.html","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://i40-tools.github.io/I40KG/docs/index.html"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/I40KG/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Steffen Lohmann"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/I40KG/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3085},"CIF":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/emmo-repo/domain-crystallography/master/crystallography.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/emmo-repo/CIF-ontology","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CIF","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"EMMO-aligned domain ontology for Crystallographic Information Framework (CIF) data mappings.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/emmo-repo/domain-crystallography/master/crystallography.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Crystallographic Information Framework Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CIF/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:36:23.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CIF&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CIF/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CIF/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CIF/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=CIF&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CIF/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CIF/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/CIF","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/emmo-repo/domain-crystallography/master/crystallography.ttl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/emmo-repo/domain-crystallography/master/crystallography.ttl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CIF/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"EMMO Crystallography Working Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/CIF/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"master"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3110},"BFO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ifomis.org/bfo/1.1"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://ifomis.uni-saarland.de/bfo/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BFO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/BFO-Ontology/BFO","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/BFO-Ontology/BFO/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Basic Formal Ontology (BFO) is a small, upper-level ontology that is designed to support integration of data across scientific domains.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BFO-Ontology/BFO/master/bfo.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Basic Formal Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Institute for Formal Ontology and Medical Information Science (IFOMIS)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/7958d520-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/7958d520-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"38","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BFO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T18:12:09.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"http://ifomis.uni-saarland.de/bfo/\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BFO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BFO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BFO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BFO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BFO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BFO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BFO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BFO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"5"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ifomis.org/bfo/1.1","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ifomis.org/bfo/1.1"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BFO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"5"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Robert Arp"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Holger Stenzhorn\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/786c9db0-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/786c9db0-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Andrew Spear\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/78f16cd0-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/78f16cd0-edb7-013e-0333-3e88a3ad1c91\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alan Ruttenberg\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bbe72990-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bbe72990-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Pierre Grenon\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bc15f890-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bc15f890-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BFO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":258.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5983},"DINEN62264":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-DINEN62264-2/master/DINEN62264.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/hsu-aut/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DINEN62264","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern representing enterprise-control integration (ISA-95) based on DIN EN 62264.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-DINEN62264-2/master/DINEN62264.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"DIN EN 62264 Enterprise Integration ODP","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DINEN62264/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:47:25.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DINEN62264&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DINEN62264/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DINEN62264/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DINEN62264/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DINEN62264&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DINEN62264/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DINEN62264/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DINEN62264","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-DINEN62264-2/master/DINEN62264.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-DINEN62264-2/master/DINEN62264.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DINEN62264/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Automatik / Standards Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DINEN62264/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3041},"ISA88":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-ISA88.01/master/ISA-88.01.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/hsu-aut/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ISA88","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern representing batch control models based on the ISA-88 standard.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-ISA88.01/master/ISA-88.01.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"ISA 88 Batch Control ODP","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISA88/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:47:28.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ISA88&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISA88/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISA88/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISA88/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ISA88&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISA88/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISA88/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/ISA88","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-ISA88.01/master/ISA-88.01.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-ISA88.01/master/ISA-88.01.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISA88/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Automatik / Standards Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISA88/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3019},"ISO22400":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-ISO22400-2/master/ISO22400-2.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/hsu-aut/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ISO22400","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern representing manufacturing operations KPIs based on ISO 22400.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-ISO22400-2/master/ISO22400-2.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"ISO 22400 MOM Key Performance Indicators ODP","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISO22400/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:47:31.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ISO22400&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISO22400/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISO22400/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISO22400/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ISO22400&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISO22400/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISO22400/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/ISO22400","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-ISO22400-2/master/ISO22400-2.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-ISO22400-2/master/ISO22400-2.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISO22400/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Automatik / Standards Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ISO22400/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3036},"VDI2206":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDI2206/master/VDI2206.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/hsu-aut/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"VDI2206","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern for designing mechatronic systems based on VDI 2206 guideline.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDI2206/master/VDI2206.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"VDI 2206 Mechatronic Design ODP","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI2206/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:47:34.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=VDI2206&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI2206/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI2206/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI2206/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=VDI2206&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI2206/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI2206/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/VDI2206","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDI2206/master/VDI2206.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDI2206/master/VDI2206.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI2206/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Automatik / Standards Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI2206/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2933},"VDI3682":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDI3682/master/VDI3682.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/hsu-aut/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"VDI3682","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern for formalized process descriptions based on VDI 3682 guideline.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDI3682/master/VDI3682.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"VDI 3682 Process Description ODP","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI3682/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:47:39.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=VDI3682&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI3682/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI3682/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI3682/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=VDI3682&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI3682/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI3682/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/VDI3682","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDI3682/master/VDI3682.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-VDI3682/master/VDI3682.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI3682/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Automatik / Standards Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VDI3682/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2906},"WADL-ODP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-WADL/master/WADL.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/hsu-aut/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"WADL-ODP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern representing Web Application Description Language (WADL) specifications.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-WADL/master/WADL.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"WADL ODP","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WADL-ODP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:47:42.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=WADL-ODP&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WADL-ODP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WADL-ODP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WADL-ODP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=WADL-ODP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WADL-ODP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WADL-ODP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/WADL-ODP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-WADL/master/WADL.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-WADL/master/WADL.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WADL-ODP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Automatik / Standards Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WADL-ODP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2962},"OPCUA":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-OPC-UA/master/OpcUa.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/hsu-aut/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"OPCUA","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology design pattern representing OPC Unified Architecture nodesets and semantic structures.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-OPC-UA/master/OpcUa.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"OPC UA NodeSet ODP","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPCUA/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:47:45.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OPCUA&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPCUA/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPCUA/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPCUA/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OPCUA&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPCUA/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPCUA/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/OPCUA","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-OPC-UA/master/OpcUa.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hsu-aut/IndustrialStandard-ODP-OPC-UA/master/OpcUa.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPCUA/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Automatik / Standards Group"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPCUA/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3021},"AMPO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/CharlieJackson15/Aircraft-Maintenance-Process-Ontology/master/aircraft-maintenance-process-ontology.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/CharlieJackson15/Aircraft-Maintenance-Process-Ontology","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"AMPO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"An ontology of aircraft maintenance processes for knowledge conceptualization and reuse.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/CharlieJackson15/Aircraft-Maintenance-Process-Ontology/master/aircraft-maintenance-process-ontology.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Aircraft Maintenance Process Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMPO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:55:58.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=AMPO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMPO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMPO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMPO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=AMPO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMPO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMPO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/AMPO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/CharlieJackson15/Aircraft-Maintenance-Process-Ontology/master/aircraft-maintenance-process-ontology.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/CharlieJackson15/Aircraft-Maintenance-Process-Ontology/master/aircraft-maintenance-process-ontology.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMPO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Charlie Jackson"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/AMPO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2953},"OPMAD":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/jjmj128/OPMAD/main/OPMAD.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/jjmj128/OPMAD","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"OPMAD","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"BFO/CCO-aligned ontology model for predictive maintenance architecture and design.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/jjmj128/OPMAD/main/OPMAD.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Ontology for Predictive Maintenance Architecture and Design","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPMAD/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T01:56:02.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OPMAD&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPMAD/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPMAD/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPMAD/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OPMAD&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPMAD/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPMAD/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/OPMAD","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/jjmj128/OPMAD/main/OPMAD.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/jjmj128/OPMAD/main/OPMAD.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":113.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPMAD/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Juan Montero-Jimenez"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OPMAD/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.0,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2969},"SMPDO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/SMPDO"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/SMPDO/0.1/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/huanyu-li/SMPDO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SMPDO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/huanyu-li/SMPDO","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/huanyu-li/SMPDO/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology for formulations, computing models, virtual experiments, and descriptors in materials and product-development workflows.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/huanyu-li/SMPDO/main/smpdo.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"SIMAGORA Materials and Product Development Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"32","omv:numberOfProperties":"29","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMPDO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"11"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T17:16:51.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2022-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://github.com/huanyu-li/SMPDO\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SMPDO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMPDO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMPDO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"5","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMPDO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SMPDO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"30","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMPDO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMPDO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SMPDO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"17"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/SMPDO","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/SMPDO"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMPDO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://github.com/huanyu-li/SMPDO/blob/main/LICENSE","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://github.com/huanyu-li/SMPDO/blob/main/LICENSE"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Huanyu Li"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Huanyu Li\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/efd32f80-4961-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/efd32f80-4961-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Huanyu Li\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/f0704cb0-4961-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/f0704cb0-4961-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SMPDO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/chemistry, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/nfdimatwerk]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":9308},"BIMMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":3.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org//bimmo.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":2.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org//bimme/releases/2025-09-22/bimmo.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":17.0,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://obofoundry.org/ontology/bimmo","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BIMMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/HosseinBeygiNasrabadi/Bio-inspired-meta-materials-ontology-bimmo","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/HosseinBeygiNasrabadi/Bio-inspired-meta-materials-ontology-bimmo/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Bio-inspired Meta Materials Ontology (BIMMO) models structural, mechanical, and fabrication properties of bio-inspired metamaterials, aligned with PMD Core., None","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/HosseinBeygiNasrabadi/Bio-inspired-meta-materials-ontology-bimmo/main/bimmo.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Bio-inspired Meta Materials Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"846","omv:numberOfProperties":"67","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"49"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T17:16:52.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"4","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"http://obofoundry.org/ontology/bimmo\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIMMO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"39","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BIMMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"10","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BIMMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"77"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org//bimmo.ttl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org//bimmo.ttl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/unspecified","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"11"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/unspecified"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Alexandru Todor"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BIMMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2025-09-22"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/nfdimatwerk]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":36.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":231.0,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5174},"POLYINFO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://dice.nims.go.jp/ontology/PoLyInfo-ont/Schema#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://doi.org/10.48505/nims.5395","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"POLYINFO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://materiage.org/pli/","doap:bugDatabase":"https://doi.org/10.48505/nims.5395","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"NIMS Polymer Database PoLyInfo Ontology. Summarizes the concept classes, predicates, instances necessary for machine-readable representation of polymer knowledge., The PoLyInfo ontology that provides the vocabulary needed to describe polymeric data in RDF.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://mdr.nims.go.jp/filesets/c9991881-046f-4cd5-83b5-890ff03f9a17/download","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"PoLyInfo Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"3706","omv:numberOfProperties":"285","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/POLYINFO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"1212"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T17:16:55.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"6","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.1080/27660400.2024.2354651\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=POLYINFO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The PoLyInfo Ontology, Schema\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/POLYINFO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/POLYINFO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"434","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/POLYINFO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=POLYINFO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1960","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/POLYINFO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/POLYINFO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/POLYINFO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"118"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://dice.nims.go.jp/ontology/PoLyInfo-ont/Schema#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://dice.nims.go.jp/ontology/PoLyInfo-ont/Schema#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/iao.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/uo.owl, http://semanticscience.org/ontology/sio.owl, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/iao.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/uo.owl, http://semanticscience.org/ontology/sio.owl, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/POLYINFO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"13"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Masashi Ishii"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Koichi Sakamoto and Masashi Ishii\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/755862d0-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/755862d0-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/POLYINFO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":47.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7890},"MATSCI":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://growgraph.dev/ontologies/matsci-ontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://growgraph.dev/ontologies/matsci-ontology/1.2.3"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/NAS-Lund/matsci-perovskite-ontologies","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MATSCI","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/NAS-Lund/matsci-perovskite-ontologies","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/NAS-Lund/matsci-perovskite-ontologies/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A general materials-science ontology containing concepts and relations reusable across materials-science domains.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/NAS-Lund/matsci-perovskite-ontologies/main/matsci-ontology.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Materials Science Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"346","omv:numberOfProperties":"159","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MATSCI/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"4085"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T17:16:54.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://github.com/NAS-Lund/matsci-perovskite-ontologies\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MATSCI&q=","schema:comment":"[\"General materials-science ontology split from perovOntology. It contains concepts and relations reusable across materials-science domains, not only for perovskites.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MATSCI/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MATSCI/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"26","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MATSCI/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MATSCI&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"78","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MATSCI/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MATSCI/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MATSCI","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"61"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://growgraph.dev/ontologies/matsci-ontology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://growgraph.dev/ontologies/matsci-ontology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/, http://www.w3.org/ns/ssn/, http://qudt.org/2.1/vocab/prefix, http://qudt.org/2.1/vocab/quantitykind, http://qudt.org/2.1/vocab/sou, http://spinrdf.org/sp, http://spinrdf.org/spin, http://spinrdf.org/spl, http://qudt.org/2.1/schema/extensions/functions, http://qudt.org/2.1/schema/facade/qudt, http://qudt.org/2.1/vocab/dimensionvector]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/, http://www.w3.org/ns/ssn/, http://qudt.org/2.1/vocab/prefix, http://qudt.org/2.1/vocab/quantitykind, http://qudt.org/2.1/vocab/sou, http://spinrdf.org/sp, http://spinrdf.org/spin, http://spinrdf.org/spl, http://qudt.org/2.1/schema/extensions/functions, http://qudt.org/2.1/schema/facade/qudt, http://qudt.org/2.1/vocab/dimensionvector]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MATSCI/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"7"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Alexandru Todor"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"growgraph.dev\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/b1a18340-497a-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/b1a18340-497a-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MATSCI/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.2.3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":254.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5741},"PMDCORE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co/2.0.7"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/ISE-FIZKarlsruhe/odps4mse","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PMDCORE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/ISE-FIZKarlsruhe/odps4mse","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/ISE-FIZKarlsruhe/odps4mse/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology Design Patterns for Materials Science and Engineering - PMD Core.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ISE-FIZKarlsruhe/odps4mse/main/Ontologies/pmdcore.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Physical Metallurgy Domain Core Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"214","omv:numberOfProperties":"47","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCORE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"12"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T17:16:54.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2023-12-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://github.com/ISE-FIZKarlsruhe/odps4mse\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PMDCORE&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The PMD Core Ontology (PMDco) is a comprehensive framework for representing knowledge that encompasses fundamental concepts from the domains of materials science and engineering (MSE). The PMDco has been designed as a mid-level ontology to establish a connection between specific MSE application ontologies and the domain neutral concepts found in established top-level ontologies. The primary goal of the PMDco is to promote interoperability between diverse domains. PMDco's class structure is both understandable and extensible, making it an efficient tool for organizing MSE knowledge. It serves as a semantic intermediate layer that unifies MSE knowledge representations, enabling data and metadata to be systematically integrated on key terms within the MSE domain. With PMDco, it is possible to seamlessly trace data generation. The design of PMDco is based on the W3C Provenance Ontology (PROV-O), which provides a standard framework for capturing the generation, derivation, and attribution of resources. By building on this foundation, PMDco facilitates the integration of data from various sources and the creation of complex workflows. In summary, PMDco is a valuable tool for researchers and practitioners in the MSE domains. It provides a common language for representing and sharing knowledge, allowing for efficient collaboration and promoting interoperability between diverse domains. Its design allows for the systematic integration of data and metadata, enabling seamless traceability of data generation. Overall, PMDco is a crucial step towards a unified and comprehensive understanding of the MSE domain. PMDco at GitHub: https://github.com/materialdigital/core-ontology\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCORE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCORE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"16","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCORE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=PMDCORE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"13","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCORE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCORE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/PMDCORE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"45"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/pmd/co"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCORE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"5"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Alexandru Todor"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Markus Schilling\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0ca95420-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0ca95420-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Bernd Bayerlein\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0c83a730-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0c83a730-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jörg Waitelonis\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0ccf3700-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0ccf3700-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Thomas Hanke\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0cf67be0-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0cf67be0-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Henk Birkholz\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0d1c3660-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0d1c3660-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sascha Fliegener\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0d4180f0-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0d4180f0-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4971-3645\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0d673ad0-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0d673ad0-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jannis Grundmann\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0d8e4c60-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0d8e4c60-497b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/PMDCORE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2.0.7"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":249.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6905},"WTBA":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://example.com/wtb/appont"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://example.com/wtb/ver002/appont"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/NCOR-US/WindTurbineProject","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"WTBA","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://github.com/NCOR-US/WindTurbineProject","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/NCOR-US/WindTurbineProject/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Extend product life cycle ontologies developed under CHAMP to answer a particular wind turbine materials select use case.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/NCOR-US/WindTurbineProject/master/src/RDF%20and%20Application%20Ontology%20Files/WTBA.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Wind Turbine Blade Analysis Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"90","omv:numberOfProperties":"19","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WTBA/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T17:16:56.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://github.com/NCOR-US/WindTurbineProject\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=WTBA&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This is an application ontology that is to be used to facilitate a wind turbine analysis.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WTBA/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WTBA/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"14","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WTBA/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=WTBA&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"84","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WTBA/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WTBA/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/WTBA","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"20"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://example.com/wtb/appont","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://example.com/wtb/appont"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WTBA/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"4"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Alexandru Todor"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/WTBA/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.2.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3873},"ECHEM":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/electrochemistry"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/electrochemistry/0.35.0/electrochemistry"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/emmo-repo/domain-electrochemistry","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ECHEM","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/electrochemistry","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://emmo-repo.github.io/domain-electrochemistry/index.html","doap:bugDatabase":"https://github.com/emmo-repo/domain-electrochemistry/issues","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[\"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/electrochemistry/0.34.0/electrochemistry\"]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A domain ontology under EMMO for describing electrochemical systems, materials, methods, and data.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/emmo-repo/domain-electrochemistry/gh-pages/electrochemistry-inferred.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Electrochemistry Domain Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"EMMO\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c17b6ed0-498d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c17b6ed0-498d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"EMMO\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c1b25050-498d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c1b25050-498d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"4272","omv:numberOfProperties":"293","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"echem","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ECHEM/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"16"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:20.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"This reference module contains the core terms for the electrochemistry domain.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"36","dct:created":"2022-11-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[\"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7693664\"]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ECHEM&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ECHEM/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ECHEM/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"276","dct:modified":"2026-06-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ECHEM/download","foaf:logo":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/emmo-repo/domain-electrochemistry/gh-pages/assets/img/fig/png/domain-electrochemistry-logo.png","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ECHEM&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"207","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ECHEM/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ECHEM/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/ECHEM","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"269"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":73.0,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/electrochemistry","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/electrochemistry"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ECHEM/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/electrochemistry/0.34.0/electrochemistry","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[\"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/electrochemistry/0.34.0/electrochemistry\"]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"23"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"Simon Clark"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Simon Clark\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bfac3430-498d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bfac3430-498d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Eibar Flores\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bfd43de0-498d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/bfd43de0-498d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Francesca Lonstad Bleken\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c0a3ad40-498d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c0a3ad40-498d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jesper Friis\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c0da6de0-498d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c0da6de0-498d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Casper Welzel Andersen\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c10084d0-498d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c10084d0-498d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"https://doi.org/10.1109/IEEESTD.2016.7552407\",\"https://doi.org/10.1351/goldbook\",\"https://doi.org/10.1515/pac-2018-0109\",\"https://www.electropedia.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ECHEM/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://w3id.org/emmo/domain/electrochemistry/0.34.0/electrochemistry","owl:versionInfo":"0.35.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/chemistry, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":256.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6699},"IFCOWL":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://standards.buildingsmart.org/IFC/DEV/IFC4/ADD2_TC1/OWL"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IFCOWL","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IFCOWL","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://standards.buildingsmart.org/IFC/DEV/IFC4/ADD2_TC1/OWL","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IFCOWL","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IFCOWL","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Industry Foundation Classes to OWL., OWL ontology for the IFC conceptual data schema and exchange file format for Building Information Model (BIM) data","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IFCOWL/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Industry Foundation Classes to OWL","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1326","omv:numberOfProperties":"1596","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"ifc","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IFCOWL/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"1162"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:22.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"8","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IFCOWL&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Ontology automatically generated from the EXPRESS schema 'IFC4_ADD2_TC1' using the 'IFC-to-RDF' converter developed by Pieter Pauwels (pipauwel.pauwels@ugent.be), based on the earlier versions from Jyrki Oraskari (jyrki.oraskari@aalto.fi) and Davy Van Deursen (davy.vandeursen@ugent.be)\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IFCOWL/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IFCOWL/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"150","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IFCOWL/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IFCOWL&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"1326","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IFCOWL/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IFCOWL/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IFCOWL","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"208"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://standards.buildingsmart.org/IFC/DEV/IFC4/ADD2_TC1/OWL","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://standards.buildingsmart.org/IFC/DEV/IFC4/ADD2_TC1/OWL"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/express, https://w3id.org/list]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/express, https://w3id.org/list]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IFCOWL/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Pieter Pauwels (pipauwel.pauwels@ugent.be)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6b86b940-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6b86b940-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Walter Terkaj  (walter.terkaj@itia.cnr.it)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6bacf3d0-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6bacf3d0-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jakob Beetz (j.beetz@tue.nl)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c6bcab0-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c6bcab0-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Maria Poveda Villalon (mpoveda@fi.upm.es)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c92b800-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c92b800-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Aleksandra Sojic (aleksandra.sojic@itia.cnr.it)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c462d30-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/6c462d30-498b-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IFCOWL/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":253.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6045},"IOF-SCRO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/supplychain/SupplyChainReferenceOntology/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202301/supplychain/SupplyChainReferenceOntology/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IOF-SCRO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IOF-SCRO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IOF-SCRO","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IOF-SCRO","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. IOF Supply Chain Reference Ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IOF-SCRO/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"IOF Supply Chain Reference Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Industrial Ontology Foundry\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ddafc750-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/ddafc750-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"231","omv:numberOfProperties":"166","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-SCRO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:24.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOF-SCRO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-SCRO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-SCRO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"26","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-SCRO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOF-SCRO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"185","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-SCRO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-SCRO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IOF-SCRO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"16"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":72.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/supplychain/SupplyChainReferenceOntology/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/supplychain/SupplyChainReferenceOntology/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/commonstocoremapping/meta/MappingAnnotationVocabularyToCommons/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/commonstocoremapping/MappingCommonsToIOF/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Collections/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Designators/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Identifiers/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/TextDatatype/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/AnnotationVocabulary/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/commonstocoremapping/meta/MappingAnnotationVocabularyToCommons/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/commonstocoremapping/MappingCommonsToIOF/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Collections/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Designators/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/Identifiers/, https://www.omg.org/spec/Commons/TextDatatype/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-SCRO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dcbd9430-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dcbd9430-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2b350ed0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2b350ed0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2c5f25d0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2c5f25d0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dcefab10-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dcefab10-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd40d4c0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd40d4c0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd5721b0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/dd5721b0-1bcf-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Farhad Ameri, Texas State University\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c6f90bb0-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c6f90bb0-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c7344610-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/c7344610-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-SCRO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":39.0,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":249.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7129},"FUNSTEP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.aidimme.es/FurnitureSectorOntology.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/FUNSTEP","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"FUNSTEP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/FUNSTEP","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/FUNSTEP","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Furniture Sector Ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/FUNSTEP/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Furniture Sector Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"875","omv:numberOfProperties":"173","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FUNSTEP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"212"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:28.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=FUNSTEP&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Furniture Sector Ontology leaded by AIDIMME (www.aidimme.es) under funStep© initiative (www.funstep.org). This is licensed by a BSD 3-Clause License and its use requires permission which can be requested at: https://www.aidimme.es/@contacto\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FUNSTEP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FUNSTEP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"6","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FUNSTEP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=FUNSTEP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"709","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FUNSTEP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FUNSTEP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/FUNSTEP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"45"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.aidimme.es/FurnitureSectorOntology.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.aidimme.es/FurnitureSectorOntology.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FUNSTEP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"6"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FUNSTEP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"version 2.5.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":43.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4400},"SEAS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/seas/FlexibilityOntology-1.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/seas/seas-1.1"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SEAS","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SEAS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/seas/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SEAS","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SEAS","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Smart Energy Aware Systems., The main SEAS ontology glues together all of the SEAS modules.\n\n**To cite the SEAS ontologies:**\n\n> Maxime Lefrançois, Planned ETSI SAREF Extensions based on the W3C&OGC SOSA/SSN-compatible SEAS Ontology Patterns. In Proceedings of Workshop on Semantic Interoperability and Standardization in the IoT, SIS-IoT, Amsterdam, Netherlands, July 2017 ([PDF](http://www.maxime-lefrancois.info/docs/Lefrancois-SIS-IoT2017-Planned.pdf) - [BibTex](SEAS-SIS-IoT-2017.bib))\n\n> Maxime Lefrançois, Jarmo Kalaoja, Takoua Ghariani, Antoine Zimmermann, The SEAS Knowledge Model, ITEA2 12004 Smart Energy Aware Systems Deliverable 2.2, Jan 2017 ([PDF](http://www.maxime-lefrancois.info/docs/SEAS-D2_2-SEAS-Knowledge-Model.pdf) - [BibTex](SEAS-D2_2-SEAS-Knowledge-Model.bib))\n\nSEAS ontology modules are organized on top of a core of three main modules:\n\n- the [seas:FeatureOfInterestOntology](https://w3id.org/seas/FeatureOfInterestOntology) describes feature of interests and their properties;\n- the [seas:EvaluationOntology](https://w3id.org/seas/EvaluationOntology) describes evaluations of these properties;\n- the [seas:SystemOntology](https://w3id.org/seas/SystemOntology) describes virtually isolated systems that share connections with other systems;\n\nOn top of the seas:SystemOntology module, various vertical domain ontologies are defined for specific sub classes of systems and why they may be connected:\n\n- the [`seas:AreaOntology`](https://w3id.org/seas/AreaOntology) describes Zone systems:\n    - a zone may be linked by a crossable connection with another zone;\n    - a zone may be a sub-zone of another zone;\n    - zones are quantified in terms of area, population, and humidity.\n- more module descriptions to come soon...\n\nWe furthermore encourage the use of the following external ontologies:\n\n- [the RDFP Presentation ontology](https://w3id.org/rdfp/) describes how RDF graphs can be validated, interpreted from web resource representations, or serialized as resource representations;\n- [the Process Execution Platform ontology](https://w3id.org/pep/) generalizes the core of the [SSN](http://www.w3.org/TR/vocab-ssn/) and the [SAN](https://www.irit.fr/recherches/MELODI/ontologies/SAN.owl) ontologies.\n","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SEAS/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Smart Energy Aware Systems","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"38","omv:numberOfProperties":"65","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"seas","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SEAS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"68"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:29.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SEAS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SEAS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SEAS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SEAS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SEAS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"38","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SEAS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SEAS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SEAS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"38"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":78.0,"normalizedScore":69,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/seas/FlexibilityOntology-1.0","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/seas/FlexibilityOntology-1.0"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"https://w3id.org/seas/FlexibilityOntology-1.0"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"https://w3id.org/seas/FlexibilityOntology-1.0","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SEAS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"https://w3id.org/seas/seas-1.0","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://maxime-lefrancois.info/me#\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/64e2a260-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/64e2a260-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://www.vtt.fi/JarmoKalaoja\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/49d6cbb0-4996-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/49d6cbb0-4996-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SEAS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://w3id.org/seas/seas-1.0","owl:versionInfo":"v1.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":273.0,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7124},"SAREF4ENER":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4ener/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4ener/v1.1.2/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SAREF4ENER","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SAREF4ENER","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4ener/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://www.etsi.org/deliver/etsi_ts/103400_103499/10341001/01.01.02_60/ts_10341001v010102p.pdf","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SAREF4ENER","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. SAREF4ENER: extension for the Energy domain., SAREF4ENER is an extension of SAREF for the Energy domain that was created in collaboration with Energy@Home (http://www.energy-home.it) and EEBus (http://www.eebus.org/en), the major Italy- and Germany-based industry associations, to enable the interconnection of their (different) data models. SAREF4ENER focuses on demand response scenarios, in which customers can offer flexibility to the Smart Grid to manage their smart home devices by means of a Customer Energy Manager (CEM). The CEM is a logical function for optimizing energy consumption and/or production that can reside either in the home gateway or in the cloud. SAREF4ENER is published as an ETSI tecnical specificatoion (ETSI TS 103 410-1).","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/SAREF4ENER/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"SAREF4ENER: extension for the Energy domain","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.etsi.org/\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9e083b00-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9e083b00-4982-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"146","omv:numberOfProperties":"97","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"s4ener","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4ENER/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"30"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:31.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2015-09-04T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SAREF4ENER&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4ENER/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4ENER/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"5","dct:modified":"2016-12-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4ENER/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=SAREF4ENER&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"2","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4ENER/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4ENER/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SAREF4ENER","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"22"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":78.0,"normalizedScore":69,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4ener/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://saref.etsi.org/saref4ener/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"https://saref.etsi.org/core/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"https://saref.etsi.org/core/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4ENER/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://forge.etsi.org/etsi-software-license","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"3"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://forge.etsi.org/etsi-software-license"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.linkedin.com/in/lauradaniele\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e5e944d0-4984-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/e5e944d0-4984-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"https://saref.etsi.org/sources/saref4ener/\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/SAREF4ENER/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.1.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":273.0,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6372},"FALCON":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.falcon.org/ontologies/upper-ontology-concepts"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/FALCON","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"FALCON","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/FALCON","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/FALCON","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. FALCON.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/FALCON/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"FALCON","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"41","omv:numberOfProperties":"40","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FALCON/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:32.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=FALCON&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FALCON/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FALCON/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"1","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FALCON/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=FALCON&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"41","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FALCON/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FALCON/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/FALCON","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"11"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.falcon.org/ontologies/upper-ontology-concepts","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.falcon.org/ontologies/upper-ontology-concepts"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FALCON/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"2"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/FALCON/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":240.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5420},"ROMAIN":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/hedi/ontologies/2018/11/ROMAIN"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/ROMAIN","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ROMAIN","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/ROMAIN","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/ROMAIN","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Reference Ontology for industrial Maintenance.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/ROMAIN/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Reference Ontology for industrial Maintenance","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"1029","omv:numberOfProperties":"221","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ROMAIN/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"246"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:33.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"5","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ROMAIN&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ROMAIN/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ROMAIN/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"85","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ROMAIN/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=ROMAIN&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"43","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ROMAIN/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ROMAIN/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/ROMAIN","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"57"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/hedi/ontologies/2018/11/ROMAIN","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/hedi/ontologies/2018/11/ROMAIN"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/iao.owl, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/ArtifactOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/ExtendedRelationOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/GeospatialOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/InformationEntityOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/TimeOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/UnitsOfMeasureOntology]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/iao.owl, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/ArtifactOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/ExtendedRelationOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/GeospatialOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/InformationEntityOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/TimeOntology, http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/UnitsOfMeasureOntology]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ROMAIN/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"11"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"H. KARRAY, F. AMERI, M.Hodkiewicz , T.Louge\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d7d70510-499d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/d7d70510-499d-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/ROMAIN/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":13,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":249.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5757},"BFO2020":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/BFO-ontology/BFO-2020","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BFO2020","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Basic Formal Ontology 2020 (ISO/IEC 21838-2) core representation.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BFO-ontology/BFO-2020/master/21838-2/owl/bfo-core.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Basic Formal Ontology 2020","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BFO2020/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:29:58.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BFO2020&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BFO2020/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BFO2020/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BFO2020/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BFO2020&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BFO2020/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BFO2020/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BFO2020","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":60.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BFO2020/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"BFO Maintainers"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BFO2020/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":229.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3442},"OBI":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/obi.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/obi/2026-05-08/obi.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://obi-ontology.org/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"OBI","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[\"An ontology for the annotation of biomedical and functional genomics experiments.\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"An integrated ontology for the description of biological and clinical investigations., An ontology for representing biomedical investigations, including study designs, the collection and preparation of the targets of investigation, assays, instrumentation and reagents used, as well as the data generated and the types of analysis performed on the data to reach conclusions, and their documentation.","omv:resourceLocator":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/obi.owl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Ontology for Biomedical Investigations","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"5219","omv:numberOfProperties":"100","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OBI/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"303"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:30:01.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"34","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OBI&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Please cite the OBI consortium http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/obi where traditional citation is called for. However it is adequate that individual terms be attributed simply by use of the identifying PURL for the term, in projects that refer to them.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OBI/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OBI/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"483","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OBI/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=OBI&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"173","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OBI/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OBI/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/OBI","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"331"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":73.0,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/obi.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/obi.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OBI/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"An ontology for the annotation of biomedical and functional genomics experiments.\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"http://www.geneontology.org/formats/oboInOwl#ObsoleteClass","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"15"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.0,"normalizedScore":25,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"OBI Maintainers"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Christian Bolling\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3bfba7e0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3bfba7e0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Daniel Rubin\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3c570110-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3c570110-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Holger Stenzhorn\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3d9284a0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3d9284a0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"James A. Overton\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3db89cc0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3db89cc0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jeffrey Grethe\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3e078060-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3e078060-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jennifer Fostel\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3e2ef300-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3e2ef300-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jessica Turner\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3e57ddc0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3e57ddc0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Kevin Clancy\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3efb9890-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3efb9890-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Larisa Soldatova\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3f22b780-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3f22b780-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Liju Fan\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3f4a5030-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3f4a5030-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Luisa Montecchi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3f71fe40-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3f71fe40-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Matthew Brush\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3f998930-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3f998930-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Matthew Pocock\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3fc18f60-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3fc18f60-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Susanna-Assunta Sansone\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/414d84b0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/414d84b0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Richard Scheuermann\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39ec39e0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39ec39e0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tina Hernandez-Boussard\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a15a8f0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a15a8f0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Bjoern Peters\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a408c80-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a408c80-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Chris Mungall\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a681a70-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a681a70-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lawrence Hunter\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a929130-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3a929130-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Philippe Rocca-Serra\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3ab94100-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3ab94100-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Chris Stoeckert\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3ba89120-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3ba89120-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Dawn Field\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3ca3d2c0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3ca3d2c0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Dirk Derom\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3ccaeb80-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3ccaeb80-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Eric Deutsch\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3cf1d590-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3cf1d590-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Frank Gibson\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3d1aa310-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3d1aa310-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Helen C. Causton\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3d6c9af0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3d6c9af0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jay Greenbaum\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3ddf0cf0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3ddf0cf0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jie Zheng\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3e809b60-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3e809b60-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Joe White\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3ea8e170-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3ea8e170-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"John Westbrook\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3ed3ee70-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3ed3ee70-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melissa Haendel\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3fe880f0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3fe880f0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mervi Heiskanen\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/400e92d0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/400e92d0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Norman Morrison\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/403a8020-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/403a8020-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Phillip Lord\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40617840-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40617840-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Pierre Grenon\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40878da0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40878da0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Richard Bruskiewich\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40afdc00-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40afdc00-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Robert Stevens\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40d78760-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40d78760-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ryan R. Brinkman\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40feb0d0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/40feb0d0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Stefan Wiemann\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/41249be0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/41249be0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tanya Gray\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/4175c3c0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/4175c3c0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Trish Whetzel\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/41a049c0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/41a049c0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yongqun He\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/41c74000-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/41c74000-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alan Ruttenberg\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39246470-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39246470-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Elisabetta Manduchi\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/394d2580-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/394d2580-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Helen Parkinson\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3975e0a0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3975e0a0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"James Malone\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/399c8140-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/399c8140-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melanie Courtot\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39c3d8a0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/39c3d8a0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Monnie McGee\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3ae17c00-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3ae17c00-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Allyson Lister\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3b079950-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3b079950-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Barry Smith\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3b2f1730-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3b2f1730-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Bill Bug\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3b578d40-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3b578d40-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Carlo Torniai\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3b808580-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3b808580-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Chris Taylor\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3bcff930-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3bcff930-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cristian Cocos\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3c258520-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3c258520-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Daniel Schober\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3c7d0cc0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3c7d0cc0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gilberto Fragoso\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3d430590-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/3d430590-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Advisors for this project come from the IFOMIS group, Saarbruecken and from the Co-ODE group in Manchester\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/4256d8d0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/4256d8d0-49b7-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/OBI/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"2026-05-08"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":49.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":264.0,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6877},"VALVE-CORE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.aibel.com/ontology/valve-core"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/PCA-POSC-Caesar-Association/IDO_Use_Case_Valve_Ontology_Public","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"VALVE-CORE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Valve Core Ontology is an industrial domain application ontology based on the Industrial Data Ontology (IDO) for piping, instrumentation, and valves lifecycle modeling., Core ontology for PLM RDL.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/PCA-POSC-Caesar-Association/IDO_Use_Case_Valve_Ontology_Public/main/ontology/valve-core.ttl","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"IDO Valve Core Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://www.posccaesar.org\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a5818c60-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a5818c60-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"263","omv:numberOfProperties":"139","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VALVE-CORE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-14T00:30:11.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"2","dct:created":"2026-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=VALVE-CORE&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Core ontology for PLM RDL.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VALVE-CORE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VALVE-CORE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"22","dct:modified":"2025-04-10T06:15:03.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VALVE-CORE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=VALVE-CORE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"255","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VALVE-CORE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VALVE-CORE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/VALVE-CORE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"31"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.aibel.com/ontology/valve-core","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.aibel.com/ontology/valve-core"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://rds.posccaesar.org/ontology/lis14/ont/core"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://rds.posccaesar.org/ontology/lis14/ont/core","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VALVE-CORE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"9"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"POSC Caesar Association"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8076-7460\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a3e07d90-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a3e07d90-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7336-3932\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a42d8660-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a42d8660-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9888-0557\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a454fc60-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a454fc60-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0009-0005-7491-9049\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a47b4890-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a47b4890-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0009-0009-4048-9465\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a4a3dd50-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a4a3dd50-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0009-0009-4214-0355\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a4c99830-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a4c99830-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7829-7674\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a3ba24e0-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a3ba24e0-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7167-7321\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a40656d0-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/a40656d0-49b8-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/VALVE-CORE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":248.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5626},"REC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/rec/full/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/REC","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"REC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/REC","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/REC","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. RealEstateCore., This ontology imports all RealEstateCore (REC) modules and thus gives the fullest expressivity that REC allows. You can use this ontology as-is, or you can construct your own ontology by importing individual REC modules.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/REC/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"RealEstateCore","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"882","omv:numberOfProperties":"518","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/REC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:20.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"4","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=REC&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/REC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/REC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"51","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/REC/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=REC&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"793","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/REC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/REC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/REC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"72"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/rec/full/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/rec/full/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/REC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Karl Hammar, Erik Wallin\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2945b480-498a-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/2945b480-498a-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/REC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"3.3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":46.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":245.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6472},"DCMATERIALS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Materials"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DCMATERIALS","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DCMATERIALS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Materials","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DCMATERIALS","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DCMATERIALS","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Digital Construction Materials., The Material Ontology defining the main concepts of building material, type and its properties.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/DCMATERIALS/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Digital Construction Materials","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"178","omv:numberOfProperties":"269","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"dicm","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCMATERIALS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"97"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:22.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2021-04-21T16:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DCMATERIALS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCMATERIALS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCMATERIALS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"15","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCMATERIALS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=DCMATERIALS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"48","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCMATERIALS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCMATERIALS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/DCMATERIALS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"14"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Materials","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Materials"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Contexts, https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Entities, https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Variables]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Contexts, https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Entities, https://w3id.org/digitalconstruction/0.5/Variables]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCMATERIALS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Prathap Valluru (prathap.valluru@tu-dresden.de)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/82a11210-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/82a11210-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Janakiram Karlapudi (janakiram.karlapudi@tu-dresden.de)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/82ca66a0-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/82ca66a0-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Seppo Törmä (seppo.torma@visualynk.com)\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/837182c0-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/837182c0-4993-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/DCMATERIALS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.5"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":264.0,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6689},"IFC-PROPS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IFC-PROPS"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IFC-PROPS","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IFC-PROPS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IFC-PROPS","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IFC-PROPS","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. IFC-PROPS.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IFC-PROPS/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"IFC-PROPS","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"34","omv:numberOfProperties":"596","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IFC-PROPS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:24.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"1","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IFC-PROPS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IFC-PROPS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IFC-PROPS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IFC-PROPS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IFC-PROPS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"34","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IFC-PROPS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IFC-PROPS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IFC-PROPS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"34"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IFC-PROPS","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IFC-PROPS"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IFC-PROPS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IFC-PROPS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":240.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4500},"BOT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/bot#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/bot-0.3.2"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BOT","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BOT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/bot#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://www.semantic-web-journal.net/system/files/swj2279.pdf","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BOT","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Building Topology Ontology., The Building Topology Ontology (BOT) is a simple ontology defining the core concepts of a building.\nIt is a simple, easy to extend ontology for the construction industry to document and exchange building data on the web.\nChanges since version 0.2.0 of the ontology are documented in:\nhttps://w3id.org/bot/bot.html#changes\nThe version 0.2.0 of the ontology is documented in:\nMads Holten Rasmussen, Pieter Pauwels, Maxime Lefrançois, Georg Ferdinand Schneider, Christian Anker Hviid and Jan Karlshøj (2017) Recent changes in the Building Topology Ontology, 5th Linked Data in Architecture and Construction Workshop (LDAC2017), November 13-15, 2017, Dijon, France, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/320631574_Recent_changes_in_the_Building_Topology_Ontology\nThe initial version 0.1.0 of the ontology was documented in:\nMads Holten Rasmussen, Christian Anker Hviid and Jan Karlshøj (2017) Proposing a Central AEC Ontology That Allows for Domain Specific Extensions, Lean and Computing in Construction Congress (LC3): Volume I ? Proceedings of the Joint Conference on Computing in Construction (JC3), July 4-7, Heraklion, Greece, pp. 237-244 https://doi.org/10.24928/JC3-2017/0153","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/BOT/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Building Topology Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"10","omv:numberOfProperties":"17","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"bot","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BOT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"5"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:30.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2018-06-21T12:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BOT&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BOT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BOT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"2020-07-31T08:51:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BOT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=BOT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"3","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BOT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BOT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/BOT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"6"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":73.0,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/bot#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/bot#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BOT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"https://w3id.org/bot-0.3.1","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"1"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2033-859X\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/00effbf0-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/00effbf0-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6519-7057\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0116ab20-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0116ab20-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Georg Ferdinand Schneider\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/01463350-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/01463350-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mads Holten Rasmussen\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/016b9930-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/016b9930-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Pieter Pauwels\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/01bbd010-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/01bbd010-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"http://maxime-lefrancois.info/me#\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/64e2a260-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/64e2a260-4986-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8020-4609\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/00c8b570-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/00c8b570-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Maxime Lefrançois\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0192d400-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/0192d400-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"María Poveda-Villalón\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c53f920-4994-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/9c53f920-4994-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ali Kücükavci\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14424ec0-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14424ec0-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ana Roxin\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/146a1fc0-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/146a1fc0-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Edison Chung\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/148f3b20-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/148f3b20-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gonçal Costa\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14b5ebc0-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14b5ebc0-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lars Wikström\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1555c670-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1555c670-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mathias Bonduel\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/157c9820-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/157c9820-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"All contributing members of the W3C Linked Building Data Community Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/15a2d840-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/15a2d840-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Rui Ma\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1616a860-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1616a860-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sjoerd Rongen\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1664a460-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1664a460-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ville Kukkonen\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/168f10b0-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/168f10b0-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Hervé Pruvost\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14dc2130-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14dc2130-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Pouya Zangeneh\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/15c96bd0-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/15c96bd0-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Richard Pinka\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/15efb150-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/15efb150-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Karl Hammar\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14137b20-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/14137b20-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jyrki Oraskari\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/15036630-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/15036630-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Katja Breitenfelder\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/152d6c50-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/152d6c50-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Rui de Klerk\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/163c0040-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/163c0040-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/test1\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Walter Terkaj\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/16b952a0-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/16b952a0-4995-013f-275d-324cff836c6c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/BOT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://w3id.org/bot-0.3.1","owl:versionInfo":"0.3.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":48.0,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":254.0,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7092},"IOF-MAINTENANCE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/maintenance/MaintenanceReferenceOntology/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/202301/maintenance/MaintenanceReferenceOntology/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IOF-MAINTENANCE","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IOF-MAINTENANCE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IOF-MAINTENANCE","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IOF-MAINTENANCE","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. IOF Maintenance Working Group Reference Ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/IOF-MAINTENANCE/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"IOF Maintenance Working Group Reference Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Industrial Ontology Foundry\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/079b32c0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/079b32c0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"128","omv:numberOfProperties":"120","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-MAINTENANCE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:31.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"The purpose of this IOF Maintenance Reference ontology is to support semantic interoperatibility through the use modular ontologies in the maintenance domain. This Ontology contains terms and concepts identified as common in a number of application ontologies for maintenance management, maintenance procedures, asset failure and failure modes and effects analysis. The ontology is aligned with the IOF Core Ontology which is aligned with Basic Formal Ontology and importas terms for other domain independent ontologies.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOF-MAINTENANCE&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-MAINTENANCE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-MAINTENANCE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"17","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-MAINTENANCE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=IOF-MAINTENANCE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"91","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-MAINTENANCE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-MAINTENANCE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/IOF-MAINTENANCE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"15"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":96,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":72.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/maintenance/MaintenanceReferenceOntology/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/maintenance/MaintenanceReferenceOntology/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/Core/, https://spec.industrialontologies.org/ontology/core/meta/AnnotationVocabulary/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-MAINTENANCE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"8"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://opensource.org/licenses/MIT"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"IOF Maintenance Working Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/15ecedf0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/15ecedf0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Melinda Hodkiewicz, University of Western Australia\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1624a5e0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1624a5e0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Markus Stumptner, University of South Australia\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1639fc40-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1639fc40-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Matt Selway, University of South Australia\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/164e5260-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/164e5260-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/users/matadmin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Caitlin Woods, University of Western Australia\",\"id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1662ebb0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@id\":\"https://data.dev.matportal.org/Agents/1662ebb0-1bd0-013f-bacf-326a786ab40c\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/IOF-MAINTENANCE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":39.0,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":249.0,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":7158},"MMSSO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/administrator/ontologies/maintenance/MetaMaintenanceMotionStateSequenceOntology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/MMSSO","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MMSSO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/MMSSO","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/MMSSO","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Maintenance Motion State Sequence Ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/MMSSO/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Maintenance Motion State Sequence Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"78","omv:numberOfProperties":"93","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MMSSO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"79"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:32.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MMSSO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MMSSO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MMSSO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"14","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MMSSO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MMSSO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"46","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MMSSO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MMSSO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MMSSO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"6"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/administrator/ontologies/maintenance/MetaMaintenanceMotionStateSequenceOntology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.semanticweb.org/administrator/ontologies/maintenance/MetaMaintenanceMotionStateSequenceOntology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.0,"normalizedScore":15,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/bfo.owl","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MMSSO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"7"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MMSSO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":245.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3748},"MNT-ACT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://spec.equonto.org/ontology/maintenance-work-management/maintenance-activity-ontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/MNT-ACT","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MNT-ACT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/MNT-ACT","doap:bugDatabase":"http://industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/MNT-ACT","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Discovered from ENIT Portal. Maintenance Activity Ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"https://data.industryportal.enit.fr/ontologies/MNT-ACT/download?apikey=019adb70-1d64-41b7-8f6e-8f7e5eb54942","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"Maintenance Activity Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"19","omv:numberOfProperties":"0","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MNT-ACT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"null","omv:numberOfIndividuals":"0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"null","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2026-06-13T19:15:33.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"0","dct:created":"2026-06-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MNT-ACT&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MNT-ACT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MNT-ACT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"0","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MNT-ACT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/search?ontologies=MNT-ACT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"17","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MNT-ACT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MNT-ACT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/MNT-ACT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":"8"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome][OBO Foundry, Agrisemantics, FAIRsharing, ROMULUS, DAML Ontology Library, Colore, BARTOC, TaxoBank, LusTRE, LOV4IoT, VOCAB OEG, LiveSchema, Protege Ontology Library]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.[NCBO BioPortal, AgroPortal, SIFR BioPortal, EBI OLS, Ontobee, OntoHub, AberOWL, LOV, ONKI Ontology Library Service, MMI ORR, ESIP COR, LifeWatch EcoPortal, MatPortal, MedPortal, CISMeF HeTOP, FINTO, ANDC RVA, NVS, GFBIO TS, Loterre, Caliper, Crop Ontology Curation Tool, Planteome]","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://spec.equonto.org/ontology/maintenance-work-management/maintenance-activity-ontology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://spec.equonto.org/ontology/maintenance-work-management/maintenance-activity-ontology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[\"http://sparql.bioontology.org\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"null","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MNT-ACT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":35.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":"0"},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"ENIT IndustryPortal Admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.dev.matportal.org/ontologies/MNT-ACT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":2.0,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/iof, https://data.dev.matportal.org/groups/materialdigital]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":41.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":240.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":3974}},"combinedScores":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":8.89,"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}],"properties":["owl:ontologyIRI"],"state":{"success":251,"average":3,"fail":1}},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.07,"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}],"properties":["dct:identifier"],"state":{"success":0,"average":3,"fail":252}},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}],"state":{"success":255,"average":0,"fail":0}},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":2.2,"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}],"properties":["owl:versionIRI"],"state":{"success":24,"average":88,"fail":143}}},"score":23.17,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":11.82,"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}],"properties":["omv:knownUsage","foaf:homepage","void:uriRegexPattern","omv:acronym","vann:preferredNamespaceUri","dct:subject","dct:coverage","dct:audience","foaf:page","doap:bugDatabase","skos:hiddenLabel","idot:exampleIdentifier","door:comesFromTheSameDomain","owl:backwardCompatibleWith","vann:example","mod:hasEvaluation","dct:alternative","doap:mailing-list","dct:description","omv:resourceLocator","omv:keywords","dct:title","dct:publisher","doap:repository"],"state":{"success":39,"average":216,"fail":0}},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.66,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}],"properties":["omv:numberOfClasses","omv:numberOfProperties","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix","mod:metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms","omv:numberOfIndividuals"],"state":{"success":40,"average":215,"fail":0}},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":6.99,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}],"properties":["dct:hasPart","omv:isOfType","omv:keyClasses","dct:dateSubmitted","dct:abstract","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children","dct:created","dct:bibliographicCitation","pav:curatedOn","foaf:depiction","void:openSearchDescription","schema:comment","void:propertyPartition","dct:valid","void:classPartition","mod:classesWithOneChild","dct:modified","void:dataDump","foaf:logo","void:uriLookupEndpoint","door:hasDisparateModelling","mod:classesWithNoDefinition","schema:associatedMedia","schema:workTranslation","voaf:usedBy","dct:language","mod:analytics","owl:incompatibleWith","void:rootResource","mod:browsingUI","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith","schema:award","voaf:toDoList","mod:maxChildCount"],"state":{"success":254,"average":1,"fail":0}}},"score":21.47,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}],"state":{"success":255,"average":0,"fail":0}},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}],"state":{"success":255,"average":0,"fail":0}}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}],"properties":["schema:includedInDataCatalog"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}],"properties":["schema:includedInDataCatalog"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":65.64,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":2.19,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}],"properties":["owl:ontologyIRI","dct:identifier"],"state":{"success":93,"average":0,"fail":162}},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}],"state":{"success":255,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":17.22,"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}],"properties":["owl:ontologyIRI"],"state":{"success":47,"average":208,"fail":0}},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":5.98,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}],"properties":["sd:endpoint"],"state":{"success":254,"average":0,"fail":1}}},"score":32.39,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}],"state":{"success":255,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}],"state":{"success":255,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}],"state":{"success":255,"average":0,"fail":0}}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}],"state":{"success":255,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}],"state":{"success":255,"average":0,"fail":0}}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}],"state":{"success":255,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}],"state":{"success":255,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}],"state":{"success":255,"average":0,"fail":0}},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":3.98,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}],"properties":["owl:deprecated","omv:status"],"state":{"success":254,"average":0,"fail":1}}},"score":19.98,"normalizedScore":99,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":102.37,"normalizedScore":90,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":17.82,"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}],"properties":["omv:hasOntologyLanguage"],"state":{"success":251,"average":2,"fail":2}},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":9.88,"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}],"properties":["omv:hasOntologyLanguage"],"state":{"success":252,"average":0,"fail":3}},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":0.06,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}],"properties":["omv:hasOntologySyntax"],"state":{"success":3,"average":0,"fail":252}},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}],"properties":["omv:hasFormalityLevel"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}],"properties":["dct:hasFormat","dct:isFormatOf"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}}},"score":27.76,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":1.73,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}],"properties":["owl:imports"],"state":{"success":88,"average":0,"fail":167}},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.02,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}],"properties":["dct:relation"],"state":{"success":1,"average":0,"fail":254}},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}],"properties":["voaf:hasEquivalencesWith"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}],"properties":["schema:translationOfWork","voaf:generalizes","voaf:specializes","voaf:similar","dct:isPartOf"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}],"properties":["voaf:metadataVoc"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}}},"score":1.75,"normalizedScore":5,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":6.97,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}],"properties":["dct:hasPart","owl:imports","mod:obsoleteProperty","mod:synonymProperty","omv:hasOntologySyntax","dct:isPartOf","door:comesFromTheSameDomain","mod:prefLabelProperty","dct:relation","dct:hasVersion","voaf:specializes","schema:translationOfWork","voaf:generalizes","door:hasDisparateModelling","mod:hierarchyProperty","owl:priorVersion","dct:subject","dct:isFormatOf","schema:workTranslation","voaf:usedBy","omv:hasFormalityLevel","dct:license","owl:backwardCompatibleWith","mod:definitionProperty","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith","owl:incompatibleWith","mod:authorProperty","dct:hasFormat","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith","voaf:similar"],"state":{"success":254,"average":0,"fail":1}}},"score":6.97,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":36.48,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":4.98,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}],"properties":["mod:definitionProperty","mod:prefLabelProperty","mod:authorProperty","mod:obsoleteProperty","mod:synonymProperty"],"state":{"success":254,"average":0,"fail":1}},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.78,"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}],"properties":["mod:obsoleteParent","mod:hierarchyProperty","mod:maxDepth"],"state":{"success":12,"average":242,"fail":1}},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}}},"score":6.76,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":7.81,"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}],"properties":["dct:license"],"state":{"success":112,"average":39,"fail":104}},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":3.98,"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}],"properties":["dct:accessRights","cc:morePermissions"],"state":{"success":0,"average":254,"fail":1}},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":6.97,"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}],"properties":["cc:useGuidelines","dct:rightsHolder"],"state":{"success":0,"average":254,"fail":1}}},"score":18.77,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":2.15,"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}],"properties":["schema:translator","dct:creator","dct:contributor","pav:curatedBy"],"state":{"success":0,"average":137,"fail":118}},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.09,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}],"properties":["prov:wasGeneratedBy","prov:wasInvalidatedBy","dct:source"],"state":{"success":0,"average":11,"fail":244}},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}],"properties":["dct:accrualPolicy","dct:accrualMethod","dct:accrualPeriodicity"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":3.35,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}],"properties":["dct:hasVersion","owl:priorVersion","owl:versionInfo"],"state":{"success":172,"average":83,"fail":0}},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.01,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}],"properties":["omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology"],"state":{"success":0,"average":1,"fail":254}},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.01,"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}],"properties":["omv:designedForOntologyTask","mod:competencyQuestion"],"state":{"success":0,"average":1,"fail":254}},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}],"properties":["foaf:fundedBy"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}}},"score":5.6,"normalizedScore":14,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":1.67,"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}],"properties":["mod:ontologyInUse","omv:endorsedBy"],"state":{"success":0,"average":85,"fail":170}},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}],"properties":["mod:group"],"state":{"success":0,"average":0,"fail":255}},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":5.88,"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}],"properties":["dct:accessRights"],"state":{"success":250,"average":0,"fail":5}}},"score":7.55,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":38.69,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":243.18,"minScore":131.0,"maxScore":282.0,"medianScore":245.0,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0},"status":{"request":"http://dev.matportal.org:80/fairness-assessment/?combined=true&ontologies=all&portal=matportal","success":true,"executionTime":248,"endpoint":"http://matportal-api:9393","useCache":true}}